Miruvor
Sign up

Beef organ supplements (Heart & Soil)

How it went for everyone who tried it

Helped means they said it helped with what they took it for, which may be one symptom and not the illness.

82%
helped
9 of 11
9%
no change
1 of 11
9%
got worse
1 of 11

Shares are out of the 11 people who said how it went. 2 more tried it without saying how it went overall; 2 of them describe a problem.

How it wentPeopleShare
Helped a lot19%
Helped873%
No change19%
Worse19%
Much worse00%
Where it was reportedHelpedSaid how it went
Reddit810
Recovery stories11

Did it last, for everyone it helped?

  • None of the 9 people it helped said it wore off, whether or not they credit it for their improvement.

Ask about this treatment

Among the 5 who credit it with their improvement, here’s how they are now

Credit it means they say it’s one reason they got better: 5 say it was one of several things that helped.

20%
recovered or near normal
1 of 5
40%
much or somewhat better
2 of 5
40%
relapsed
2 of 5

Where each person was at the end of their story, or in their latest post that says how they are, compared with their worst point.

Outcome describedPeopleShare
Recovered00%
Near normal120%
Much better120%
Somewhat better120%
Relapsed240%

Did it last?

  • No one said its benefit wore off.
  • 2 of the 5 who credit it say they still need to keep doing something (not always this) to stay well.

By how ill people were

Only the 5 who credit it, so people it didn’t help or made worse aren’t here. How they are now is their outcome overall, not the effect of this one treatment.

Severity at worstHow they are nownRecovered or near normal
Mild250%, few people
Severe10%, few people
Very severe20%, few people
At worstOutcomePeopleShare
MildNear normal1 of 250%
MildSomewhat better1 of 250%
SevereRelapsed1 of 1100%
Very severeMuch better1 of 250%
Very severeRelapsed1 of 250%

Adverse events

What people said went wrong, in their own words.

3 of 13

people who wrote about taking it described a problem they tied to it

Described one · 3Didn’t mention one · 10

The serious kinds

Worth telling a doctor about straight away.

  • Mood or psychiatric effects

    2 people
    “I tried taking ancestral supplements, but had to stop I tried twice both times on the 3rd day I’d have crushing anxiety and all sorts of issues”
    — Fox 75333
    “I am actually experimenting with beef organs, and I am experiencing definite overmethylation from it.”
    — sflorence

The serious kinds are a death, suicidal thoughts or an attempt, a hospital stay, an ER visit, an allergic reaction or anaphylaxis, heart rhythm, liver or kidney, blood count, mood or psychiatric, or refeeding or deficiency problems, and being made much worse: a large worsening such as a crash lasting weeks or more.

Other kinds

Unpleasant effects people tied to it, the most serious first.

Made symptoms worse · 1 ShowHide
  • Made symptoms worse

    1 person
    “I am able to take freeze dried beef organs 2 -3 times a week and can't tolerate them taken daily even in small doses.”
    — Grove 55771

How often it comes up

Posts that mention Beef organ supplements (Heart & Soil), per 1,000 posts each month. Hover or tap a point for the count.

0201020142017202020232026
MonthPosts mentioning itAll postsPer 1,000
Oct 200901050
Jan 201001410
Feb 201001130
Jun 201101090
Nov 201101240
Dec 201101990
Jan 201202320
Feb 201201030
Mar 201201900
Apr 201201620
May 201203750
Jun 201202380
Jul 201202400
Aug 201204850
Sep 201205610
Oct 201205260
Nov 201205140
Dec 201206990
Jan 201305330
Feb 201304470
Mar 201304290
Apr 201304990
May 201306060
Jun 201306090
Jul 201306160
Aug 201305770
Sep 201303640
Oct 201305360
Nov 201303850
Dec 201305190
Jan 201409440
Feb 201408210
Mar 201404250
Apr 201403610
May 201406170
Jun 201404890
Jul 201404440
Aug 201406220
Sep 201405070
Oct 201406780
Nov 201405670
Dec 201406290
Jan 201507600
Feb 201508730
Mar 201501,2760
Apr 201509840
May 201501,4960
Jun 201501,0460
Jul 201501,2110
Aug 201509980
Sep 201501,0600
Oct 201501,2550
Nov 201501,2460
Dec 201509240
Jan 201601,2820
Feb 201601,0510
Mar 201601,0020
Apr 201609980
May 201601,0450
Jun 201601,2300
Jul 201601,6190
Aug 201601,7290
Sep 201601,7850
Oct 201601,2200
Nov 201601,0920
Dec 201601,2110
Jan 201701,6600
Feb 201701,9880
Mar 201702,0780
Apr 201702,1330
May 201702,3700
Jun 201702,1940
Jul 201702,1830
Aug 201702,4660
Sep 201702,1890
Oct 201703,0420
Nov 201701,9760
Dec 201702,1120
Jan 201802,6200
Feb 201802,1550
Mar 201802,6130
Apr 201802,2510
May 201802,8280
Jun 201803,8710
Jul 201803,0670
Aug 201803,7570
Sep 201803,5120
Oct 201803,2610
Nov 201802,8610
Dec 201802,7540
Jan 201903,6720
Feb 201902,7150
Mar 201903,3170
Apr 201903,1410
May 201913,8550.26
Jun 201903,3920
Jul 201903,3120
Aug 201903,9430
Sep 201904,0350
Oct 201903,9220
Nov 201903,5080
Dec 201903,6590
Jan 202004,6500
Feb 202004,3740
Mar 202004,4750
Apr 202003,6900
May 202004,5430
Jun 202005,7010
Jul 202006,1040
Aug 2020110,3330.10
Sep 2020011,9580
Oct 2020614,5680.41
Nov 2020416,5460.24
Dec 2020320,7640.14
Jan 2021324,5620.12
Feb 2021024,6720
Mar 2021129,4760.03
Apr 2021028,5090
May 2021025,7910
Jun 2021127,8710.04
Jul 2021127,2200.04
Aug 2021030,8080
Sep 2021030,0740
Oct 2021222,1320.09
Nov 2021027,7220
Dec 2021231,8720.06
Jan 2022142,3170.02
Feb 2022438,6970.10
Mar 2022144,3050.02
Apr 2022344,3330.07
May 2022350,5940.06
Jun 2022349,0580.06
Jul 2022653,4850.11
Aug 2022354,4550.06
Sep 2022656,9360.11
Oct 2022758,5110.12
Nov 2022859,1980.14
Dec 2022161,5760.02
Jan 2023161,0040.02
Feb 2023050,1330
Mar 2023259,9250.03
Apr 2023154,2510.02
May 2023557,7680.09
Jun 2023052,6790
Jul 2023356,4010.05
Aug 2023465,4350.06
Sep 2023761,8350.11
Oct 2023158,4190.02
Nov 2023153,6620.02
Dec 2023160,6430.02
Jan 2024071,8180
Feb 2024070,0450
Mar 2024168,2610.01
Apr 2024364,3740.05
May 2024367,6980.04
Jun 2024164,7200.02
Jul 2024165,3350.02
Aug 2024168,5170.01
Sep 2024970,1680.13
Oct 2024172,6070.01
Nov 2024071,8020
Dec 2024174,4010.01
Jan 2025077,9090
Feb 2025065,1100
Mar 2025269,9050.03
Apr 20251561,6060.24
May 2025165,7330.02
Jun 2025260,5400.03
Jul 2025162,1050.02
Aug 2025164,5780.02
Sep 2025261,7040.03
Oct 2025059,2040
Nov 2025358,9440.05
Dec 2025162,8300.02
Jan 2026063,3210
Feb 2026053,0850
Mar 2026159,2080.02
Apr 2026153,9890.02
May 2026157,5410.02
Jun 2026155,3010.02
Jul 2026056,3910
Aug 2026056,8250
Sep 2026057,1430

Forum and Reddit posts, 4,007,898 in all, counted per month. A mention means the post names the treatment, not that the writer took it. All trends

All 13 people who tried it

  • sunshine44 on Phoenix Rising

    Relapsed ME/CFS Very severe at worstIll 18 years before improving forums.phoenixrising.me May 2026

    sunshine44 fell ill in 2008 after a year of ibuprofen and PPIs and was fully bedridden by 2018 with ME/CFS, POTS, mast cell reactions and vertigo. Nearly every supplement and drug made her worse; a 2018 supplement crash left her 90-95% bedridden. Neural…

  • Long COVID with chest pain and brain fog, nearly back to normal after colchicine and diet

    Near normal Kite 81190 Long COVID Mild at worstIll 4 years before improving or writing reddit.com Nov 2025

    Kite 81190 fell ill after COVID vaccination in early 2021: flu-like PEM after work, chest pain, palpitations, brain fog, tinnitus, and later pericarditis. A week of valacyclovir was followed by no major PEM flares, though they couldn't prove causation.…

  • ME/CFS that meant giving up work, somewhat better with a PEMF mat and supplements

    Somewhat better Beacon 64558 ME/CFS Mild at worstIll 12 years before improving or writing reddit.com Aug 2025

    This user developed CFS in 2013 at age 21 after a viral infection and a reaction to Cipro, and had to give up a job. Fighting the fatigue led to opiate addiction; they made progress in both, then COVID added MCAS and histamine problems and a relapse on…

  • Long COVID with brain fog and exhaustion; improved on vaccines, nattokinase, then set back

    Relapsed Otter 40561 Long COVID Severe at worstIll 4 years before improving or writing reddit.com Jan 2024

    Otter 40561 got COVID in January 2020 and was ill for four years, with breathing problems, brain fog, exhaustion, palpitations and fevers, working full time from home throughout. Pfizer vaccines and supplements, especially nattokinase, brought clear…

  • Bedbound with ME/CFS, now much better and housebound after an animal-based carnivore diet

    Much better Starling 98420 ME/CFS Very severe at worst reddit.com Mar 2022

    Starling 98420, in their early thirties in Europe, has ME/CFS, POTS and fibromyalgia; after overwork and a low-dose naltrexone trial in March 2021 they were bedbound and unable to eat for months. An animal-based carnivore diet begun in mid-2021 took them…

  • Bedridden with long COVID, now nearly back to normal after steroids and antihistamines

    Near normal Doesn’t credit it · HelpedCove 97470 Long COVID Severe at worstIll 18 months before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Cove 97470 caught COVID in March 2020 and was still bedridden at three months with breathlessness, severe asthma and chest pressure; these respiratory symptoms mostly resolved by about five to six months, when vertigo, brain fog, headaches, tinnitus and eye…

  • ME/CFS: chronic fatigue and pain; bedridden after too-high levothyroxine

    Outcome unclear Doesn’t credit it · Not saidGrove 55771 ME/CFS Severe at worst reddit.com Sep 2026

    They reported chronic fatigue and pain for many years without a diagnosis, in line with CFS and fibromyalgia, and sensitivity to most daily supplements; vitamin D and magnesium at night were tolerated. Sleeping more than eight hours or too little both made…

  • ME/CFS: months of light and phone intolerance, somewhat better on high-fruit salted diet

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · HelpedBadger 43913 ME/CFS Very severe at worst reddit.com May 2026

    Badger 43913 said they had had POTS and dysautonomia their whole life, with spells lasting months when they could not tolerate even a little light or hold their phone because of migraine and pain. A diet very high in hydrating fruit, lettuce and salted salad…

  • Long COVID with a pounding pulse after lunch linked to carbs; Ancestral Supplements tried

    Outcome unclear Doesn’t credit it · WorseFox 75333 Long COVID reddit.com Dec 2025

    Fox 75333 linked a pounding or bounding pulse after lunch to carbs, noting they haven't noticed it when eating clean after going carnivore. They tried Ancestral Supplements but stopped twice on the third day due to crushing anxiety and other issues; they…

  • Unable to work with long COVID, now nearly back to normal after rest and diet

    Near normal Doesn’t credit it · HelpedComet 64334 Long COVID Severe at worstIll 6 months before improving or writing reddit.com May 2025

    Comet 64334 caught COVID in March 2021 and spent months sleeping 18-20 hours a day, unable to work, with fatigue, brain fog, joint pain and breathlessness. Rest, a keto diet and later a carnivore diet were credited; fatigue and joint pain cleared and they…

  • Long COVID with chest tightness and panic, somewhat better after lumbrokinase

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · No changeComet 61134 Long COVID Moderate at worstIll 3 years before improving or writing reddit.com May 2024

    Comet 61134 became ill with COVID in March 2020 and spent years with constant chest tightness, stomach burning and no appetite, plus early air hunger and about eight months of unending panic. Gallbladder removal eased her stomach burning and nausea,…

  • Long COVID food crashes and stomach trouble; beef kidney and bone broth helped

    Outcome unclear Doesn’t credit it · HelpedBluebell 71039 Long COVID reddit.com Sep 2022

    Writing in a long-COVID forum in September 2022, the user reported that beef kidney supplements taken 15 minutes before meals helped them avoid crashing after eating, and that bone broth before meals was one of the only things that soothed their stomach when…

  • sflorence on Phoenix Rising

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · Not said ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 11 years before improving forums.phoenixrising.me May 2020

    sflorence, who was 21 in 2016, had had ME/CFS and multiple chemical sensitivity since high school and was bedridden despite months on the Freddd methylation protocol, which he rated at about 15% more energy. Lamotrigine once brought complete remission until…

The first 5 credit Beef organ supplements (Heart & Soil) for their improvement; the other 8 tried it without crediting it.

A little hope, every Sunday

New recovery stories and data-driven research on ME/CFS and long COVID. Ideas worth considering, and the evidence behind them.

Free · Unsubscribe anytime