Acupuncture
What studies of acupuncture found
At a glance, by condition
Long COVID: C Might help, very uncertain
Based on the strongest evidence, the randomised trial and studies with no comparison group (very low certainty): 3 findings, all C.
3 outcomes rated · see each below
ME/CFS: C Might help, very uncertain
Based on the strongest evidence, randomised trials and studies with no comparison group and the randomised trial and compared with another group, not randomised (very low certainty): 21 of 23 findings are C.
12 outcomes rated · see each below
How we got this
Each condition’s headline comes from its graded findings (one for each outcome and kind of study) rated with the highest certainty: the grade most of them share; a tie goes to the finding with the most people, then the most studies, then the outcome’s name. It sums up the grades below, and conditions are never combined.
What this means: For long COVID, acupuncture might help some people, but research can’t show it yet. For ME/CFS, acupuncture might help some people, but research can’t show it yet. If you’re thinking about it, talk it through with a doctor who knows ME/CFS or long COVID.
Ask about this treatment
The grades, in plain words
Each outcome gets a direction, a certainty and a letter read from the two. Certainty is judged with GRADE, the method Cochrane and WHO use.
- AHelpsImprovement, high certaintyProbably helpsImprovement, moderate certainty
- BMay helpImprovement, low certainty
- Acupuncture · Long COVID is hereAcupuncture · ME/CFS is hereCMight help, very uncertainImprovement, very low certaintyMixed resultsStudies disagree
- DLittle or no differenceStudies found little or no difference
- FHarmsIt made things worse
By symptom and daily life
Long COVID
Symptoms
Smell and taste loss1 study · 2 (few people) people received acupuncture Improvement C
Why this grade: Improvement, very low certainty, from studies without a control group: no control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design); few people (2 in all); not all results were tested against chance.
Studies with no comparison group2 in the study · 30 mm long and 0.16 mm in diameter, 1–2 times a week (few people)
Smell and taste loss improved.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on smell and taste loss in long COVID. Improvement · very low certainty C
- No control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design)
- Few people (2 in all)
- Not all results were tested against chance
See the 1 study
-
- People in the study
- 2 in the study
- Dose
- 30 mm long and 0.16 mm in diameter, 1–2 times a week
- Outcome
- olfactory dysfunction
- Effect
- better (not tested)
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
Daily life and health overall
Overall symptoms4 studies · 195 people received acupuncture Improvement C
Why this grade: Improvement, very low certainty, from randomised trials: high risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight; few people (160 in all).
The randomised trial160 randomised · 10-14 days · 10 points were applied: 9 basic points, and 1 point depending on the specific complaint, once day for 10-14 days
Overall symptoms improved more than in the comparison group.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on overall symptoms in long COVID. Improvement · very low certainty C
- High risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight
- Few people (160 in all)
Studies with no comparison group3 studies · 115 people with results
Overall symptoms improved.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on overall symptoms in long COVID. Improvement · very low certainty C
- No control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design)
- Not all results were tested against chance
Combination: Chinese, Japanese and Korean herbal medicine + Acupuncture + BL132,067 in the study · 1,331 with outcome data
Explainable machine learning model and nomogram for predicting the efficacy of Traditional Chinese Medicine in treating Long COVID: a retrospective study. (2025): effective treatment, better (not tested).
Shown, not counted: acupuncture was given together with other treatments.
Combination: Chinese, Japanese and Korean herbal medicine + proton pump inhibitor + Epipharyngeal abrasive therapy (EAT) + Acupuncture + Moxibustion + Zinc + Antihistamines (unspecified) + Mirtazapine (Remeron) + Sleeping pills (unspecified) + Nasal saline rinses and sprays (neti pot)128 in the study · 114 with outcome data
Factors involved in the improvement of prolonged symptoms in patients with COVID-19 treated with Japanese traditional (Kampo) medicine: A single-center, prospective, observational study. (2026): the end of visit milestone, better (not tested).
Shown, not counted: acupuncture was given together with other treatments.
Combination: Acupuncture + Cupping1 in the study
Einsatz von Akupunktur bei Long Covid Use of acupuncture in long COVID (2022): Beschwerden, better (not tested).
Shown, not counted: acupuncture was given together with other treatments.
See the 4 studies
-
Acupuncture as an Additional Method of Rehabilitation Post-COVID-19: a randomized controlled trial. (2023)
- People in the study
- 160 randomised
- Dose
- 10 points were applied: 9 basic points, and 1 point depending on the specific complaint, once day for 10-14 days
- Outcome
- all four scales
- Effect
- better (not tested)
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Low
- Deviations from intended interventions
- Some concerns
- Missing outcome data
- Low
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
The Effectiveness of Acupuncture in The Treatment of Post COVID-19 Condition: A Retrospective Study (2022)
- People in the study
- 85 in the study
- Dose
- weekly for 8 to 12 consecutive weeks
- Outcome
- overall effectiveness
- Effect
- better (not tested)
- Risk of bias
- before-after study without a control group (JBI checklist for quasi-experimental studies); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
-
- People in the study
- 2 in the study
- Dose
- 30 mm long and 0.16 mm in diameter, 1–2 times a week
- Outcome
- malaise
- Effect
- better (not tested)
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
-
[Tongtiao acupuncture-moxibustion method for 28 cases of long COVID-19 olfactory dysfunction]. (2025)
- People in the study
- 28 in the study
- Dose
- Each treatment lasted 40 min, administered once daily for 6 days per week, followed by a 1-day rest, over 4 consecutive weeks
- Outcome
- total effective rate
- Effect
- better (not tested)
- Risk of bias
- before-after study without a control group (JBI checklist for quasi-experimental studies); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
Daily functioning1 study · 1 (few people) person received acupuncture Uncertain –
Why this grade: Uncertain, very low certainty, from studies without a control group: no control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design); few people (1 in all); not all results were tested against chance; one study saw it get worse, without a test against chance.
Studies with no comparison group1 in the study · 14 days after the ulcerations were initially observed · eight needlings were done: five insertions for the tongue, one insertion for the uvula, and two insertions for the bilateral palatopharyngeal arches, on September 12, 2024 (few people)
Too little to say about daily functioning.
Too little to say: daily functioning got worse in one study, but the change wasn't tested against chance. Uncertain · very low certainty –
- No control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design)
- Few people (1 in all)
- Not all results were tested against chance
- One study saw it get worse, without a test against chance
Combination: Chinese, Japanese and Korean herbal medicine + proton pump inhibitor + Epipharyngeal abrasive therapy (EAT) + Acupuncture + Moxibustion + Zinc + Antihistamines (unspecified) + Mirtazapine (Remeron) + Sleeping pills (unspecified) + Nasal saline rinses and sprays (neti pot)128 in the study · 114 with outcome data
Factors involved in the improvement of prolonged symptoms in patients with COVID-19 treated with Japanese traditional (Kampo) medicine: A single-center, prospective, observational study. (2026): PS ≤ 2, better (not tested).
Shown, not counted: acupuncture was given together with other treatments.
Combination: Acupuncture + Cupping1 in the study
Einsatz von Akupunktur bei Long Covid Use of acupuncture in long COVID (2022): gut belastbar, better (not tested).
Shown, not counted: acupuncture was given together with other treatments.
See the 1 study
-
- People in the study
- 1 in the study
- Dose
- eight needlings were done: five insertions for the tongue, one insertion for the uvula, and two insertions for the bilateral palatopharyngeal arches, on September 12, 2024
- Outcome
- swallowing difficulty
- Effect
- worse (not tested)
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
ME/CFS
Symptoms
Fatigue11 studies · 523 people received acupuncture Improvement C
Why this grade: Improvement, very low certainty, from randomised trials: high risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight; the studies disagree; effect size 0.43 (small).
Randomised trials9 studies · 756 people with results
Fatigue improved more than in the comparison group.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on fatigue in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- High risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight
- The studies disagree
- Effect size 0.43 (small)
How big was the difference?
0.43, small. The effect size compares acupuncture with group c (usual care alone group).
Studies with no comparison group2 studies · 41 people with results
Studies disagree about fatigue.
Studies disagree about whether acupuncture helps fatigue. Mixed results · very low certainty C
- No control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design)
- Few people (41 in all)
- The studies disagree
Combination: Acupuncture + Cupping72 randomised
Observation on therapeutic effect of chronic fatigue syndrome treated with Panlongci (coiling dragon needling) and moving cupping on back (2012): BELL's score, no clear difference.
Shown, not counted: acupuncture was given together with other treatments.
See the 11 studies
-
- People in the study
- 150 randomised
- Dose
- 10 sessions; stainless steel disposable needles (0.25-mm diameter, 30-mm length), 10 sessions for 4 weeks, 2 to 3 times a week
- Outcome
- Fatigue Severity Scale (FSS) score at 5 weeks after randomization Fatigue Severity Scale
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Some concerns
- Deviations from intended interventions
- Some concerns
- Missing outcome data
- Low
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- High
-
- People in the study
- 60 randomised
- Dose
- BL23 perpendicularly needled 15 to 30 mm; other points obliquely needled 15 to 30 mm; 10 s for each acupoint, twice a week for twenty minutes each time, a total of eight treatments
- Outcome
- Somatic fatigue scores Fatigue Scale-14
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Some concerns
- Deviations from intended interventions
- Some concerns
- Missing outcome data
- Low
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
- People in the study
- 50 randomised · 45 analysed
- Dose
- 10 sessions, every other day; 15 minutes each
- Outcome
- FAI score Fatigue Assessment Instrument
- Effect
- worse (not tested)
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Low
- Deviations from intended interventions
- Some concerns
- Missing outcome data
- Low
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
[A clinical trial of acupuncture for treating chronic fatigue syndrome in Hong Kong]. (2007)
- People in the study
- 99 randomised
- Dose
- twice a week for 4 weeks
- Outcome
- physical and mental fatigue
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Some concerns
- Deviations from intended interventions
- High
- Missing outcome data
- High
- Measurement of the outcome
- Low
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
- People in the study
- 60 randomised
- Dose
- 30 min, 3 courses, 10 times as a course with 3 days between two courses, once a day
- Outcome
- body fatigue scores fatigue scale 14
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Some concerns
- Deviations from intended interventions
- High
- Missing outcome data
- High
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
- People in the study
- 68 randomised
- Dose
- The treatment was given once a day, 5 treatments a week, with 2 days break
- Outcome
- FS-14 scores fatigue scale-14
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Some concerns
- Deviations from intended interventions
- High
- Missing outcome data
- High
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
- People in the study
- 80 randomised · 77 analysed
- Dose
- needles Hwato®; 0.25 mm × 40 mm; inserted at depth of 50-60 mm; needles maintained 20 min, 20 sessions over 4 weeks; five sessions per week
- Outcome
- FS-14 scores Fatigue Scale-14
- Effect
- worse
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Low
- Deviations from intended interventions
- High
- Missing outcome data
- Low
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
[Bamboo-based medicinal moxibustion for chronic fatigue syndrome: a randomized controlled trial]. (2023)
- People in the study
- 64 randomised
- Dose
- once a day
- Outcome
- FS-14 scores fatigue scale-14
- Effect
- worse
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Some concerns
- Deviations from intended interventions
- High
- Missing outcome data
- High
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
- People in the study
- 133 randomised
- Dose
- once daily for 20 days
- Outcome
- physical, mental and total scores Chalder Fatigue Scale (14-item fatigue scale)
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Some concerns
- Deviations from intended interventions
- High
- Missing outcome data
- High
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
- People in the study
- 40 in the study
- Dose
- "Disposable stainless steel filiform needles (32 gauges, 1.5 cun long) were inserted into points with twirling method or gently twirling and slowly lifting-thrusting method." Needles "retained for 30 min", "Acupuncture was performed once a day for 2 weeks."
- Outcome
- lassitude
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
-
Acupuncture in the treatment of post viral fatigue syndrome--a case report. (2005)
- People in the study
- 1 in the study
- Dose
- 40x0.26mm, 15 minutes with no manual or electrical stimulation
- Outcome
- tiredness
- Effect
- no clear difference
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
Depression3 studies · 168 people received acupuncture Mixed results C
Why this grade: Mixed results, very low certainty, from randomised trials: high risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight; few people (227 in all); the studies disagree; randomised trials found mixed results.
Randomised trials2 studies · 227 people with results
Studies disagree about depression.
Studies disagree about whether acupuncture helps depression. Mixed results · very low certainty C
- High risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight
- Few people (227 in all)
- The studies disagree
Studies with no comparison group60 randomised · 4 weeks · BL23 perpendicularly needled 15 to 30 mm; other points obliquely needled 15 to 30 mm; 10 s for each acupoint, twice a week for twenty minutes each time, a total of eight treatments
Depression improved.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on depression in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- No control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design)
- Few people (30 in all)
See the 3 studies
-
- People in the study
- 150 randomised
- Dose
- 10 sessions; stainless steel disposable needles (0.25-mm diameter, 30-mm length), 10 sessions for 4 weeks, 2 to 3 times a week
- Outcome
- BDI at 5 and 13 weeks after randomization Beck Depression Inventory
- Effect
- no clear difference
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Some concerns
- Deviations from intended interventions
- Some concerns
- Missing outcome data
- Low
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Low
-
- People in the study
- 80 randomised · 77 analysed
- Dose
- needles Hwato®; 0.25 mm × 40 mm; inserted at depth of 50-60 mm; needles maintained 20 min, 20 sessions over 4 weeks; five sessions per week
- Outcome
- HAMD scores Hamilton rating scale for depression
- Effect
- worse
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Low
- Deviations from intended interventions
- High
- Missing outcome data
- Low
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
- People in the study
- 60 randomised
- Dose
- BL23 perpendicularly needled 15 to 30 mm; other points obliquely needled 15 to 30 mm; 10 s for each acupoint, twice a week for twenty minutes each time, a total of eight treatments
- Outcome
- Depression Symptom Check-List 90
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
- before-after study without a control group (JBI checklist for quasi-experimental studies); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
Anxiety4 studies · 143 people received acupuncture Mixed results C
Why this grade: Mixed results, very low certainty, from randomised trials: high risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight; few people (137 in all); the studies disagree; randomised trials found mixed results.
Randomised trials2 studies · 137 people with results
Studies disagree about anxiety.
Studies disagree about whether acupuncture helps anxiety. Mixed results · very low certainty C
- High risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight
- Few people (137 in all)
- The studies disagree
Studies with no comparison group2 studies · 75 people with results
Anxiety improved.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on anxiety in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- No control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design)
See the 4 studies
-
- People in the study
- 60 randomised
- Dose
- 30 min, 3 courses, 10 times as a course with 3 days between two courses, once a day
- Outcome
- SAS scores self-rating anxiety scale
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Some concerns
- Deviations from intended interventions
- High
- Missing outcome data
- High
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
- People in the study
- 80 randomised · 77 analysed
- Dose
- needles Hwato®; 0.25 mm × 40 mm; inserted at depth of 50-60 mm; needles maintained 20 min, 20 sessions over 4 weeks; five sessions per week
- Outcome
- SAS scores Self-rating Anxiety Scale
- Effect
- no clear difference
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Low
- Deviations from intended interventions
- High
- Missing outcome data
- Low
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
- People in the study
- 60 randomised
- Dose
- BL23 perpendicularly needled 15 to 30 mm; other points obliquely needled 15 to 30 mm; 10 s for each acupoint, twice a week for twenty minutes each time, a total of eight treatments
- Outcome
- Anxiety Symptom Check-List 90
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
- before-after study without a control group (JBI checklist for quasi-experimental studies); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
-
Clinical observation on acupuncture therapy for chronic fatigue syndrome (2012)
- People in the study
- 90 randomised
- Dose
- 0.30 mm in diameter and 25-40 mm in length, once every day, and 7 treatments constituted 1 course
- Outcome
- SAS score Self-rating Anxiety Scale
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
- before-after study without a control group (JBI checklist for quasi-experimental studies); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
Sleep4 studies · 132 people received acupuncture Improvement C
Why this grade: Improvement, very low certainty, from randomised trials: high risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight; few people (68 in all).
The randomised trial68 randomised · before and after treatment; treatment for 4 weeks · The treatment was given once a day, 5 treatments a week, with 2 days break
Sleep improved more than in the comparison group.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on sleep in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- High risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight
- Few people (68 in all)
Compared with another group, not randomised107 in the study · 5 consecutive weeks · once daily, with a total of 6 acupuncture sessions per week for 5 consecutive weeks
Sleep improved more than in the comparison group.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on sleep in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- Serious risk of bias (ROBINS-I)
Studies with no comparison group2 studies · 41 people with results
Sleep improved.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on sleep in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- No control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design)
- Few people (41 in all)
- Not all results were tested against chance
See the 4 studies
-
- People in the study
- 68 randomised
- Dose
- The treatment was given once a day, 5 treatments a week, with 2 days break
- Outcome
- PSQI scores Pittsburgh sleep quality index
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Some concerns
- Deviations from intended interventions
- High
- Missing outcome data
- High
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
- People in the study
- 107 in the study
- Dose
- once daily, with a total of 6 acupuncture sessions per week for 5 consecutive weeks
- Outcome
- PSQI scores Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
ROBINS-I: Serious
- Confounding
- NI. adjustment for confounding isn't reported
- Selection of participants
- Moderate. comparison group: non-randomised; patients grouped by treatment received
Among these, 50 patients who received eszopiclone tablets were collected as the control group. The remaining 57 patients who received the acupuncture therapy in addition to the treatment in the control group were collected as the observation group.
- Classification of interventions
- Moderate. from records after the fact
- Deviations from intended interventions
- NI. not reported for this design
- Missing data
- NI. missing data aren't reported
- Measurement of outcomes
- Serious. self-reported by people who knew their treatment
- Selection of the reported result
- Moderate. a pre-specified primary outcome
-
- People in the study
- 40 in the study
- Dose
- "Disposable stainless steel filiform needles (32 gauges, 1.5 cun long) were inserted into points with twirling method or gently twirling and slowly lifting-thrusting method." Needles "retained for 30 min", "Acupuncture was performed once a day for 2 weeks."
- Outcome
- insomnia
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
-
Acupuncture Treatment for an Adolescent with Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (2008)
- People in the study
- 1 in the study
- Dose
- Depth of needle penetration was 1–2 mm; needles used were Seirin #5 (0.25 /H11003 40 mm; Tokyo, Japan), once a week for 6 weeks; duration of each treatment was 30 minutes
- Outcome
- able to sleep at night
- Effect
- better (not tested)
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
Cognition (brain fog)2 studies · 70 people received acupuncture Improvement C
Why this grade: Improvement, very low certainty, from randomised trials: high risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight; few people (60 in all); effect size 0.43 (small).
The randomised trial60 randomised · 4 weeks · BL23 perpendicularly needled 15 to 30 mm; other points obliquely needled 15 to 30 mm; 10 s for each acupoint, twice a week for twenty minutes each time, a total of eight treatments
Cognition (brain fog) improved more than in the comparison group.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on cognition (brain fog) in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- High risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight
- Few people (60 in all)
- Effect size 0.43 (small)
How big was the difference?
0.43, small. The effect size compares acupuncture with control.
Studies with no comparison group40 in the study · "Acupuncture was performed once a day for 2 weeks." · "Disposable stainless steel filiform needles (32 gauges, 1.5 cun long) were inserted into points with twirling method or gently twirling and slowly lifting-thrusting method." Needles "retained for 30 min", "Acupuncture was performed once a day for 2 weeks."
Cognition (brain fog) improved.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on cognition (brain fog) in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- No control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design)
- Few people (40 in all)
See the 2 studies
-
- People in the study
- 60 randomised
- Dose
- BL23 perpendicularly needled 15 to 30 mm; other points obliquely needled 15 to 30 mm; 10 s for each acupoint, twice a week for twenty minutes each time, a total of eight treatments
- Outcome
- Compulsion Symptom Check-List 90
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Some concerns
- Deviations from intended interventions
- Some concerns
- Missing outcome data
- Low
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
- People in the study
- 40 in the study
- Dose
- "Disposable stainless steel filiform needles (32 gauges, 1.5 cun long) were inserted into points with twirling method or gently twirling and slowly lifting-thrusting method." Needles "retained for 30 min", "Acupuncture was performed once a day for 2 weeks."
- Outcome
- amnesia
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
Pain1 study · 40 people received acupuncture Improvement C
Why this grade: Improvement, very low certainty, from studies without a control group: no control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design); few people (40 in all).
Studies with no comparison group40 in the study · "Acupuncture was performed once a day for 2 weeks." · "Disposable stainless steel filiform needles (32 gauges, 1.5 cun long) were inserted into points with twirling method or gently twirling and slowly lifting-thrusting method." Needles "retained for 30 min", "Acupuncture was performed once a day for 2 weeks."
Pain improved.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on pain in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- No control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design)
- Few people (40 in all)
See the 1 study
-
- People in the study
- 40 in the study
- Dose
- "Disposable stainless steel filiform needles (32 gauges, 1.5 cun long) were inserted into points with twirling method or gently twirling and slowly lifting-thrusting method." Needles "retained for 30 min", "Acupuncture was performed once a day for 2 weeks."
- Outcome
- pain in muscles, joints, neck, back, shoulders and arms
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
Smell and taste loss1 study · 40 people received acupuncture Improvement C
Why this grade: Improvement, very low certainty, from studies without a control group: no control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design); few people (40 in all).
Studies with no comparison group40 in the study · "Acupuncture was performed once a day for 2 weeks." · "Disposable stainless steel filiform needles (32 gauges, 1.5 cun long) were inserted into points with twirling method or gently twirling and slowly lifting-thrusting method." Needles "retained for 30 min", "Acupuncture was performed once a day for 2 weeks."
Smell and taste loss improved.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on smell and taste loss in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- No control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design)
- Few people (40 in all)
See the 1 study
-
- People in the study
- 40 in the study
- Dose
- "Disposable stainless steel filiform needles (32 gauges, 1.5 cun long) were inserted into points with twirling method or gently twirling and slowly lifting-thrusting method." Needles "retained for 30 min", "Acupuncture was performed once a day for 2 weeks."
- Outcome
- tastelessness in the mouth
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
Breathlessness1 study · 1 (few people) person received acupuncture Improvement C
Why this grade: Improvement, very low certainty, from studies without a control group: no control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design); few people (1 in all); not all results were tested against chance.
Studies with no comparison group1 in the study · 2010 to 2026 · weekly for eighteen months (few people)
Breathlessness improved.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on breathlessness in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- No control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design)
- Few people (1 in all)
- Not all results were tested against chance
See the 1 study
-
- People in the study
- 1 in the study
- Dose
- weekly for eighteen months
- Outcome
- not blue-purple or breathless
- Effect
- better (not tested)
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
Low mood or anxiety2 studies · 70 people received acupuncture Little or no difference D
Why this grade: Little or no difference, very low certainty, from randomised trials: high risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight; one trial of 60 people found no clear difference; a small benefit can't be ruled out; effect size 0.08 (very small).
The randomised trial60 randomised · 4 weeks · BL23 perpendicularly needled 15 to 30 mm; other points obliquely needled 15 to 30 mm; 10 s for each acupoint, twice a week for twenty minutes each time, a total of eight treatments
No clear difference in low mood or anxiety.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on low mood or anxiety in ME/CFS. Little or no difference · very low certainty D
- High risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight
- One trial of 60 people found no clear difference; a small benefit can't be ruled out
- Effect size 0.08 (very small)
How big was the difference?
0.08, very small. The effect size compares acupuncture with control.
Studies with no comparison group40 in the study · "Acupuncture was performed once a day for 2 weeks." · "Disposable stainless steel filiform needles (32 gauges, 1.5 cun long) were inserted into points with twirling method or gently twirling and slowly lifting-thrusting method." Needles "retained for 30 min", "Acupuncture was performed once a day for 2 weeks."
Low mood or anxiety improved.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on low mood or anxiety in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- No control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design)
- Few people (40 in all)
See the 2 studies
-
- People in the study
- 60 randomised
- Dose
- BL23 perpendicularly needled 15 to 30 mm; other points obliquely needled 15 to 30 mm; 10 s for each acupoint, twice a week for twenty minutes each time, a total of eight treatments
- Outcome
- Hostility Symptom Check-List 90
- Effect
- no clear difference
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Some concerns
- Deviations from intended interventions
- Some concerns
- Missing outcome data
- Low
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
- People in the study
- 40 in the study
- Dose
- "Disposable stainless steel filiform needles (32 gauges, 1.5 cun long) were inserted into points with twirling method or gently twirling and slowly lifting-thrusting method." Needles "retained for 30 min", "Acupuncture was performed once a day for 2 weeks."
- Outcome
- mental condition Classification of Fatigue Symptoms
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
Daily life and health overall
Overall symptoms6 studies · 159 people received acupuncture Mixed results C
Why this grade: Mixed results, very low certainty, from randomised trials: high risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight; few people (120 in all); the studies disagree; randomised trials found mixed results.
Randomised trials2 studies · 120 people with results
Studies disagree about overall symptoms.
Studies disagree about whether acupuncture helps overall symptoms. Mixed results · very low certainty C
- High risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight
- Few people (120 in all)
- The studies disagree
Compared with another group, not randomised107 in the study · 5 consecutive weeks · once daily, with a total of 6 acupuncture sessions per week for 5 consecutive weeks
No clear difference in overall symptoms.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on overall symptoms in ME/CFS. Little or no difference · very low certainty D
- Serious risk of bias (ROBINS-I)
- The change wasn't shown to be more than chance
Studies with no comparison group3 studies · 42 people with results
Overall symptoms improved.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on overall symptoms in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- No control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design)
- Few people (42 in all)
- Not all results were tested against chance
Combination: Acupuncture + Acupressure, ear seeds and auricular devices64 randomised
The therapeutic effects of electrical acupuncture and auricular-plaster in 32 cases of chronic fatigue syndrome. (2006): total effective rates, better.
Shown, not counted: acupuncture was given together with other treatments.
Combination: Acupuncture + Cupping72 randomised
Observation on therapeutic effect of chronic fatigue syndrome treated with Panlongci (coiling dragon needling) and moving cupping on back (2012): total effective rate, better.
Shown, not counted: acupuncture was given together with other treatments.
Combination: Acupuncture + Massage100 randomised
Therapeutic Observation on Acupuncture plus Tuina for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (2013): total effective rate, better.
Shown, not counted: acupuncture was given together with other treatments.
See the 6 studies
-
- People in the study
- 60 randomised
- Dose
- BL23 perpendicularly needled 15 to 30 mm; other points obliquely needled 15 to 30 mm; 10 s for each acupoint, twice a week for twenty minutes each time, a total of eight treatments
- Outcome
- SCL-90 total scores Symptom Check-List 90
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Some concerns
- Deviations from intended interventions
- Some concerns
- Missing outcome data
- Low
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
Clinical study on tuina and moxibustion for chronic fatigue syndrome (2012)
- People in the study
- 60 randomised
- Dose
- Stainless filiform needles of 25 mm in length, once every other day, 3 times a week, consecutively for 4 weeks
- Outcome
- Recovery rate
- Effect
- worse
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Some concerns
- Deviations from intended interventions
- Some concerns
- Missing outcome data
- Low
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
- People in the study
- 107 in the study
- Dose
- once daily, with a total of 6 acupuncture sessions per week for 5 consecutive weeks
- Outcome
- clinical overall response rate
- Effect
- no clear difference
- Risk of bias
ROBINS-I: Serious
- Confounding
- NI. adjustment for confounding isn't reported
- Selection of participants
- Moderate. comparison group: non-randomised; patients grouped by treatment received
Among these, 50 patients who received eszopiclone tablets were collected as the control group. The remaining 57 patients who received the acupuncture therapy in addition to the treatment in the control group were collected as the observation group.
- Classification of interventions
- Moderate. from records after the fact
- Deviations from intended interventions
- NI. not reported for this design
- Missing data
- NI. missing data aren't reported
- Measurement of outcomes
- Serious. self-reported by people who knew their treatment
- Selection of the reported result
- Moderate. a pre-specified primary outcome
-
Acupuncture in the treatment of post viral fatigue syndrome--a case report. (2005)
- People in the study
- 1 in the study
- Dose
- 40x0.26mm, 15 minutes with no manual or electrical stimulation
- Outcome
- improvement
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
-
- People in the study
- 40 in the study
- Dose
- "Disposable stainless steel filiform needles (32 gauges, 1.5 cun long) were inserted into points with twirling method or gently twirling and slowly lifting-thrusting method." Needles "retained for 30 min", "Acupuncture was performed once a day for 2 weeks."
- Outcome
- Total score of symptoms
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
-
- People in the study
- 1 in the study
- Dose
- weekly for eighteen months
- Outcome
- brief and remarkable reprieve
- Effect
- better (not tested)
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
Quality of life2 studies · 100 people received acupuncture Improvement C
Why this grade: Improvement, very low certainty, from randomised trials: high risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight; few people (99 in all).
The randomised trial99 randomised · 4 weeks · twice a week for 4 weeks
Quality of life improved more than in the comparison group.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on quality of life in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- High risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight
- Few people (99 in all)
Studies with no comparison group1 in the study · 6 weeks · Depth of needle penetration was 1–2 mm; needles used were Seirin #5 (0.25 /H11003 40 mm; Tokyo, Japan), once a week for 6 weeks; duration of each treatment was 30 minutes (few people)
Quality of life improved.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on quality of life in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- No control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design)
- Few people (1 in all)
See the 2 studies
-
[A clinical trial of acupuncture for treating chronic fatigue syndrome in Hong Kong]. (2007)
- People in the study
- 99 randomised
- Dose
- twice a week for 4 weeks
- Outcome
- HQOL SF-12 health-related quality of life (HQOL) questionnaire
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Some concerns
- Deviations from intended interventions
- High
- Missing outcome data
- High
- Measurement of the outcome
- Low
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
Acupuncture Treatment for an Adolescent with Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (2008)
- People in the study
- 1 in the study
- Dose
- Depth of needle penetration was 1–2 mm; needles used were Seirin #5 (0.25 /H11003 40 mm; Tokyo, Japan), once a week for 6 weeks; duration of each treatment was 30 minutes
- Outcome
- quality of life for the patient and her family
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
Daily functioning4 studies · 33 people received acupuncture Improvement C
Why this grade: Improvement, very low certainty, from randomised trials: high risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight; few people (60 in all); effect size 1.25 (large).
The randomised trial60 randomised · 4 weeks · BL23 perpendicularly needled 15 to 30 mm; other points obliquely needled 15 to 30 mm; 10 s for each acupoint, twice a week for twenty minutes each time, a total of eight treatments
Daily functioning improved more than in the comparison group.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on daily functioning in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- High risk of bias (RoB 2) in the results that carry most of the weight
- Few people (60 in all)
- Effect size 1.25 (large)
How big was the difference?
1.25, large. The effect size compares acupuncture with control.
Studies with no comparison group3 studies · 3 people with results (few people)
Daily functioning improved.
The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of acupuncture on daily functioning in ME/CFS. Improvement · very low certainty C
- No control group: part of any change may be placebo, natural recovery or regression to the mean (risk of bias by design)
- Few people (3 in all)
- Not all results were tested against chance
See the 4 studies
-
- People in the study
- 60 randomised
- Dose
- BL23 perpendicularly needled 15 to 30 mm; other points obliquely needled 15 to 30 mm; 10 s for each acupoint, twice a week for twenty minutes each time, a total of eight treatments
- Outcome
- Interpersonal sensitivity Symptom Check-List 90
- Effect
- better
- Risk of bias
RoB 2: High
- Randomisation process
- Some concerns
- Deviations from intended interventions
- Some concerns
- Missing outcome data
- Low
- Measurement of the outcome
- High
- Selection of the reported result
- Some concerns
-
Acupuncture Treatment for an Adolescent with Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (2008)
- People in the study
- 1 in the study
- Dose
- Depth of needle penetration was 1–2 mm; needles used were Seirin #5 (0.25 /H11003 40 mm; Tokyo, Japan), once a week for 6 weeks; duration of each treatment was 30 minutes
- Outcome
- returned to regular school classes and was able to resume normal daily activities
- Effect
- better (not tested)
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
-
- People in the study
- 1 in the study
- Dose
- weekly for eighteen months
- Outcome
- wore a dress reserved for swim days only
- Effect
- better (not tested)
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
-
Acupuncture in the treatment of post viral fatigue syndrome--a case report. (2005)
- People in the study
- 1 in the study
- Dose
- 40x0.26mm, 15 minutes with no manual or electrical stimulation
- Outcome
- work pattern
- Effect
- better (not tested)
- Risk of bias
- case report or series (JBI checklist for case reports / case series); not rated with RoB 2 or ROBINS-I
Studies of combinations
Outcomes that only studies of acupuncture given together with other treatments looked at. Shown, not graded: they can’t tell what acupuncture did alone.
Autonomic symptoms Long COVID
Combination: Ethyl loflazepate + Agomelatine (Valdoxan) + Mosapride + Pancreatic enzymes (Creon, Zenpep) + Simethicone (Gas-X) + Tegoprazan + Chinese, Japanese and Korean herbal medicine + Acupuncture + Moxibustion1 in the study
Integrative personalized medicine care for adjustment disorder of a post-COVID-19 patient: A CARE-compliant case report. (2024): autonomic nervous system activity score, better (not tested).
Shown, not counted: acupuncture was given together with other treatments.
Quality of life Long COVID
Combination: Ethyl loflazepate + Agomelatine (Valdoxan) + Mosapride + Pancreatic enzymes (Creon, Zenpep) + Simethicone (Gas-X) + Tegoprazan + Chinese, Japanese and Korean herbal medicine + Acupuncture + Moxibustion1 in the study
Integrative personalized medicine care for adjustment disorder of a post-COVID-19 patient: A CARE-compliant case report. (2024): EQ-5D-5L scores, better (not tested).
Shown, not counted: acupuncture was given together with other treatments.
Side effects
Stopping because of side effects2 studies
Three CFS patients and 2 healthy volunteers were lost during the treatment because they could not adapt to acupuncture or they lost contact
Acupuncture and Moxibustion have Different Effects on Fatigue by Regulating the Autonomic Nervous System: A Pilot Controlled Clinical Trial. (2016)She cancelled her appointment for treatment one month later: it was unnecessary
Acupuncture in the treatment of post viral fatigue syndrome--a case report. (2005)
Side effects studies reported3 kinds
| Side effect | Studies that reported it |
|---|---|
| Fatigue | 1 study |
| Nausea or stomach upset | 1 study |
| Worse symptoms or a flare | 1 study |
All papers
- Acupuncture for chronic fatigue syndrome: a randomized, sham-controlled trial with single-blinded design.2013 · placebo trial · 101 randomised · 98 started · 74 analysed
Summary
This single-center randomized sham-controlled trial studied acupuncture for persistent fatigue after chemotherapy in cancer patients. The paper says 101 patients were randomized to true or sham acupuncture; 74 patients (34 in the acupuncture group and 40 in the sham group) completed post-treatment questionnaires and were evaluable for the primary endpoint. Treatment was once a week over 6 weeks for 6 standardized sessions. The primary endpoint was the Brief Fatigue Inventory (BFI); secondary measures included the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) and Functional Assessment of Cancer Treatment-General (FACT-G). In both groups BFI scores fell by about 1 point between baseline and post-intervention follow-up, with no statistically significant difference between groups: adjusted post-treatment difference 0.04 (95 % CI −0.57 to 0.66; p=0.9). HADS and FACT-G scores also improved in both groups, with no statistically significant differences between groups. At 6 months, fatigue scores were almost unchanged (difference over time −0.14; 95 % CI −0.84 to 0.56; p=0.7). A total of 11 serious adverse events occurred; none was deemed related to the study interventions. The authors state that 13 in the acupuncture group and 11 in the sham group did not complete post-treatment questionnaires, and that the study is limited by patients lost to follow-up and by a once-weekly 6-week regimen that may not have been intensive or long enough.
- [Bamboo-based medicinal moxibustion for chronic fatigue syndrome: a randomized controlled trial].2023 · randomised trial · 64 randomised
Summary
This randomized controlled trial asked whether bamboo-based medicinal moxibustion improves chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). Sixty-four patients with CFS were randomly divided into a moxibustion group (32 cases; 1 case dropped off, 1 case excluded) and an acupuncture group (32 cases; 2 cases dropped off). The moxibustion group received bamboo-based medicinal moxibustion and the acupuncture group routine acupuncture, once a day, 6 days as a course of treatment with 1 day interval, for 2 courses of treatment. Outcomes were observed before treatment, 1 and 2 courses into treatment and at follow-up 14 days after treatment using the fatigue scale-14 (FS-14) and somatic and psychological health report (SPHERE). Compared before treatment, FS-14 and SPHERE scores in the two groups decreased at 1 and 2 courses into treatment and at follow-up (P<0.01); the FS-14 and SPHERE scores in the moxibustion group were lower than those in the acupuncture group (P<0.01, P<0.05). The total effective rate was 93.3% (28/30) in the moxibustion group and 73.3% (22/30) in the acupuncture group (P<0.05). Harms were not reported; reasons for dropping off or exclusion were not reported.
- Acupuncture as an Additional Method of Rehabilitation Post-COVID-19: a randomized controlled trial.2023 · randomised trial · 160 randomised
Summary
This randomized clinical trial took place at the rehabilitation center “Kamenskoe Plato” in Almaty, Kazakhstan. It included 160 participants with Post COVID-19 condition (PCC); 80 were assigned to complex rehabilitation methods (CRM) with acupuncture and 80 to CRM alone, at a ratio of 1:1. Acupuncture was performed once a day for 10-14 days, and all participants completed at least 10 days of treatment. The acupuncture group received full-body dry acupuncture at 10 points; both groups received CRMs. Outcomes were the Modified Dyspnea Scale (MDS), Bartel index (BI), 6-minute walking test (6-MWT), and Borg RPE scale. Adverse events were monitored and documented. The text reports significant within-group improvement in MDS and Borg scale in both groups. The 6-MWT and BI scores improved significantly in the acupuncture group only; in the group without acupuncture, BI and 6-MWT results were not significantly different. The text also states that after rehabilitation the acupuncture group had better results on all four scales than the group without acupuncture, without a significance value in that sentence. No adverse events are reported in the text. The authors state that no blinding was performed and that combining acupuncture with other rehabilitation procedures cannot show the exact effectiveness of acupuncture.
- [Effect of electroacupuncture at back- shu points of five zang on fatigue status and cortical excitability in chronic fatigue syndrome].2022 · randomised trial · 72 randomised
Summary
This study examined electroacupuncture (EA) at back-shu points of the five zang in people with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). A total of 72 patients with CFS were randomized into an EA group (36 cases, 4 cases dropped off) and a sham EA group (36 cases, 3 cases dropped off). The EA group received EA at Ganshu (BL 18), Xinshu (BL 15), Pishu (BL 20), Feishu (BL 13) and Shenshu (BL 23), with continuous wave, 2 Hz in frequency. The sham EA group received sham EA at non-acupoints (1.5-2.0 cm lateral to back-shu points of five zang), with shallow needling, and no current was connected. Treatment in both groups was 20 min each time, once every other day, 2 weeks as one course, 3 courses were required. Before and after treatment, the scores of fatigue scale-14 (FS-14) and the MOS 36-item short form health survey (SF-36) were observed, and cortical excitability (the resting motor threshold [RMT], amplitude of motor-evoked potential [MEP-A] and latency of motor-evoked potential [MEP-L]) was detected in the two groups. After treatment, the physical fatigue score, mental fatigue score and total score of FS-14, as well as RMT of motor cortex in the EA group were decreased compared with those before treatment. The abstract reports no between-group comparison of these outcomes and no side effects; dropouts were 4 in the EA group and 3 in the sham EA group.
- [Acupuncture in the treatment of chronic fatigue syndrome based on "interaction of brain and kidney" in TCM: a randomized controlled trial].2019 · randomised trial · 68 randomised
Summary
This randomized controlled trial examined acupuncture for fatigue symptoms in chronic fatigue syndrome, based on the theory of interaction of brain and kidney, and explored clinical effects and a potential mechanism. A total of 68 patients were randomized into an observation group and a control group, 34 cases in each one; where the patients were from is not reported. The control group received oral oryzanol and vitamin B1 and was required to have proper rest and physical exercise. The observation group received the same basis plus acupuncture. Treatment was given once a day, 5 treatments a week, with 2 days break; consecutive treatment for 4 weeks was required. Before and after treatment, the fatigue scale-14 (FS-14), the somatic and psychological health report (SPHERE) and the Pittsburgh sleep quality index (PSQI) were observed. After treatment, FS-14 scores, SPHERE scores and PSQI scores were all reduced as compared with the scores before treatment in the two groups (P<0.05, P<0.01). After treatment, the scores of FS-14, SPHERE and PSQI in the observation group were all lower than the results in the control group (P<0.05, P<0.01). The abstract does not report side effects, withdrawals, or the number of patients analysed. The authors state that acupuncture therapy relieves fatigue symptoms and potential symptoms and improves sleep quality in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome; they propose a possible mechanism involving decrease of serum IL-6 and INF-γ levels. No limitations are stated in the abstract.
- [Chaihu Longgu Muli decoction combined with acupuncture at back-shu points for chronic fatigue syndrome].2017 · randomised trial · 60 randomised
Summary
The study compared Chaihu Longgu Muli decoction combined with acupuncture at back-shu points with simple Chaihu Longgu Muli decoction for chronic fatigue syndrome. Sixty patients were randomly assigned into an herbal group and a combination group, 30 cases in each one. The herbal group received simple Chaihu Longgu Muli decoction for continuous one month, one decoction a day. The combination group received that decoction plus 30 min acupuncture at bilateral Xinshu (BL 15), Feishu (BL 13), Pishu (BL 20), Ganshu (BL 18) and Shenshu (BL 23), with acupoints according to syndrome differentiation; acupuncture was given for 3 courses, 10 times as a course with 3 days between two courses, once a day. Fatigue status was evaluated before and after treatment by fatigue scale 14 (FS-14) and self-rating anxiety scale (SAS). The FS-14 scores, including body fatigue scores, mental fatigue scores and total scores, and SAS scores after treatment were lower than those before treatment in the two groups (all P<0.01), with better improvements in the combination group (all P<0.01). Harms, withdrawals, and the number analysed were not reported. The authors state no limitations in the abstract.
- Chronic fatigue syndrome treated by the traditional Chinese procedure abdominal tuina: a randomized controlled clinical trial.2017 · randomised trial · 80 randomised · 77 analysed
Summary
This randomized, single assessor-blinded trial evaluated abdominal Tuina for chronic fatigue syndrome. Eighty people were enrolled at the First Teaching Hospital of Tianjin University of TCM and divided into two groups of 40: abdominal Tuina or acupuncture. Treatments were given once a day, 5 d for one course with a 2 d interval between courses; the whole course lasted 4 weeks (20 sessions). FS-14, SAS and HAMD scores were measured before and after treatment and at 3-month follow-up. In total, 77 patients completed the trial (39 in the abdominal Tuina group and 38 in the acupuncture group). After treatment, FS-14 scores were 6.6±1.8 with abdominal Tuina versus 7.6±2.1 with acupuncture (P=0.039), and HAMD scores were 5.6±1.3 versus 6.3±1.2 (P=0.025). SAS scores were 47±4 versus 49±5, and the difference between groups was not significant (P=0.065). At follow-up, FS-14, SAS and HAMD scores in the abdominal Tuina group were superior to those in the acupuncture group (all P<0.05). CFS recurred in two cases in the abdominal Tuina group and three in the acupuncture group, but the difference was not significant. No serious adverse events were observed; one patient in the abdominal Tuina group had persistent pain for 1 h during the first treatment, and 2/38 in the acupuncture group had hematoma at the needling site. One patient in the abdominal Tuina group dropped out because she failed to visit the clinic, and two in the acupuncture group because they underwent additional treatments prohibited in the trial.
- [Efficacy of acupoint catgut embedding combined with ginger-partitioned moxibustion on chronic fatigue syndrome of spleen-kidney yang deficiency syndrome and its effects on T lymphocyte subsets and activity of NK cell].2017 · randomised trial · 60 randomised
Summary
This randomised study compared acupoint catgut embedding combined with ginger-partitioned moxibustion with regular acupuncture for chronic fatigue syndrome of spleen-kidney yang deficiency syndrome. It included 60 patients, with 30 cases in each group. The setting was not reported. One group received acupoint catgut embedding at Guanyuan (CV 4), Shenshu (BL 23), Pishu (BL 20), Zusanli (ST 36), Qihai (CV 6) once a week plus ginger-partitioned moxibustion at Guanyuan (CV 4), Qihai (CV 6) and Zusanli (ST 36) once every three days for consecutive one month. The other group received regular acupuncture at Guanyuan (CV 4), Shenshu (BL 23), Pishu (BL 20), Zusanli (ST 36), Qihai (CV 6) once a day, 6 treatments per week (one day for rest) for consecutive one month. Outcomes compared before and after treatment included clinical symptom scores, fatigue scale-14 (FS-14), fatigue assessment instrument (FAI), and total effective rate. After treatment, clinical symptom scores, FS-14 and FAI were reduced in both groups (all P<0.05); the catgut embedding combined with ginger-partitioned moxibustion (CECGP) group had significantly lower clinical symptom scores, FS-14 and FAI than the regular acupuncture group (all P<0.05). The total effective rate was 96.7% (29/30) in the CECGP group and 93.3% (28/30) in the regular acupuncture group (P>0.05). Side effects and withdrawals were not reported. The abstract states no limitations.
- Acupuncture and Moxibustion have Different Effects on Fatigue by Regulating the Autonomic Nervous System: A Pilot Controlled Clinical Trial.2016 · randomised trial · 50 randomised · 45 analysed
Summary
This controlled clinical trial asked whether acupuncture and moxibustion change fatigue and autonomic nervous system activity in chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). Participants were recruited by notices from Huangjiahu Hospital, affiliated with Hubei University of Chinese Medicine, and the External Treatment Center. 50 participants were recruited; 45 completed the trial on schedule, with 15 in each group. The acupuncture group and a control group of healthy volunteers received manipulation acupuncture at ST36 (bilateral) and CV4; the moxibustion group received indirect moxibustion at the same points. Every participant received 10 sessions, administered every other day, each lasting 15 minutes. The Fatigue Assessment Instrument (FAI), a 7-point scale, was completed before and after the 4th and 10th treatments; heart rate variability (HRV) parameters were also measured. FAI scores decreased significantly after the 4th and 10th treatments in all 3 groups. After the 10th treatment, the FAI score in the moxibustion group was lower than in the acupuncture group, and the decrease values in the moxibustion group were higher than in the acupuncture group. 3 CFS patients and 2 healthy volunteers were lost during treatment because they could not adapt to acupuncture or lost contact. Side effects were not reported. The authors state that the sample size was 15 in each group.
- [Moxibustion at Gaohuang (BL 43) for chronic fatigue syndrome: a randomized controlled trial].2015 · randomised trial · 90 randomised
Summary
This trial assessed the dose–effect of Long-snake-like moxibustion for chronic fatigue syndrome. Sixty female patients were randomly allocated to 60-min Long-snake-like moxibustion (Group A, n=30) or 30-min Long-snake-like moxibustion (Group B, n=30), with 30 healthy control subjects. Treatment was 3 times per week for 4 weeks (12 sessions). Outcomes included Fatigue scale-14, Symptoms Scale of Spleen-Kidney Yang Deficiency, Self-rating depression scale, Self-rating anxiety scale, and Thermal Texture Maps. At week 4, Group A scores were lower than Group B for physical fatigue (5.00 vs. 6.00; p=0.003), FS-14 total (8.00 vs. 9.00; p=0.012), and Spleen-Kidney Yang Deficiency total (9.80 vs. 13.07; P=0.012). Mental fatigue showed no significant between-group difference (3.00 vs. 3.00; p=0.542), and SDS and SAS showed no statistical differences between groups. No adverse events, harms, or withdrawals for harms were reported. The authors state limitations of a small sample size, only female subjects, and only two time points for TTM scanning.
- Acupuncture for chronic fatigue syndrome and idiopathic chronic fatigue: a multicenter, nonblinded, randomized controlled trial.2015 · randomised trial · 150 randomised
Summary
This three-arm, non-blinded, randomized trial tested acupuncture added to usual care for chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) and idiopathic chronic fatigue (ICF). In four hospitals in South Korea, 150 participants were divided into Group A (n = 49; body acupuncture), Group B (n = 51; Sa-am acupuncture), and Group C (n = 50; usual care alone). Treatment groups received 10 sessions for 4 weeks. The primary outcome was the Fatigue Severity Scale (FSS) at 5 weeks; secondary outcomes included FSS at 13 weeks, SRI, BDI, NRS, and EQ-5D at 5 and 13 weeks. At 5 weeks, Group A had a significantly lower FSS score than Group C (P = 0.023); Group B did not (P = 0.151). FSS at 13 weeks was not different between groups. SRI scores were significantly lower in both treatment groups than in Group C at 5 and 13 weeks. BDI was significantly lower in Group B than Group C at 13 weeks (P = 0.007). NRS was significantly reduced in both treatment groups compared with Group C at 5 and 13 weeks. EQ-5D did not differ among groups. Three participants in Group A, two in Group B, and two in Group C dropped out. A total of 10 adverse events were reported by 10 participants; 2 of the 150 participants (1.3 %) showed acupuncture-related adverse events, and all participants who experienced adverse events improved and continued. The authors state that specific effects could not be isolated.
- [Randomized controlled clinical trials of acupuncture and moxibustion treatment of chronic fatigue syndrome patients].2014 · randomised trial · 133 randomised
Summary
Randomized controlled clinical trials of acupuncture and moxibustion treatment of chronic fatigue syndrome patients included 133 CFS patients randomized into acupuncture group (47 cases), warm-needling group (44 cases) and non-acupoint group (42 cases). Manual acupuncture (MA) stimulation was applied in the acupuncture group; moxa-heated needle was applied in the warm-needling group; non-acupoints were used in the non-acupoint group. Treatment was given once daily for 20 days. The Chalder Fatigue Scale (14-item fatigue scale) evaluated CFS changes before and after treatment. Compared with pre-treatment, scores including physical and mental fatigue and total score decreased in both acupuncture and warm-needling groups (P < 0.05, P < 0.01), but not in the non-acupoint group (P > 0.05) except physical score (P < 0.05). Physical, mental and total scores of acupuncture and warm-needling groups were lower than non-acupoint group (P < 0.05, P < 0.01); warm-needling physical and total scores were lower than acupuncture (P < 0.05). Satisfactory rates were 36.2% (17/47), 72.7% (32/44) and 35.7% (15/42). No harms, side effects, or withdrawals were reported. Setting and analysed numbers were not reported. Limitations were not reported.
- Observations on the Therapeutic Effect of Warm Needling Moxibustion on Chronic Fatigue Syndrome2014 · randomised trial · 80 randomised
Summary
Eighty patients with chronic fatigue syndrome were randomly allocated to a treatment group and a control group, 40 cases each, to compare warm needling moxibustion with electroacupuncture. The treatment group received warm needling moxibustion and the control group received electroacupuncture. Both groups were treated once every other day, 10 days as a course for a total of two courses. Symptoms were scored with the Chronic Fatigue Syndrome Symptom Rating Scale, and blood immunoglobulins were measured before and after treatment. The clinical therapeutic effects were compared between the two groups. The abstract reports a statistically significant pre-/post-treatment difference in the clinical symptom score in both groups (P0.01), and a statistically significant difference in the pre-/post-treatment clinical symptom score difference value between the treatment and control groups (P0.01). The total efficacy rate was 92.5% in the treatment group and 85.0% in the control group, with a statistically significant difference between the two groups (P0.05). The abstract does not report numbers for the immunoglobulin results, participant flow after enrolment, withdrawals, or harms. The setting was not reported, and no limitations were stated.
- [Impacts on chronic fatigue syndrome of qi deficiency syndrome and T cell subgroups in patients treated with acupuncture at selective time].2013 · randomised trial · 80 randomised
Summary
Eighty patients with chronic fatigue syndrome of qi deficiency syndrome were randomized into a selective-time-acupuncture group and an acupuncture group, 40 cases in each one. Qihai (CV 6), Guanyuan (CV 4), Hegu (LI 4), Taichong (LR 3), Sanyinjiao (SP 6) and Zusanli (ST 36) were selected in the two groups; in the selective-time-acupuncture group acupuncture was used at 9:00am to 11:00am, and in the acupuncture group at any time except in the range from 9:00am to 11:00am. Treatment was given once every day, 10 day treatment made one session and two sessions of treatment were required. The fatigue scale was adopted to evaluate the efficacy before and after treatment, and the ratios among CD3+, CD4+ and CD8+ T cells in the peripheral blood were detected before and after treatment. In the acupuncture group, the total score of fatigue and the score of physical fatigue were reduced after treatment as compared with those before treatment (all P<0.05). In the selective-time-acupuncture group, the total score of fatigue, the score of physical fatigue and the score of mental fatigue after treatment were reduced (all P<0. 01). The improvements in the scores of the selective-time-acupuncture group were superior to the acupuncture group (all P<0. 05). The total effective rate was 95.0% (38/40) in the selective-time-acupuncture group, which was better than 80.0% (32/40) in the acupuncture group (P<0.05). Side effects and withdrawals were not reported. The abstract does not state limitations.
- Clinical study on tuina and moxibustion for chronic fatigue syndrome2012 · randomised trial · 60 randomised
Summary
This randomized study asked whether tuina plus thunder-fire moxibustion affects chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). Sixty outpatients with CFS at the authors' hospital were randomized into two groups of 30. The treatment group received tuina and thunder-fire moxibustion, and the control group received ordinary acupuncture. Both were given once every other day, 3 treatments a week, for consecutive 4 weeks. After 4-week treatment, the study compared recovery rate and total effective rate, and recorded therapeutic effect categories (Recovery, Marked effective, Effective, Invalid). Recovery rate was 36.7% in the treatment group versus 16.7% in the control group; total effective rate was 93.3% versus 76.7%. The paper reports the between-group differences as statistically significant (P<0.01). In the treatment group, 11 were Recovery, 7 Marked effective, 10 Effective, and 2 Invalid; in the control group, 5 were Recovery, 7 Marked effective, 11 Effective, and 7 Invalid. Dropout was n=0 in each group. The paper states 'without adverse reactions.' The authors concluded: 'of the treatment of tuina and thunder-fire moxibustion has better therapeutic effect than the ordinary acupuncture in treating CFS.' Limitations were not reported.
- Clinical observation on acupuncture therapy for chronic fatigue syndrome2012 · randomised trial · 90 randomised
Summary
This clinical observation asked whether acupuncture improves chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) and anxiety. 90 CFS patients from the Acupuncture Department of the No.1 Hospital Affiliated to Guangzhou University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, treated from January, 2007 to April, 2008, were randomised using a random number table into two groups of 45. One group received acupuncture at Renying (ST 9), Fengfu (GV 16) and Baihui (GV 20), once every day, with 7 treatments constituting 1 course, for two treatment courses. The other received Shen Mai injection 20 mL added to 5% glucose solution 250 mL by intravenous drip one time per day for 15 d. The Self-rating Anxiety Scale (SAS) was measured before and after treatment. SAS scores decreased in both groups: acupuncture 48.6±6.16 to 42.91±5.40 and control 47.1±6.50 to 41.91±4.63, each P<0.01. After treatment there was no significant difference between the two groups (P>0.05). Harms and withdrawals were not reported. The authors state that after treatment SAS scores remained higher than the national norm and that improving anxiety needs long-term treatment in many aspects, including psychological care.
- Observations on the Efficacy of Thunder-fire Moxibustion plus Massotherapy in Treating Chronic Fatigue Syndrome2009 · randomised trial · 60 randomised
Summary
This abstract-only report describes a study of 60 patients with chronic fatigue syndrome. The aim was to investigate the efficacy of thunder-fire moxibustion plus massotherapy for treating chronic fatigue syndrome. Patients were randomly allocated to a treatment group of 30 cases (thunder-fire moxibustion plus massotherapy) and a control group of 30 cases (conventional acupuncture). The paper does not report the setting, treatment duration, or the number analysed. The therapeutic effects on the clinical symptoms were evaluated. The cure rate was 37.6% in the treatment group and 16.7% in the control group. The efficacy rate was 93.3% in the treatment group and 76.7% in the control group. The paper states there was a statistically significant difference between the two groups (P0.01). It does not report harms, side effects, or whether any participants stopped treatment. The authors conclude that the efficacy rate of thunder-fire moxibustion plus massotherapy is higher than that of conventional acupuncture in treating chronic fatigue syndrome. No limitations are stated.
- [A clinical trial of acupuncture for treating chronic fatigue syndrome in Hong Kong].2007 · randomised trial · 99 randomised
Summary
This single-blinded, randomized controlled trial in Hong Kong evaluated acupuncture for chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). The objective was to evaluate the efficacy of acupuncture in treating chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) in Hong Kong. The study included an effective sample size of 99, with 50 patients in the treatment group and 49 in the control group. Participants meeting inclusion criteria were randomly assigned to a treatment and a control group. Both groups received the same set of acupuncture points twice a week for 4 weeks; the treatment group received conventional needle acupuncture, while the control group received sham acupuncture without skin penetration. Outcomes concerned physical and mental fatigue and health-related quality of life (HQOL). Improvements in physical and mental fatigue and HQOL in both groups were observed, but the improvements in treatment group were significantly bigger than in control group (P<0.01 or P<0.05). Adverse events, if any, were recorded. No adverse events occurred. The text does not state limitations.
- [Clinical observation on effect of electro-acupuncture on back-shu points in treating chronic fatigue syndrome].2005 · randomised trial · 60 randomised
- Efficacy of Eszopiclone Plus Acupuncture Therapy by Dispersing the Stagnated Liver-Qi and Regulating the Spirit for Treating Chronic Fatigue Syndrome-Related Sleep Disorders.2025 · compared with another group · 107 in the study
Summary
This retrospective analysis included 107 patients with CFS-induced sleep disorders at Hainan Provincial People's Hospital from February 2021 to February 2023. The control group comprised 50 patients who received eszopiclone tablets 3 mg once daily before bedtime. The observation group comprised 57 patients who received the same eszopiclone plus acupuncture therapy by dispersing the stagnated liver-qi and regulating the spirit for 6 sessions per week for 5 consecutive weeks. Outcomes included PSQI scores, clinical overall response rate, serum 5-HT and BDNF levels, and adverse reactions. After treatment, PSQI scores decreased in both groups (P < .05), and post-treatment PSQI scores were lower in the observation group than the control group (P < .05). The abstract reports higher post-treatment serum 5-HT and BDNF levels in the observation group than the control group. Basic recovery was 61.40% in the observation group and 38.00% in the control group (P = .063); significant improvement was 31.58% in observation vs 46.00% in control; some improvement was 7.02% in observation vs 14.00% in control; no change was 2.00% in the control group. Total adverse reactions were 7.02% in the observation group and 22.00% in the control group (P = .026), with fatigue, dry mouth, headache, and decreased appetite each at 1.75% in the observation group; control decreased appetite was 8.00%, headache 6.00%, fatigue and dry mouth 4.00% each. There was no statistical difference in the incidence of headache, fatigue, dry mouth, or decreased appetite (P > .05). The authors state limitations include retrospective design, small sample size, and no follow-ups.
- The impact of "long COVID" on menstruation in Chinese female college students and the intervention of acupuncture.2024 · compared with another group · 731 in the study · 468 with outcome data
Summary
This cross-sectional study explored acupuncture for menstrual changes after long COVID in Chinese female college students. An online questionnaire was distributed by snowball sampling to students in multiple provinces and cities. Of 731 participants enrolled, 468 met analysis criteria; 85 fit the definition of long COVID. Among the 85, 69 (81.18%) reported changes in overall menstrual status compared with 6 months before COVID-19. Seventeen patients received acupuncture and 68 did not. The acupuncture group had fewer reported changes in menstrual cycle (7 [41.18%] vs 44 [64.71%]; OR 2.62), menstrual duration (7 [41.18%] vs 44 [64.71%]; OR 2.62), menstrual blood flow (8 [47.06%] vs 47 [69.18%]; OR 2.52) and menstrual blood color (7 [41.18%] vs 43 [63.24%]; OR 2.46). No harms or withdrawals were reported. The authors state limitations: the 68 subjects may have received other treatments, and acupuncture location, dosage and methods were not identified.
- Exploring the central mechanism of mind-regulation electroacupuncture in treatment of chronic fatigue syndrome with anxiety and depression comorbidity based on functional magnetic resonance imaging.2024 · compared with another group · 60 in the study · 49 with outcome data
Summary
This study examined mind-regulation electroacupuncture in chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) with anxiety and depression comorbidity. Sixty participants were enrolled: 30 CFS patients with anxiety and depression comorbidity from medical staffs formed the observation group, and 30 healthy medical university students matched for gender, age and education years formed the control group. The observation group received electroacupuncture at Sun's scalp emotional area and abdominal regions 1 and 8, with Baihui, Guanyuan and bilateral Zusanli and Sanyinjiao; continuous wave at 2 Hz, maximal tolerable intensity, 30 min per session, once daily for 6 consecutive days then 1 day rest, for 2 weeks (12 treatments). The control group received no acupuncture. Outcomes were MFI-20, SDS, SAS and PSQI before and after treatment, plus resting-state fMRI ReHo and functional connectivity. Forty-nine participants completed the trial: 26 in the observation group and 23 in the control group were analysed; 4 observation-group and 7 control-group participants dropped out, and the paper records poor compliance for these withdrawals (dropout rate 18.3%). Before treatment, the observation group scored higher than the control group on all five MFI-20 domains, MFI-20 total, SDS, SAS and PSQI (P<0.05). After treatment, except the MFI-20 reduced motivation domain, the other MFI-20 domains and total, SDS, SAS and PSQI were lower than before treatment in the observation group (P<0.05). ReHo increased in the right precuneus and decreased in the left inferior temporal gyrus and left angular gyrus after treatment. Harms were not reported. The authors state the sample was small and no control intervention, waiting-treatment or task-state group was set.
- [Tongtiao acupuncture-moxibustion method for 28 cases of long COVID-19 olfactory dysfunction].2025 · no comparison group · 28 in the study
Summary
This abstract-only report asked whether Tongtiao acupuncture-moxibustion method affects long COVID-19 olfactory dysfunction. It included 28 patients with long COVID-19 olfactory dysfunction; where they were recruited is not reported. All received Tongtiao acupuncture-moxibustion therapy (regulating orifices, invigorating the brain, and regulating qi and blood) at listed acupoints. Each treatment lasted 40 min, given once daily for 6 days per week, followed by a 1-day rest, over 4 consecutive weeks. No comparison group was reported; outcomes were compared before and after treatment. Measured outcomes were T&T olfactory test scores, each TCM symptom scores, Hamilton depression scale (HAMD) scores, and Hamilton anxiety scale (HAMA) scores, with clinical effect evaluated by T&T olfactory test grading. After treatment, T&T olfactory test scores, each TCM symptom scores, HAMD scores, and HAMA scores were decreased (P<0.01, P<0.05). The total effective rate was 96.4% (27/28). Side effects and withdrawals were not reported. The abstract does not state limitations.
- The Effectiveness of Acupuncture in The Treatment of Post COVID-19 Condition: A Retrospective Study2022 · no comparison group · 85 in the study
- Improvement in Long-COVID Symptoms Using Acupuncture: A Case Study.2022 · no comparison group
Summary
This observational case study reports a 46-year-old male with long-COVID syndrome (LCS). The paper describes acupuncture for this patient; the text does not report the acupuncture schedule, dose, duration or follow-up time. There was no comparison group, and the study was not randomised. The paper reports reduced symptoms and signs of LCS and states: "Acupuncture for this patient was associated with reduced symptoms and signs of LCS." No numerical symptom scores, no follow-up time, no side effects and no withdrawals for harms were reported. The authors also describe Traditional Chinese Medicine diagnostic patterns for this patient: Lung Qi and Yin Deficiency, Qi and Blood Stagnation, and Spleen Qi Deficiency with dampness. The authors conclude that a preliminary TCM diagnostic structure for LCS was defined and that acupuncture appears to have been helpful for a patient with LCS. They state that further research is needed to demonstrate the efficacy of acupuncture and/or other TCM modalities for LCS. They also state that empirical data about the range of symptoms or the utility of acupuncture alone for LCS are very limited. The text does not report enrolment, analysed numbers, setting, funding or conflicts.
- The search for pain relief in people with chronic fatigue syndrome: a descriptive study.2011 · no comparison group · 50 in the study
Summary
This descriptive, cross-sectional study asked people with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) who experienced pain which complementary/alternative medicine (CAM) and physiotherapy treatments they had tried for pain and how much benefit they perceived. 50 participants were recruited through CFS support groups across Scotland; interviews took place in their homes. 10 participants were severely affected. There was no comparison group; treatment duration and follow-up were not reported. At interview, 18 of 50 were currently receiving treatment for pain, and 3 were receiving physiotherapy. 45 participants reported previously trying 19 different CAM treatments. Acupuncture was the most frequently tried (23 participants); 14 reported benefit, and among 5 severely affected participants, 4 reported relief and 1 reported increased pain. Of 18 who tried massage, 5 reported reduced pain and 13 reported increased pain during treatment or worse the following day. Of 17 who tried reflexology, 9 reported increased pain and 4 found it beneficial. All who tried acupressure, lymphatic drainage, and hyperbaric oxygen reported improvements. 27 participants tried physiotherapy and reported 16 different interventions; spinal mobilisations, TENS, and ultrasound were reported to make no difference. 12 tried graded exercise therapy, and 11 stopped because it increased pain. For cognitive behaviour therapy, 11 reported benefit, 13 did not, and 22 refused. 41 of 50 were taking pain medication; 11 reported it eased pain, and Two were unable to take it due to side effects. Warm baths (29), heat applications (25), lying down/rest (22), and drinking water (17) were reported to ease pain.
- [Effect of electroacupuncture at Shenshu (BL 23) and Zusanli (ST 36) on the event-related potentials of chronic fatigue syndrome].2010 · no comparison group
Summary
This abstract reports a study of chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) that used dynamic detection of chronobiology to test event-related potentials in 20 healthy subjects and 20 CFS patients. The setting and recruitment location are not reported. CFS patients received electroacupuncture at Shenshu (BL 23) and Zusanli (ST 36); the duration of treatment is not reported. They were compared with healthy subjects. P3a and P3b latencies were collected and analyzed at 4 equidistant time points (8:00, 14:00, 20:00, 2:00) within 24 hours. The abstract reports that the circadian rhythm latency of P3b restored after treatment in the CFS patients; no statistical significance is reported for that statement. The authors conclude that event-related potential circadian rhythms are lost in CFS patients and that electroacupuncture at Shenshu (BL 23) and Zusanli (ST 36) can regulate the circadian rhythm of P3a and P3b latency and improve the cognition of the patients in daytime. Side effects, harms, withdrawals, worsening, and numbers analyzed are not reported. The abstract does not state limitations. No between-group result is recorded in the provided data.
- Potential application of brain-gut axis-based treatments in Long COVID and ME/CFS: a case-based systematic review.2026 · case report · 1 in the study
Summary
This case report and literature review describes one 33-year-old man with post-COVID ME/CFS admitted to Jaseng Hospital of Korean Medicine. He received vagal reflex stimulation via electroacupuncture of the deep peroneal nerve for 12 weeks (once daily for three consecutive weeks during hospitalization, then tapering). There was no comparison group. Fatigue was assessed with the Multidimensional Fatigue Inventory (total score 20–100) at baseline and at 4, 8 and 12 weeks, and flu-like symptom duration was self-recorded daily. Total MFI score declined from 71 to 31 (a reduction of more than 50%). General fatigue and reduced activity each fell −9 points; mental fatigue improved 63.6% (11 to 4) and reduced motivation 61.5% (13 to 5). General fatigue fell below the cut-off (< 13) at week 8 and reduced activity reached the threshold (< 10) at week 12. Daily flu-like symptom duration decreased from 557.1 ± 51.2 to 17.1 ± 15.8 min. Fluctuations at weeks 4 (282.9 ± 126.0 min) and 8 (285.7 ± 140.5 min) reflected transient, single-day symptom flares. No adverse events were observed. The authors state that lack of follow-up data precluded assessment of treatment durability, objective measures were not obtained, and few RCTs with small samples were included.
- Home Alone 2020: A First-Person Case Study on Surviving Modern Pandemics and their Aftermath of Illnesses2026 · case report · 1 in the study
Summary
This single-person case study reports the author’s ME/CFS course from 2010 to 2026, with no comparison group and no blinding. Treatments included Valtrex (valacyclovir) eight tablets a day throughout 2016; Xue-Fu-Zhu-Yu-Tang; weekly acupuncture for eighteen months; Lomatium dissectum started in July 2019 and taken daily; Oxymatrine (or Equilibrant); X39 phototherapy patches since summer 2020; concentrated oxygen ninety minutes a day over six months; and xylitol nasal spray since winter 2020. The author reports using laboratory results and her own observations, not a validated symptom scale. After only two weeks of Chinese herbs she had a brief and remarkable reprieve. After six weeks of acupuncture she went, in her case, from being bedridden and dying to dancing; after six months of weekly acupuncture she survived a short flight and reported dancing like a twenty year old. Weekly acupuncture over eighteen months revived her, but did not kill the viruses. Lomatium produced an immediate emotional response called a pathogen “die-off” and left her feeling lighter in body and spirit. Patches restored energy; concentrated oxygen coincided with improvements in pre-diabetes, allergies, arthrosis and breathing. Valtrex viral loads never dropped, and eight tablets a day made her very ill. Harms included not tolerating certain herbs or tablets and medication overload, elimination and withdrawal; she never had the Lomatium rash. The authors state the case cannot show causation.
- A Case Report of a Patient With Post-COVID-19 Dysphagia Who Required Antibiotics Following Intraoral Acupuncture.2025 · case report · 1 in the study
- Electroacupuncture for post-COVID proctodynia: a case report.2024 · case report
Summary
This is a case report, published as a letter, about electroacupuncture for proctodynia after COVID. The text available here is only the title and the publisher's access page, because the report itself is restricted. It does not say who was treated, how the electroacupuncture was given, for how long, what was measured or what happened afterwards, so no results and no side effects can be recorded from it.
- Long-COVID symptoms improved after MDMA and psilocybin therapy: A case report.2024 · case report
Summary
This case report describes a 41-year-old female with Long-COVID syndrome after contracting COVID-19 in February 2022. She self-medicated with psilocybin and MDMA under a therapist-recommended protocol. The first dosing session, on May 05, 2022, was 1 g of dried golden teacher psilocybin cubensis mushrooms; she reported a 20% improvement in depression, fatigue, joint pains, and headache for 7 days. The second session, 24 days later, was MDMA 125 mg followed 1 h later by 2 g of mushrooms in tea and 1 h later by a second 2 g of mushrooms in tea. After this session the patient reported significant improvement in post-COVID symptoms; headache frequency reduced to approximately once per week from a May 2022 baseline of 5 per week, duration decreased to less than 2–4 h per attack from a typical 8–12 h, and she rated symptom improvement approximately 80%. After another 2 g dose, symptoms abated to 90% relief. She later had an early November relapse, then after 2 g on November 24th reported complete resolution and returned to work 3 days later. Harms included chills and shivering with a sensation of being cold while “coming up” and transient nausea and emesis 40 min after ingestion. No comparison group was studied.
- Case Report: Acupuncture is an effective treatment for olfactory dysfunction in the post COVID-19 condition.2022 · case report · 2 in the study
Summary
This case report describes two patients with post COVID-19 condition and olfactory dysfunction who were referred to the authors' department. There was no comparison group. Both received acupuncture treatment at LI20 plus systemic points, with needles 30 mm long and 0.16 mm in diameter inserted about 10 mm deep, scheduled 1–2 times a week. Both also received Kampo prescriptions (Kamikihito in case 1; Ninjin'yoeito in case 2). Olfactory dysfunction was rated on an NRS from 0 to 10. In case 1, the NRS decreased from 10 to 6 immediately after acupuncture; after a total of eight sessions the patient still had an NRS score of 9. After LI20 was added at the ninth session, the NRS was reduced to 4 immediately after treatment and maintained at 7 after 2–3 days. In case 2, the baseline NRS was 3; after the second and third treatments there was a rapid reduction to an NRS score of 0, and later the patient's olfactory dysfunction eased to an NRS score of 0–1. The abstract reports improvement lasting 2–4 days; case 1's reduction lasted 2–3 days before flare-up, and case 2's lasted 3–4 days. Malaise also improved but flared the next day. No adverse reactions were observed.
- Proceedings #19. Maintenance tDCS: A Case of Full and Durable Recovery from Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME/CFS)2017 · case report · 1 in the study
Summary
This conference proceeding reports a case report of one 61-year-old man with treatment-resistant progressive ME/CFS who was referred for neuromodulation. There was no comparison group. He was trained in the office and then self-administered tDCS at home daily, with anode on the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, cathode on the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, 2 mA/min, 20 minutes, 40 mA total dose, using 1.5” diameter electrode pads. After four weeks, sessions were increased to twice daily (6 AM and 12 Noon). Modafinil 200 mg provided partial relief of fatigue; later the dose was lowered to 100 mg due to insomnia, and modafinil was stopped but resumed at 100 mg daily after he felt less well. The paper reports one year of maintenance tDCS and follow-up neurophysiological studies 14 months after initial presentation. It reports significant benefit early in the day during the first month of daily tDCS, consistent benefit after twice-daily sessions, and full clinical recovery over the next few months, with improved exercise tolerance and a return to physical exercise several times each week. Before treatment, omission errors were 14.29%; after treatment, behavioral measures were within the normal rage and there were no omission errors. The patient reported sustained relief. The authors state that data were not shown for frontocentral infra-slow frequency drift.
- Case Report of Chronic Fatigue Syndrome Treated with Salt-Indirect Moxibustion2012 · case report · 1 in the study
Summary
This case report describes one 53-year-old man with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) who visited an Oriental hospital with chronic and severe fatigue. He was treated as an outpatient every day for 14 days with indirect moxibustion on three acupoints, KD1, CV4 and CV8, for 30 minutes daily; the moxa corn consisted of 3.5 g of wormwood fiber. He also received acupuncture (mainly at HT7, LI4, SP3) and a herbal drug (Myelophil, twice per day). There was no comparison group; outcomes were self-reported before and after treatment. VAS and NRS were recorded on Day 1, Day 7 and Day 14. The abstract and results text report VAS and NRS changed from 8.5 and 70 to 3.5 and 35, respectively; Table 1 and the Discussion print the final VAS as 3.3. Table 1 shows NRS 70 on Day 1, 53 on Day 7, and 35 on Day 14, and VAS 8.5, 6.1, and 3.3. The report states fatigue feeling and related-symptoms were radically reduced by 14-day treatment, and other physical and mental activities improved. Harms, worsening, and withdrawals were not reported. The authors state that further study needs to verify the therapeutic effects of moxibustion on CFS and its mechanisms using more subjects, and that this case study didn’t measure biomarkers for oxidative stress and antioxidants.
- The treatment of Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME, CFS) with Acupuncture2010 · case report · 1 in the study
Summary
This single case report (n=1) describes a 27-year-old woman with myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME) or chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). She received acupuncture and moxa: needling at points St36, Kid3, Liv3, and Ren6 plus a moxa stick, with Yintang needled if feeling stressed. She was also advised to keep warm and eat warm, easily digestible foods. There was no comparison group. Outcomes reported were energy, needing to sleep in the afternoon, feeling cold, and aching. The report states that she began to feel more energy straight away. After 4 treatments she was having to sleep less in the afternoon. After 8 treatments she hardly ever had to sleep in the afternoon and had much more energy. She also felt less cold and ached less. No side effects, harms, or withdrawals were reported. The paper does not report study design, setting, randomisation, blinding, funding, or treatment duration. Follow-up is reported as after 8 treatments. The authors state no limitations.
- Acupuncture Treatment for an Adolescent with Chronic Fatigue Syndrome2008 · case report · 1 in the study
Summary
This Case Report described one 14-year-old girl with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) who presented with extreme fatigue and insomnia. The authors reported the case as unique because a literature search did not reveal the use of acupuncture for a young person with chronic fatigue syndrome. She received acupuncture once a week for 6 weeks; each treatment lasted 30 minutes, and needle penetration was 1–2 mm. There was no comparison group. After 2 treatments, the patient was able to sleep at night. After 3 treatments, she was able to attend daytime home school class without fatigue. After 5 treatments, she returned to regular school classes and was able to resume normal daily activities with her peers and siblings. After 6 treatments, she graduated from eighth grade and entered high school. The quality of life for the patient and her family significantly improved. No complications were noted. The authors stated that further research is needed to confirm these findings and evaluate the positive outcome.
- Clinical observation on the effects of Bo's abdominal acupuncture in 40 cases of chronic fatigue syndrome.2008 · case report · 40 in the study
Summary
The study aimed to observe Bo’s abdominal acupuncture in 40 outpatients with chronic fatigue syndrome diagnosed in reference to American Center for Disease Control and Prevention criteria. Bo’s abdominal acupuncture was given at Zhongwan (CV 12), Xiawan (CV 10), Qihai (CV 6), Guanyuan (CV 4), Huaroumen (ST 24) and Wailing (ST 26) with disposable stainless steel filiform needles (32 gauges, 1.5 cun long); needles were retained for 30 min, once a day for 2 weeks. Scores for symptoms and a fatigue questionnaire were compared before and after treatment; there was no comparison group. Scores for total symptoms fell from 16.36±0.43 to 6.02±1.25 (P<0.01), and total fatigue scores from 87.22±13.28 to 53.23±15.93 (P<0.01). Lassitude fell from 25.98±3.68 to 5.73±4.39 (P<0.01), pain in muscles, joints, neck, back, shoulders and arms from 26.56±4.36 to 7.39±5.32 (P<0.01), insomnia from 24.30±5.60 to 10.55±4.22 (P<0.01), anorexia from 26.90±6.48 to 8.56±2.21 (P<0.01), and diarrhea from 14.46±2.98 to 5.22±1.86 (P<0.01). Dizziness (11.55±1.38 to 8.95±2.66) and lymphadenectasis (9.08±1.55 to 7.35±2.18) were reported lower without stated significance. Side effects and withdrawals were not reported. No limitations are stated.
- Acupuncture in the treatment of post viral fatigue syndrome--a case report.2005 · case report · 1 in the study
Summary
This case report describes one 27 year old PE teacher in general practice with post viral fatigue syndrome/chronic fatigue syndrome. Acupuncture was given at weekly intervals initially. The first treatment was deep needling at LI4, LI11, LR3 and ST36 bilaterally for 15 minutes with no manual or electrical stimulation. From the second treatment, electroacupuncture was given at LI11 and ST36 for 15 minutes at a dense-dispersed frequency (2/80Hz), with LR3 needled bilaterally without stimulation; from the third treatment the duration of stimulation was increased to 30 minutes. The patient rated symptoms on a visual analogue scale (VAS) of 0-10 and kept symptom and work diaries. After the second treatment the report states an excellent response, with symptoms improved and return to work on alternate half days, nine till noon. By the fourth treatment her VAS score had fallen to three; by the fifth it was 1-2 and she was working four half days per week. After the sixth treatment she worked daily until 2pm with a VAS score of three. At review on 27/9/04 she remained well, although not quite back to normal, and was working three full days and two half days. The report states she remained well some eight months after starting treatment. She deteriorated slightly for three days after the first treatment then improved slightly for two days, although tiredness remained unchanged. There was no comparison group.
- Chronic fatigue syndrome and women: can therapy help?1992 · case report · 1 in the study
Summary
This paper reports a case study of one woman, “Claire,” with chronic fatigue syndrome and Epstein-Barr virus, in psychotherapy with the author. She received insight-oriented psychotherapy; treatment lasted three years. There was no comparison group. The paper reports that psychotherapy helped Claire. It reports that psychotherapy apparently helped her alleviate longstanding symptoms of depression, that her emotional life became calmer, more manageable, and more satisfying, that she had more insight into her previous needs to achieve professionally, and that she was beginning to see her life as approximating “normal” again in terms of health and lack of symptoms. For health over the first 24 months of treatment, the paper reports that her health would appear to improve and then all of a sudden deteriorate. Reported harms include that her health deteriorated during treatment to the point that she felt she had to quit her job, and that she would have a week of overwhelming fatigue and then need complete bedrest. The authors state that it cannot be generalized that insight therapy can help all victims of chronic fatigue syndrome.
- Factors involved in the improvement of prolonged symptoms in patients with COVID-19 treated with Japanese traditional (Kampo) medicine: A single-center, prospective, observational study.2026 · combination: given with other treatments · 128 in the study · 114 with outcome data
Summary
This single-center, prospective, observational study in Japan enrolled 128 consecutive patients with prolonged symptoms of COVID-19; 114 were analysed. Patients received a symptom-selected regimen that included Kampo formulas (HET, JTT, NYT, BRIHK, yokukansan, TSS, KOSS) and other treatments such as a proton pump inhibitor, acupuncture and moxibustion, zinc preparation, and antihistamines. No control treatment group was included. Outcomes were performance status (PS ≤ 2) and the end-of-visit milestone. In 3 months, 75 (65.8%) patients achieved PS ≤ 2 and 36 (31.6%) achieved the end-of-visit milestone. At 6 months, 60 of 76 patients (78.9%) achieved PS ≤ 2 and 51 of 78 patients (67.9%) achieved the end-of-visit milestone. The group with first-visit general fatigue at or above the median took more time to achieve PS ≤ 2 (hazard ratio 0.405 [0.253–0.650]) and the end-of-visit milestone (0.283 [0.150–0.532]) than the below-median group. The ≥90 days group reached the end-of-visit milestone later (0.510 [0.267–0.974]) than the <90 days group. There were 5 (4.4%) adverse events; 2 patients had liver dysfunction caused by HET or JTT, and both improved after discontinuing the drug.
- Explainable machine learning model and nomogram for predicting the efficacy of Traditional Chinese Medicine in treating Long COVID: a retrospective study.2025 · combination: given with other treatments · 2,067 in the study · 1,331 with outcome data
Summary
This retrospective study asked whether Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) treatment outcomes in Long COVID could be predicted. Data were extracted from 2,067 Long COVID patients treated with TCM between December 2022 and February 2024 at three hospitals in Zhejiang, China; 1,331 patients were analysed. All analysed patients received a sequential TCM therapy over a 14-day period, including CRPRF and YTRF herbal prescriptions and thumb-tack acupuncture at named points. There was no comparison group. Treatment outcome was assessed after 14 days as improvement in two or more clinical symptoms or a minimum 2-point increase in the Traditional Chinese Medicine Syndrome Score (TCMSS). The study reported that 1,155 patients were classified as effective and 176 as ineffective. The paper also reported that patients with a lower lymphocyte ratio responded better to TCM treatment than those with a higher ratio, and that patients with chest tightness and aversion to cold showed a better response than those without these symptoms. The text did not report side effects, worsening, stopping, or withdrawals. The authors state that all case data came from Zhejiang Province, China, so caution is needed when applying results to other regions.
- Integrative personalized medicine care for adjustment disorder of a post-COVID-19 patient: A CARE-compliant case report.2024 · combination: given with other treatments · 1 in the study
Summary
This CARE-compliant case report describes one 84-year-old female patient with adjustment disorder of post-COVID-19 syndrome who visited a traditional Korean Medicine hospital in Seoul, Republic of Korea, in August 2023. There was no comparison group. Treatment was integrative personalized medicine care: conventional Western drugs (ethyl loflazepate, agomelatine, mosapride, pancreatin, simethicone, tegoprazan), herbal medicines (Chowiseungcheong-tang, Cheongsimyeonja-tang, Bosimgunbi-tang, Cheonghyulganggi-tang), acupuncture (18 sessions, 20 minutes each) and moxibustion. The patient had a 10-day inpatient treatment followed by outpatient treatments 2 to 3 times a week after discharge. Assessments were at week 1, week 7 and week 16 from start of treatment. HAM-D scores decreased from 13 to 3 at week 7; BDI from 27 to 5 at week 7 and from 5 to 4 at week 16; Patient Health Questionnaire-9 from 20 to 1 at week 7 and week 16; ISI from 23 to 5 at week 7. Sleep changed from taking 1 to 3 hours to fall asleep and waking 5 to 6 times to 8 hours of restful sleep on the day of taking CSYJ-tang. EQ-5D-5L changed from 7 to 0 and EQ-VAS from 50 to 90 at week 16. HRV score changed from 62 to 73, and was 71 at follow-up on November 7, 2023. Gastrointestinal symptoms and palpitations disappeared. Harms and withdrawals for harms were not reported. The authors state limitations including no polysomnography, thyroid test, or vitamin B12 test.
- "An integrative approach with Ayurveda and Traditional Chinese Acupuncture in post covid parosmia - A case study".2023 · combination: given with other treatments · 1 in the study
Summary
This single case report describes a 20-year-old female with post covid parosmia after SARS-CoV-2 infection; the setting is not reported. There was no comparison group. Treatment was an integrative Ayurveda and Traditional Chinese Acupuncture approach: Nasya with Shadbindu taila, eight Bindu (4 ml) into each nostril in the morning for seven days; acupuncture in the afternoon for 20 min duration for seven days; Naradiya laxmivilasa rasa one tablet (250 mg) orally thrice daily after food for one month; and Pratimarsha nasya with Shadbindu taila, two Bindu (1 ml) into each nostril thrice daily from day eight to the end of four months. Outcomes were Indian Smell identification test score, VAS for parosmia, severity analysis, and quality of life. ISIT was zero before treatment, four on day seven, eight after one month, and ten after four months. VAS was ten before treatment and zero on day seven, after one month, and after four months. Severity analysis was severe alterations before treatment and normal at all follow-up points. The paper reports considerable improvement in quality of life in terms of sleep, food intake and psychological stress, and the authors inferred there would be no side effects by this unique integrative approach. No limitations are stated.
- Einsatz von Akupunktur bei Long Covid Use of acupuncture in long COVID2022 · combination: given with other treatments · 1 in the study
Summary
This single case report describes a 32-year-old woman who developed Long Covid after Covid-19 in March 2020. Three months after infection she presented with thoracic stinging, tightness, palpitations, fatigue, and exertional dyspnea. She received acupuncture at points including Lu 5, Mi 9, Mi 6, Ma 36, Gb 41, 3E, Le 3, He 7, and PaM 3, with cupping on the posterior thorax at the beginning of treatments. Sessions were scheduled regularly every 1–2 weeks. No comparison group was used. Outcomes reported: after she stopped cycling due to a massive worsening of symptoms, her complaints improved quickly; after 6 weeks she could begin light home workouts and short bicycle rides; after 10 weeks she felt well resilient and was symptom-free. No adverse effects from acupuncture or cupping are reported. The authors state the treatment approach was the first patient they saw for Long Covid and discuss typical Qi deficiency; they do not report formal limitations.
- Effects of Korean Medicine Treatment in Post-acute COVID-19 Syndrome: A Retrospective Case Series of 15 Patients2022 · combination: given with other treatments · 15 in the study
Summary
This retrospective case series described clinical features and before/after outcomes of Korean medicine treatment for post-acute COVID-19 syndrome. It included 15 patients who visited the outpatient Allergy, Immune, and Respiratory System Department at Kyung Hee University Korean Medicine Hospital from January 10, 2021 to April 10, 2022. Herbal medicine was prescribed for all 15 patients; acupuncture and cupping were performed in 4 patients (26.7%) each, and electroacupuncture in 1 patient (6.7%). Treatment lasted a minimum of 26 days, a maximum of 148 days, and an average of 77.9±31.1 days. There was no comparison group. Outcomes were NRS, mMRC, LCQ, QOL-VAS, and PCFS before and after treatment. NRS was available in 5 patients (33.3%), and all decreased; mMRC in 3 (20%), all to 0; LCQ in 4 (26.7%), all increased. QOL-VAS was available in 6 (40%): 2 were unchanged and 4 increased. PCFS was available in all 15: 2 were unchanged and 13 decreased. Adverse events occurred in 2 patients (13.3%): 1 had dyspepsia, and 1 had dyspepsia and headache; events were mild, and both improved after herbal medicine dose reduction.
- A Case Report on the Use of Korean Medicine Treatment of a Patient with Post Covid-19 Syndrome of Fatigue and Headache2022 · combination: given with other treatments · 1 in the study
Summary
This case report described one 52-year-old male patient with headache and chronic fatigue who was diagnosed with post-acute COVID-19 syndrome. He also had sweating and insomnia. He was treated with acupuncture and herbal medicines such as Sasammaekmoondong-tang; the treatment duration was not reported. There was no comparison group, and the report does not describe randomisation, blinding, or a control intervention. Outcomes concerned the Fatigue Severity Scale (FSS) and clinical symptoms. Following treatment, the FSS score dropped from 48 at the first visit to 18 at the final visit, and the report states that fatigue improved. The report also states that clinical symptoms such as headache and insomnia disappeared. The final visit was the reported follow-up point. Harms, side effects, and withdrawals were not reported. The authors conclude that, according to the findings of this study, Korean Medicine could be used in the clinic to treat post-COVID-19 complications. The text does not state limitations.
- Acupuncture in multidisciplinary treatment of post-COVID-19 Syndrome: A Case Report2022 · combination: given with other treatments · 1 in the study · preprint
Summary
This case report described one 50-year-old woman with post-COVID syndrome after mild assay-confirmed COVID-19, referred from a Long-COVID Clinic to an outpatient hospital-affiliated acupuncturist with 8 months of fatigue, anosmia, chest pressure, palpitations, and other symptoms. She received 7 sessions of scalp, auricular, and body acupuncture, recommended weekly with 30-minute needle retention. Symptom-titrated physical activity led by a physical therapist began 1-week post-acupuncture, involving six 30-minute exercise sessions while heart rate was monitored, with as-needed rest. The report measured the patient’s symptom reports and function over treatment and follow-up. Chest pressure and palpitations resolved after 1 acupuncture treatment. With 6 additional treatments spanning 9 weeks, overlapping with physical therapist-led STPA, the patient completely recovered and resumed normal exercise habits. The patient was doing well without PCS relapse 1-month later. Thirty-minute needle retention with De Qi twisting and lifting techniques was well-tolerated. The authors noted that the independent effects of acupuncture were less clear because STPA/exercise therapy was concurrent, and they stated limitations including lack of standardized patient-reported outcome assessments, that repeat testing could have evaluated sequential changes, that recovery could be explained by natural history, and that findings may not be broadly generalizable.
- [Clinical research of auricular gold-needle therapy in treatment of chronic fatigue syndrome of qi deficiency constitution].2019 · combination: given with other treatments · 120 in the study
Summary
This randomised study enrolled 120 patients with chronic fatigue syndrome of qi deficiency constitution, with 40 cases in each of three treatment groups: auricular gold-needle therapy, auricular point pressure therapy, and a Chinese herb group. A separate health control group of 40 cases received no intervention. In the gold-needle group, a gold needle stimulated auricular points on one side and cowherb seed pressure was used on the other side; the pressure group received cowherb seed pressure on one side only. Both had treatment once a week, 4 treatments as one course, with 3 consecutive courses required. The herb group took buzhong yiqi wan orally, 6 g twice a day, with 1 month as one session and 3 consecutive sessions required. Clinical symptom score and serum IgA, IgG and IgM were observed before and after treatment, and therapeutic effects were evaluated. The total effective rate was 90.0% (36/40) in the gold-needle group, 80.0% (32/40) in the pressure group and 82.5% (33/40) in the herb group; the abstract reports the gold-needle rate as better than the other two. Harms and withdrawals are not reported. No limitations are stated in the abstract.
- A case of chronic fatigue syndrome improved by traditional Korean medicine.2013 · combination: given with other treatments · 1 in the study
Summary
This case report described one 33-year-old woman with chronic fatigue syndrome who attended an Oriental hospital with severe and persisting fatigue over 3 years. She received traditional Korean medicine: Samchulgunbitang and Myelophil herbal drugs, salt-indirect moxibustion on three acupoints (KD1, CV4 and CV8), and acupuncture mainly at HT7, LI4 and SP3. Treatment was inpatient for 7 days and outpatient for 3 months. There was no comparison group; outcomes were before-and-after ratings. Fatigue severity was measured with a numerical rating scale (NRS) and a visual analog scale (VAS). Total NRS was 70 at Day 0, 58 at Day 7, and 37 at Day 97; VAS was 8.1, 6.2, and 3.7 at the same times. The paper reported that NRS and VAS scores significantly improved to 37 and 3.7 over 3 months. After a 7-day hospitalization, the patient subjectively reported a notable improvement in fatigue-related symptoms; severe anorexia moderately improved, and she regained confidence regarding her physical health and mental attitude. Harms and withdrawals were not reported.
- Therapeutic Observation on Acupuncture plus Tuina for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome2013 · combination: given with other treatments · 100 randomised
Summary
This randomized controlled trial enrolled 100 CFS patients, with 52 in a treatment group and 48 in a control group. The objective was to observe the clinical efficacy of acupuncture and tuina in treating chronic fatigue syndrome(CFS). The treatment group received acupuncture plus tuina; the control group received intravenous injection of Shengmai injection. Doses, schedules, and treatment duration are not reported. The groups were compared in therapeutic efficacy and co-morbid symptom scores. The total effective rate was 96.2% in the treatment group versus 83.3% in the control group, and the difference was statistically significant(P0.05). The two groups both had significant changes of component and general scores of co-morbid symptoms after treatment(P0.01). The differences between the two groups in the component and general scores of co-morbid symptoms after treatment were statistically significant(P0.05). The abstract does not report setting, follow-up, or the number analysed. Randomisation method, allocation concealment, and blinding are not reported. Harms, withdrawals for harms, and worsening or stopping are not reported. The abstract reports no limitations.
- Observation on therapeutic effect of chronic fatigue syndrome treated with Panlongci (coiling dragon needling) and moving cupping on back2012 · combination: given with other treatments · 72 randomised
Summary
This study compared Panlongci (coiling dragon needling) plus moving cupping on the back with oral prednisone in people with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). Seventy-two cases were randomly divided into an acupuncture-cupping group (37 cases) and a prednisone group (35 cases). Patients came from the out-patient department of People's Hospital of Danyang City and TCM Hospital of Jianggan District of Hangzhou City between September 2008 and September 2010. The acupuncture-cupping group received Panlongci at Jiaji points (EX-B 2) once a day, plus moving cupping on the back every 2 days. The prednisone group took prednisone tablets 10 mg orally each morning at 8:00, once a day. Seven days counted as one treatment course, and 2 courses were carried out. The FS-14 scale and Bell's CFS integral table were used to assess fatigue before and after treatment. After one course, Bell's scores improved in both groups (both P<0.01) but did not differ significantly between groups (P>0.05). After 2 courses, the Bell's score improved more in the acupuncture-cupping group than in the prednisone group (P<0.05). The total effective rate was 91.9% (34/37) in the acupuncture-cupping group and 71.4% (25/35) in the prednisone group (P<0.05). Side effects and withdrawals were not reported. The authors state that the comprehensive mechanism remains to be studied.
- Solar-Term Acupuncture and Moxibustion for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome2011 · combination: given with other treatments · 75 randomised
Summary
Seventy-five patients with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) were randomly equally divided into 3 groups: solar-term acupuncture and moxibustion (SAM), 7d group, and control. The prescription was injection of VB-12 with 1ml at Ganshu (BL18), Pishu (BL20) and Shenshu (BL23) of both sides; warming acupuncture at Guanyuan (RN4), Zhongwan (RN12), and both Zusanli (ST36); and sliding cupping on the back. It was applied once a day for 24 times altogether as a course, for SAM on the day of solar-term and for the 7d group on the day after the solar-term day specified for that group; the control group received no treatment. Outcomes were clinical symptoms and Fatigue Assessment Instrument (FAI), Self-rating Depression Scale (SDS), and Self-rating Anxiety Scale (SAS). The abstract reports that the difference in effect after therapy among the 3 groups was statistically significant (P0.05); FAI, SDS and SAS in the solar-term and 7d groups were significantly improved after therapy with statistical difference (P0.05), and results showed statistical difference compared with control (P0.05); FAI, SDS and SAS scores between solar-term and 7d groups were also statistically different (P0.05). Side effects, withdrawals, number analysed per group, and follow-up were not reported. Setting was not reported. The abstract states no limitations.
- Acupuncture treatment of chronic fatigue syndrome.2009 · combination: given with other treatments · 1 in the study · abstract
Summary
This case history reports one female patient, a Hong Kong resident, diagnosed as having chronic fatigue syndrome. The paper describes acupuncture treatment given for the patient, with needles retained for 30 minutes each time; cupping was also used at Xinshu (BL 15), Geshu (BL 17), Ganshu (BL 18), Pishu (BL 20), Weishu (BL 21) and Shenshu (BL 23). Altogether, 50 treatments were given, with a 3-month follow-up period. There was no comparison group. The paper reports that after 5 treatments the symptoms were slightly improved. After 10 treatments, the patient could walk for 15 minutes without fatigue and had an improved mental state. After 2 courses of treatment, dizziness and weakness of the loins and legs were improved. After 10 more treatments, fatigue and heaviness in the head and lower limbs were further alleviated. During treatment, cupping made the patient feel comfortable throughout the whole body. Altogether, 50 treatments were given; the patient was in a very good condition after a 3-month follow-up period. The paper does not report harms, side effects, or withdrawals. The paper states that acupuncture is good at regulating the functions of the whole body and can be adopted for clinical treatment of CFS. No limitations are stated.
- Chronic fatigue syndrome treated by acupuncture and moxibustion in combination with psychological approaches in 310 cases.2007 · combination: given with other treatments · 310 in the study
Summary
This study examined acupuncture plus moxibustion combined with a psychological approach for chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). The treatment was given based on differentiation of symptoms and signs in 310 cases. The abstract reports no comparison group, no randomisation and no blinding. The setting, duration of treatment and follow-up were not reported. The treatment components as printed were acupuncture, moxibustion and a psychological approach. Of 310 cases observed, 275 cases (88.7%) were clinically cured, 28 cases (9%) improved and 7 cases (2.3%) failed. The number enrolled was 310 and the number analysed was 310. The abstract reports these clinical therapeutic effect categories only, with no patient-rated scales or laboratory measures and no time point. Harms were not reported, and the abstract gives no information on side effects, on people stopping treatment, or on withdrawals for any reason. The authors' conclusion is recorded separately, and the abstract states no limitations.
- The therapeutic effects of electrical acupuncture and auricular-plaster in 32 cases of chronic fatigue syndrome.2006 · combination: given with other treatments · 64 randomised
Summary
This abstract reports a randomised controlled trial that aimed “To observe the therapeutic effects of electrical acupuncture and auricular-plaster therapy for chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS).” The study enrolled 64 CFS patients: “64 CFS patients were randomly divided into two groups.” The treatment group had 32 cases and received electrical acupuncture and auricular-plaster therapy; the control group had 32 cases and received oral hydrocortisone. The abstract does not report dose, schedule, treatment duration, follow-up, setting, or where patients were from. It also does not state how many patients were analysed. The measured outcome was “total effective rates.” The abstract reports that “The total effective rates were respectively 93.75% in the treatment group and 75.00% in the control group,” with “a statistically significant difference between the two groups (P < 0.05).” It does not report any other outcome, any worsening, any discontinuation, or any side effects. Harms and withdrawals are not reported. The authors conclude that “Electrical acupuncture and auricular-plaster therapy may show a better anti-fatigue effect than that of routine Western drugs.” The abstract does not state limitations.
- PSYCHONEUROLOGICAL THERAPY FOR POST-COVID SYNDROME: A COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW OF METHODS AND CLINICAL EFFECTIVENESS.2026 · systematic review
Summary
Review of psychoneurological therapies for post-COVID syndrome in adults with persistent cognitive, emotional or neurological symptoms. No new participants were enrolled; eligible randomized controlled trials, observational studies and clinical reports published up to 2024 were summarized narratively. The review describes SSRIs, SNRIs, anxiolytics, antipsychotics, nootropics, CBT and psychodynamic therapy, mindfulness, physiotherapy and exercise, breathing, massage, acupuncture, social rehabilitation, TMS and ECT. It reports that in a randomized clinical trial (2021), SSRIs reduced depression and anxiety in 150 PCS patients, with 60% improving on the Hamilton scale after 12 weeks; venlafaxine improved cognitive function and reduced anxiety in 80 patients compared with placebo. CBT produced marked improvement in 65% after 8 weeks, and a 60% reduction in post-traumatic symptoms was observed in another CBT study. Acupuncture was followed by substantial improvement in 65%, social rehabilitation helped 75% regain social and occupational abilities, and physiotherapy improved endurance and reduced chronic fatigue in 80%. Harms mentioned include risk of dependence with benzodiazepines, mild headaches or localized discomfort with TMS, and short-term memory loss or cognitive disturbances with ECT. The authors state that individualized, combined strategies are most effective; they note that each strategy has limitations and requires further research.
- Comparative effectiveness of non-pharmacological traditional Chinese medicine therapies for chronic fatigue syndrome: a systematic review and network meta-analysis.2026 · systematic review
Summary
This systematic review and network meta-analysis asked whether non-pharmacological traditional Chinese medicine therapies help adults with chronic fatigue syndrome. It included 29 studies with 2,234 participants; searches covered Web of Science, Embase, PubMed, Scopus, CINAHL, Cochrane Library, CNKI, Wan Fang, VIP Database, and SinoMed to January 1, 2026. Treatments included acupuncture, moxibustion, massage, cupping, scraping, qigong, and acupoint application, compared with conventional care or inert treatment. Outcomes were overall fatigue, physical fatigue, mental fatigue, sleep quality, anxiety, and depression. Treatment lengths varied across the included studies; no overall duration was reported in the recorded data. For overall fatigue (24 studies, 1,789 patients), moxibustion was associated with a reduction versus conventional care (SMD, −1.84; 95% CI, −2.25 to −1.44). For physical fatigue (13 studies, 1,051 patients), massage was associated with reduced physical fatigue (SMD, −2.21; 95% CI, −2.65 to −1.77); for mental fatigue (13 studies, 1,051 patients), massage was associated with reduced mental fatigue (SMD, −2.05; 95% CI, −3.07 to −1.02). For anxiety (6 studies, 574 patients), massage was associated with reduced anxiety (SMD, −3.35; 95% CI, −6.64 to −0.05); for depression (7 studies, 631 patients), massage was associated with reduced depression (SMD, −1.23; 95% CI, −1.76 to −0.69). For sleep quality (9 studies, 687 patients), cupping showed the greatest improvement versus conventional care (SMD, −4.60; 95% CI, −7.05 to −2.15). Side effects, withdrawals, and people who worsened were not reported in the recorded data. The authors state limitations including heterogeneity, risk of bias, and small trials.
- Effectiveness of physical, psychological, and alternative interventions for post-COVID-19 condition: a systematic review.2026 · systematic review
Summary
This systematic review asked whether supervised physical, psychological and alternative non-pharmacological treatments help adults with post-COVID-19 condition. It included 27 randomized trials with 1,998 participants; trials were supervised and face-to-face and compared interventions with usual care, placebo/sham or active comparators. Interventions included cardiopulmonary rehabilitation, multimodal and unimodal exercise, CBT and lifestyle programmes, neuromodulation, oxygen therapies, acupuncture and balneotherapy. Intervention durations varied. The review reported that cardiopulmonary rehabilitation and multimodal exercise consistently improved cardiorespiratory fitness and walking capacity; CBT and lifestyle adjustments significantly reduced fatigue and subjective concentration complaints. Examples recorded: in 114 participants, CBT lowered CIS-fatigue by a between-group mean difference of −8.8 points (95% CI −11.9 to −5.8); in 70 participants, active HD-tDCS plus rehabilitation lowered MFIS total fatigue by a between-group difference of −14.03 points (95% CI −20.28 to −7.78). Findings for neuromodulation, complementary and oxygen therapies were heterogeneous, often showing no benefit over placebo. For example, HBOT did not produce significantly greater improvements than sham on any primary or secondary outcome. Side effects and withdrawals were not reported in the recorded data. The authors state that the evidence does not support definitive conclusions about the effectiveness of any intervention category.
- Effect of nonpharmacologic therapies on depressive symptoms in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome: a network meta-analysis.2025 · systematic review
Summary
This network meta-analysis examined nonpharmacologic therapies for depressive symptoms in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). The authors searched PubMed, Cochrane Library, Web of Science, Embase, CNKI, Wanfang, CBM, VIP, and Sinomed for randomized controlled trials until March 26, 2025, and included 47 RCTs involving 4,028 participants. The review compared nonpharmacologic interventions with control conditions and measured depression or depressive symptoms with scales. Compared with control, the review reports significant differences for acupuncture (SMD = -1.91, 95% CI: -2.9 to -0.94), moxibustion (SMD = -2.91, 95% CI: -4.61 to -1.22), Tuina (SMD = -2, 95% CI: -3.64 to -0.38), diet therapy (SMD = -5.64, 95% CI: -8.98 to -2.29), electrical stimulation (SMD = 1.9, 95% CI: 0.03 to 3.78), Ap + Mox (SMD = 2.53, 95% CI: 1.17 to 3.91), and Ap + Mox + Ae (SMD = 3.16, 95% CI: 0.39 to 5.98). The review states that relaxation therapy, AER, RT, and Qigong did not markedly improve depressive symptoms, and psychotherapy did not show significant effects. Harms were not reported as counts; the review includes a statement that graded exercise therapy may exacerbate symptoms in certain CFS patients, a statement about exercise therapy, the patient’s energy limit, characteristic post-exertional malaise (PEM), and efficacy, and a statement that Tuina has no adverse reactions. The authors state heterogeneity, inconsistent depression scales, and medium risk of bias in most included studies, with some interventions from few small studies, so results should be viewed with caution.
- The efficacy of acupuncture-based chinese medicine in chronic fatigue syndrome: A meta-analysis.2025 · systematic review
Summary
This systematic review and meta-analysis examined acupuncture for chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). The search dated from 2010 to October 2023 and included 9 studies. The authors describe the review as studying acupuncture’s effect on fatigue, functional mobility, and mental health, though the recorded outcomes are FSS at 5 weeks, FSS at 13 weeks, SPHERE, and SDS. Treatment duration is not reported in the recorded data, and the recorded data include no trial-level results or participant counts. The authors conclude that acupuncture can significantly improve fatigue, somatic and mental health, and depression in CFS patients, and that acupuncture, especially when combined with rehabilitation, seems to improve fatigue and quality of life. For harms, the review states “virtually no side effects or infections”; it also states that only 5 studies reported adverse effects and that none of the studies purported the number or cause for withdrawals or dropouts. The authors state that results should be considered carefully since some methodological weaknesses are worth mentioning, such as diversity between studies and the inclusion of lower-quality clinical trials; they also note significant study heterogeneity and that the protocol was not registered.
- The effect of massage on patients with chronic fatigue syndrome: A systematic review and meta-analysis.2024 · systematic review
Summary
This systematic review and meta-analysis searched PubMed, Cochrane Library, Web of Science, Embase, Wanfang Database, VIP Database, and China National Knowledge Infrastructure Database until November 2023. It included 32 randomized controlled trials with a total of 2594 CFS patients. The review compared massage therapy with other therapies; treatment duration was not reported. For the outcome effective rate, 28 studies involving 2170 patients were pooled: RR = 1.23, 95% CI 1.19, 1.28. For FS-14 overall score, six studies involving 360 subjects were pooled: MD = −1.59, 95% CI −1.84, −1.34. Mental fatigue score pooled three studies involving 193 subjects: MD = −0.85, 95% CI −0.99, −0.72. Physical fatigue score pooled three studies involving 193 subjects: MD = −1.30, 95% CI −1.60, −1.00. One study reported adverse reactions: local skin swelling occurred in 3 cases in the control group and 2 cases in the observation group; skin bruising occurred in 1 case in the control group and 3 cases in the observation group; nausea occurred in 2 cases in the control group and no nausea symptoms were observed in the observation group. These were described as temporary and not requiring medical treatment; no serious adverse reactions occurred. Withdrawals or worsening were not reported. The authors note most studies did not use blinding and all included literature was Chinese.
- Interventions for the management of long covid (post-covid condition): living systematic review.2024 · systematic review
Summary
This living systematic review assessed drug and non-drug interventions for long covid in adults. It included 24 unique trials with 3695 patients, predominantly from the Americas or Europe. One trial (n=114) compared an online CBT programme called “fit after covid” with usual care; moderate certainty evidence suggested CBT probably reduces fatigue (mean difference −8.4, 95% CI −13.11 to −3.69) and probably improves concentration (mean difference −5.2, −7.97 to −2.43). One trial (n=585) compared combined physical and mental health rehabilitation with one session of online advice and support; moderate certainty evidence suggested it probably increases recovery or important improvement (161 more per 1000 patients, 95% CI 61 more to 292 more), improves quality of life (mean difference 0.04, 95% CI 0.00 to 0.08), and reduces depression (mean difference −1.50, −2.41 to −0.59), with little or no effect on physical and cognitive function or anxiety. Intermittent aerobic exercise 3-5 times weekly for 4-6 weeks probably improves physical function compared with continuous exercise (mean difference 3.8, 95% CI 1.12 to 6.48; n=110). Vortioxetine for eight weeks did not improve cognitive function; coenzyme Q10 500 mg/day for six weeks probably did not improve quality of life (n=119); SIM01 might alleviate fatigue (200 more per 1000 patients, 95% CI 94 more to 336 more; n=463) but probably did not improve quality of life. No instances of post-exertional malaise were reported in the rehabilitation trial; effects on serious adverse events were very uncertain.
- Effects of rehabilitation interventions for old adults with long COVID: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials.2024 · systematic review
Summary
This systematic review and meta-analysis examined rehabilitation interventions for old adults with long COVID. It searched PubMed, EMBASE, Web of Science, Scopus, and Cochrane Library databases to 15 November 2023 and included 11 RCTs involving 832 participants (64.37 ± 7.94 years; 52.2% were men) with a mean/median age of 60 or older. Rehabilitation interventions included exercise training and respiratory rehabilitation; duration was not reported. They were compared with control groups (usual/standard care/placebo). Outcomes included 6 MWT, 30 seconds STS, HGS, FEV1/FVC, fatigue, quality of life, independence in activities of daily living, depression, and anxiety. Compared with controls, the review reported improvement in 6 MWT (MD = 15.77 m, 95% CI = 5.40, 26.13, P < 0.01), 30 seconds STS (MD = 4.11 n, 95% CI = 2.46, 5.76, P < 0.001), fatigue (SMD = −0.66, 95% CI = −1.13, −0.19, P < 0.01), independence in activities of daily living (SMD = 0.31, 95% CI = 0.13, 0.48, P < 0.001), depression (SMD = −0.89, 95% CI = −1.76, −0.02, P < 0.05), anxiety (SMD = −0.81, 95% CI = −1.58, −0.05, P < 0.05), and all SF-36 quality-of-life domains. HGS was not significant (MD = 1.67 kg, 95% CI = −0.84, 4.18, P > 0.05), and FEV1/FVC was not significant (MD = 3.45%, 95% CI = −1.43%, 8.33%, P > 0.05). Side effects and withdrawals were not reported.
- The use of complementary and alternative medicine for the treatment of gastrointestinal symptoms in Long COVID: a systematic review.2023 · systematic review
Summary
This systematic review examined complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) for gastrointestinal symptoms of Long COVID. Five electronic databases were searched, and four studies (three case reports and one case series) involving five individuals were included. All were non-experimental and had no comparison group. Two studies used nutritional approaches. One gave a botanical-based, high-fiber formula (1 dose/day titrated to 3 doses/day) to one patient; nausea (r = −0.328, p = 0.011) and loss of appetite (r = −0.451, p < 0.001) decreased as formula intake increased. The other gave oral lactoferrin (400–600 mg/day) to two patients, with resolution of diarrhea within 2 weeks. Two studies used traditional Chinese medicine. One gave an herbal decoction (6 days/week) to one patient, who had complete resolution of symptoms. The other gave an herbal decoction daily plus weekly acupuncture to one patient, who reported complete resolution of GI symptoms. The review reports reductions in nausea, loss of appetite, diarrhea, acid reflux, epigastric pain, and bloating. Harms and withdrawals were not reported. The authors state the search yielded few results and all were non-experimental; observational design limits definitive conclusions, spontaneous improvement without a control group is possible, no variant-specific data were available, and generalizability is limited.
- Moxibustion for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.2021 · systematic review
Summary
This systematic review and meta-analysis asked whether moxibustion treats chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). Fifteen randomised controlled trials involving 1030 CFS participants were included; all trials were conducted in different provinces of China. Participants received moxibustion alone, compared with acupuncture or drugs. The review did not report treatment duration. Outcomes were total effective rate, fatigue severity on FS-14 and FAI, and adverse events. Pooled results showed moxibustion was better than the control group for total effective rate (OR = 5.19, 95%CI = [3.58, 7.53], P < 0.00001); subgroup results were better than acupuncture (OR = 4.58, 95%CI = [2.85, 7.35]) and drugs (OR = 6.36, 95%CI = [3.48, 11.59]). Moxibustion further relieved FS-14 compared with control (WMD = −2.20, 95% CI = [−3.16, −1.24], P < 0.00001), and was better than acupuncture (WMD = −1.76) and drugs (WMD = −4.17). For FAI, moxibustion improved scores compared with acupuncture (WMD = −16.36, 95% CI = [−26.58, −6.14], P=0.002). Moxibustion-related adverse events included 1 case of mild scald; acupuncture-related events included 3 cases of dizziness and 2 cases of local hematoma. The authors rated the certainty of evidence as limited and stated limitations: methodological quality was not satisfactory, all 15 trials were from Chinese databases (possible language bias), sample sizes were small, and heterogeneity was high.
- A mixed-methods systematic review of post-viral fatigue interventions: Are there lessons for long Covid?2021 · systematic review
Summary
This mixed-methods systematic review asked whether post-viral fatigue interventions offer lessons for long Covid. Online databases were searched in October 2020, and 40 papers were selected. The included fatigue interventions involved 25 studies in CFS/ME, nine in fibromyalgia and eight in unexplained fatigue. Treatments varied widely and were compared with controls, typically usual care or waiting lists; fatigue severity was the main outcome. Intervention duration varied and is not quantified in the recorded data. The review reported mean differences for several interventions. The largest mean difference was for the Three Principles/Innate Health programme (MD -39.0, 95% CI -51.8 to -26.2, SMD = 1.670). Group-based CBT also showed reductions (MD -27.5, 95% CI -33.7 to -21.3, SMD = 1.170; MD -23.7, 95% CI -29.2 to -18.2, SMD = 2.266). Smaller mean differences were reported for GET (MD -11.5, 95% CI -17.6 to -5.4, SMD = 0.524) and self-regulation based physical activity (MD -9.9, 95% CI -16.3 to -3.4, SMD = 0.513). TENS (MD -6.0, 95% CI -16.9 to 4.9, SMD = 0.239), Tai Ji Quan (MD -0.4, 95% CI -9.6 to 8.9, SMD = 0.023) and supportive listening (MD 1.06, 95% CI -1.4 to 3.6, SMD = -0.111) showed little or no benefit. Doxycycline mean differences were positive (MD 6.3, 95% CI 3.7 to 8.8, SMD = -0.752; MD 8.75, 95% CI 6.36 to 11.14, SMD = -1.120). No side effects, withdrawals or worsening were reported in the recorded data.
- Acupuncture for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome: An Overview of Systematic Reviews.2021 · systematic review
Summary
This overview asked whether acupuncture treats chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). It searched databases from inception to September 1, 2019 and included 10 MAs/SRs published between 2009 and 2019. The reviews compared acupuncture, acupuncture-moxibustion, or electro-acupuncture with placebo, sham acupuncture, medicine, waiting list, or other interventions. Outcomes were total effective rate, VAS, SF-36, FAI, and CFS physical and mental fatigue. For total effective rate, reviews with n=390, 671, 337, 1036, and 845 reported that 'acupuncture had effectiveness and safety for CFS.' Three reviews described VAS and SF-36 and reported acupuncture was superior to sham acupuncture, intravenous infusion, and non-acupuncture therapy. Two reviews investigated CFS-Physical Fatigue and CFS-Mental Fatigue and reported 'acupuncture was effective for CFS.' For FAI, one review reported WMD = –29.52; 95% CI: –36.17, –22.88, and another SMD= –1.75, 95% CI: –2.76, –0.73. One review reported a 'lack of sufficient evidence to support or refute the use of acupuncture for the treatment of CFS.' GRADE found 4 of 17 outcomes very low quality, 10 low, and 3 moderate; AMSTAR-2 rated all included reviews critically low. The authors state limitations including language restriction, no manual retrieval, only MA/SR data extracted, possible duplicate RCTs, and low quality of MAs/SRs.
- Acupuncture Treatment for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome2019 · systematic review
Summary
This chapter systematically reviewed acupuncture treatment for chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) based on a broad literature search and the authors’ experiences. It reports 40 clinical research papers on acupuncture for CFS published over the last 10 years. The reviewed studies used simple acupuncture, electro-acupuncture, blood-letting acupuncture, acupoint application, acupoint catgut embedding, acupoint injection, auricular acupuncture, abdominal acupuncture, moxibustion, cupping and combined therapies. Examples include 32 CFS patients given acupuncture at acupoints versus non-meridian points, measured with the WHOQOL-BREF; 60 cases randomly divided into electro-acupuncture on acupoints or non-acupoints, 30 cases in each group, measured with FSS, SPHERE, VAS and SF-36, with the acupoints group reported better (P < 0.01); and 180 CFS patients randomly divided into 2 groups (92 treatment, 88 control) for acupoint injection. Reported rates included a total effective rate of 93.75% for electro-acupuncture plus auricular application, a total efficiency of 96.7% for auricular acupuncture in 60 cases, and a total efficiency of 94.34% for abdominal acupuncture. A reviewed RCT found no obvious difference between a low sugar low yeast diet and healthy eating. The harms text states auricular acupuncture with acupoint catgut embedding has fewer clinical side effects than traditional acupuncture, while excessive exercise may lead to immune function disorders and may aggravate CFS symptoms. Numbers who worsened or stopped were not reported. The authors state current research lacks a unified syndrome differentiation standard and a unified evaluation standard of efficacy.
- A Systematic Review of Acupuncture for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome2017 · systematic review
- Traditional Chinese medicine for chronic fatigue syndrome: a systematic review of randomized clinical trials.2014 · systematic review
Summary
This systematic review asked whether traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) helps chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). It included 23 RCTs involving 1776 participants. The trials tested Chinese herbal medicine, acupuncture, electroacupuncture, moxibustion, acupoint application, qigong and combined treatments. Comparators were non-specific treatment, sham-acupuncture, sham-electroacupuncture, Fluoxetine, hydrocortisone, placebo, no treatment or paroxetine alone. Fatigue was measured with several scales. A meta-analysis of five studies favored Chinese herbal medicine over non-specific treatment on GPFS (MD −5.93 [−7.51, −4.34]). Individual studies also favored Chinese herbal medicine on CFS1 total FS score (MD −1.51 [−2.40, −0.62] and MD −3.90 [−5.05, −2.75]) and CFS2 plus auxiliary symptom score (MD −29.76 [−35.55, −23.97]). Acupuncture was favored in two meta-analyses and three individual studies; pooled CFS1-total FS score was 2.61 lower (3.56—1.65 lower) in 261 participants from 4 studies. Two individual studies found no significant difference between acupuncture and sham-acupuncture for CFS1-mental FS score and CFS2-physical FS score. Electroacupuncture, moxibustion, acupoint application, qigong and combined treatments also showed favoring results. Quality of life findings were inconsistent. Studies 20, 22 and 28 reported mild and transient adverse events such as nausea, thirst or bleeding due to acupuncture. The authors state TCM appears to alleviate fatigue, but risk of bias was high and larger studies are needed.
- Alternative medical interventions used in the treatment and management of myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome and fibromyalgia.2010 · systematic review
Summary
The review included 70 controlled clinical trials of alternative and complementary treatments and nonpharmacological supplements for ME/CFS and fibromyalgia; searches ran up to April 2007. It did not have its own treatment arm or comparison group; it summarized trials with control or comparison conditions. The review did not report one treatment dose or duration. Outcomes in included trials covered laboratory tests, physical functioning, psychologic functioning, and quality of life. The review reports that some trials showed at least one positive effect and some showed null or ambiguous results; it states that no firm conclusions can be made. Only three studies (4%) reported adverse side-effects such as bruising and rashes. For acupuncture, three RCTs reported dropout rates of around 15%–35% in all intervention groups. The authors state publication bias: beneficial effects tend to be published while negative results may remain unpublished. They also state the methodological quality of reporting was generally poor and that no definite CAM treatment recommendations can be made for ME/CFS or FM.
- A systematic review of acupuncture and moxibustion treatment for chronic fatigue syndrome in China.2008 · systematic review
Summary
This systematic review searched the Chinese Journal full-text database in January 2007 for studies of acupuncture and moxibustion for chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS); 40 studies met the inclusion criteria. The included studies used filiform needles, sometimes with warming needle, moxibustion, ear points/ear seeds, cupping, Tuina, herbs, psychotherapy or music therapy; some entries list control groups receiving acupuncture, cortisone, herbs or moxa. Outcomes were recorded as Total Effectiveness (TE). Examples recorded in Table 1 include Li et al. (2005), n = 64, with TG/CG TE 30 (93.75)/24 (75.00); Guo (2005), n = 620, with TG/CG TE 303 (97.74)/179 (58.38); and Sun and Li (2006), n = 60, with TG/CG TE 28 (93.33)/23 (76.67). Uncontrolled study entries include Gao (1998), n = 21, TE 21 (100.00), and Zeng and Liu (1999), n = 38, TE 30 (78.95). For harms, the review states that 'only one study reported that one patient fainted during an acupuncture treatment.' The authors state: 'This review cannot be used to establish the efficacy of acupuncture and moxibustion in the treatment of CFS.'
- Evidence Map Analysis of Acupuncture for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome2026 · review
Summary
This evidence map examined randomized controlled trials of acupuncture for chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). The authors searched databases including CNKI, WanFang Data, CBM, VIP, PubMed, EMbase, The Cochrane Library, and Web of Science for trials published from database inception to April 28, 2025. They included 104 RCTs involving 8,526 participants. The review describes the trials' interventions, acupoints, outcome measures, and risk-of-bias assessments; it did not pool efficacy results and reports no comparison-group result, no before-and-after treatment result, and no side-effect counts. The authors state that acupuncture is objectively effective for treating CFS. They also state that related RCTs urgently require standardization in methodological design and outcome selection. They list limitations including non-standard methodological design, significant variations in scale usage, laboratory tests being limited mainly to immunological indices, unclear primary and secondary outcome measures, lack of economic evaluations, insufficient long-term follow-up, and a deficiency in highlighting TCM characteristics. The review was registered as CRD420251024495. No treatment duration for this review's own study is reported.
- Beyond the basics: exploring non-conventional treatment for fatigue in post-acute COVID-19 syndrome.2025 · review
Summary
This narrative review examined non-conventional treatments for fatigue in post-acute COVID-19 syndrome (PACS). The review itself reports no enrolled or analysed participants, setting, or follow-up. It summarizes a 388-participant study of QJYQ 10 grams twice daily for 14 days versus standard rehabilitation, with significant Borg scale improvement in the intervention group; a 30-survivor vitamin-minerals study; a 201-subject vitamin-minerals study with chronic fatigue score enhancements in 77% and 90% at 14 days and 28 days; a 66-survivor case-control study (33 intervention, 33 control) of a 10-amino-acid supplement for 8-week; a 44-female aromatherapy study for 14 days with no reported adverse effects; a 27-patient SingStrong program; a 50-year-old acupuncture case; a 55-year-old man HBOT case; and a 55-year-old female PEMF case with brief fatigue inventory score from 6.33 at baseline to 0.11 at 6 weeks post-treatment. Outcomes included fatigue scales, muscle strength, physical performance, quality of life, cognitive function, and physical capacity. No worsening or stopping is reported. No limitations are stated.
- Myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS): diagnosis and management.2025 · review
Summary
This narrative review searched PubMed, Web of Science, Embase, and the Cochrane Library from inception to August 2025 and included 211 publications on ME/CFS diagnosis, pathophysiology, assessment, and treatment. It summarized pharmacological and non-pharmacological interventions. Reported examples include a double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial of IVIG in 99 CFS patients that found an absence of dose-dependent efficacy; a Phase III rintatolimod study in 208 ME/CFS patients in which 51.2% of a severely debilitated subgroup (n = 21/41) had a ≥ 25% improvement in exercise treadmill test duration; a 12-week trial in 207 ME/CFS patients reporting significant reductions in fatigue with CoQ10 (200 mg) and nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (20 mg); LDN showing significant improvement in 73.9% of 218 ME/CFS patients; and a pilot study of 55 ME/CFS patients in which oral minocycline produced favorable symptom improvements for 80% of treatment completers. A pooled analysis of 1,298 ME/CFS patients from eight trials associated CBT with significant reductions in fatigue severity and functional impairment. A pragmatic trial in 241 adolescents (aged 8–17) found no significant inter-group difference between GET and activity management for physical function on the Short-Form 36 at 6 months. A systematic review and meta-analysis reported a significant reduction in fatigue (Hedges’ g = -0.52) and an improvement in physical function with pacing compared with no treatment or routine care. Harms included GET-associated symptom exacerbation in a significant proportion of patients, and rintatolimod adverse events may occur. TCM findings should be cautiously interpreted because the available evidence is constrained by methodological limitations.
- From tradition to healing: the promise of acupuncture in managing chronic fatigue syndrome.2025 · review
Summary
This review asked how acupuncture and moxibustion are used for chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). It reports no primary enrollment or analysis; its setting is not reported, and it summarizes other studies. It cites a study of 310 patients treated with acupuncture combined with psychotherapy, reporting a clinical survival rate of 88.7% and a rate of 97.7%. A multicenter, unblinded RCT divided 150 patients with CFS and idiopathic chronic fatigue into body acupuncture, Sa-am acupuncture, and control groups; after 5 weeks the body acupuncture group had a significantly lower FSS score than the control group, with significant improvement in SRI and BDI scores. Another RCT compared moxibustion and acupuncture and reported 88.9% versus 72.2%. A study of 72 CFS patients found electroacupuncture produced greater reductions in fatigue and more significant improvements in cerebral cortical function than routine needling. One study of 60 CFS patients used acupoint catgut embedding combined with ginger-partitioned moxibustion and reported significantly improved clinical signs and symptoms; another 60 CFS patients compared Chaihu Longgu Muli Decoction combined with acupuncture at back-shu points with traditional Chinese medicine alone, finding better fatigue and anxiety scale improvement in the combined group. A systematic review and meta-analysis included 16 studies with 1346 patients, and a network meta-analysis included 51 RCTs. The review notes local pain, bleeding, infection, and other adverse reactions may occur during acupuncture; five patients experienced acupuncture-related adverse events with relatively mild symptoms.
- Advances in the application of traditional Chinese medicine during the COVID-19 recovery period: A review.2024 · review
Summary
This review examined clinical studies of traditional Chinese medicine during the COVID-19 recovery period, including the post-COVID-19 condition. The review itself did not enroll its own participants or report a comparison group. It reports studies of Chinese patent medicines and formulas, plus Liu Zi Jue exercise, moxibustion, and combined rehabilitation. Zhong et al treated 150 participants discharged after COVID-19 with individualized TCM for 3 to 6 months and reported improvement in clinical symptoms, lung function, and a balanced body constitution. The review lists trials of Shumian capsules, Ludangshen oral liquid, Bufei Huoxue capsules, Jinshuibao capsules, Shengmaiyin oral liquid, Shugan Jieyu capsule, Xiangsha Liujun pills, Qingjin Yiqi granules, and formulas, with sample sizes including n = 200 (G1 = 100, G2 = 100), n = 131 (G1 = 66, G2 = 65), n = 388 (G1 = 194, G2 = 194), and n = 96 (G1 = 64, G2 = 32). Pang et al reported better improvement in modified Medical Research Council scale and Borg scale data compared with control, and no treatment-related adverse events were observed among 388 patients. Tao et al reported better TCM symptom score, St. George’s Respiratory Questionnaire score, total treatment efficiency, pulse oxygen saturation level, and 6 minute walking distance data than control. The authors state further high-quality studies are needed.
- Research progress on pathogenesis of chronic fatigue syndrome and treatment of traditional Chinese and Western medicine.2024 · review
Summary
This comprehensive review synthesized recent literature on Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS) pathogenesis and traditional Chinese and Western medicine treatments; it did not enroll or analyze its own patient cohort, so setting was not reported. Cited studies described varied interventions. Shu et al. randomized 30 CFS patients to acupuncture or moxibustion at Zusanli and Guanyuan; after 4 and 10 weeks both alleviated fatigue symptoms by modulating the vagus nerve, with acupuncture showing superior short-term and moxibustion enhanced long-term clinical efficacy. Luo et al. studied 60 female CFS patients receiving 30-min or 60-min moxibustion three times per week for four weeks; 60-min moxibustion showed advantages for fatigue and depression. Qi Fengjun et al. allocated 60 CFS patients to massage or acupuncture for two treatment courses each lasting 10 days; massage showed significant therapeutic benefits. Liang Weili et al. divided 70 CFS patients; oral medication plus herbal-cake moxibustion was more efficacious than oral medication alone for fatigue and sleep quality. Borody et al. reported FMT therapeutic efficacy in 70% of cases (42 out of 60) with gastrointestinal symptoms. Adamson et al. observed improvement in 995 CFS patients after cognitive-behavioral and psychological interventions. Harms included lower incidence of nausea and diarrhea with moxibustion plus paroxetine than paroxetine alone; in a Norwegian survey approximately 80% of patients reported decline in health status after graded exercise therapy. The authors stated limitations including lack of rigorous trial design and safety data.
- Chronic inflammatory response syndrome: a review of the evidence of clinical efficacy of treatment.2024 · review
Summary
This literature review searched EBSCOhost Academic Search Premier, Proquest, Google Scholar, and the Cochrane Library in June 2022 for published treatments for chronic inflammatory response syndrome (CIRS), ME/CFS, and sick building syndrome. No patients were enrolled by the review; no comparison group, randomization, or follow-up duration was reported. The review reports 13 articles comprising 14 studies on CIRS treatment and also reviews CFS treatment studies. Named CIRS study sizes included 8, 13, 28, 14, 21, 156/111, 20, 35/4, 100, and 68/23. The review states the only treatment with documented clinical efficacy was the Shoemaker Protocol, described in 11 of the 13 articles; table entries list cholestyramine and vasoactive intestinal peptide as successful, while Rea’s antigen intradermal treatments had lack of objective data. CFS studies listed sizes including 49, 1518, 1030, 2036, 62, 409, 101, 171, 33, 32/18, 23, and 218; findings included some benefit for aripiprazole in 101 patients, high frequency of response for low-dose naltrexone in 218, and CBT/GET reported beneficial in six studies but noncurative. Reported side effects include constipation from cholestyramine, hyponatremia from desmopressin, and light-headedness from vasoactive intestinal peptides; medication intolerance was a barrier.
- Research progress in the treatment of chronic fatigue syndrome through interventions targeting the hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal axis.2024 · review
Summary
This review examined treatments targeting the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis in chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). It included seven RCTs of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) methods, with sample sizes of 41, 30, 30, 36, 30, 33, and 20 individuals with CFS. No setting was reported. Treatments included pestle needle therapy plus electric acupuncture, Fuyang cupping, Lixujieyu decoction with or without five-element gongdiao music, scalp acupuncture, acupoint acupuncture with a TCM patch, and electric acupuncture; comparisons included electric acupuncture, massage, chiropracty, and cupping, Chinese medicine alone, music alone, no treatment, Vicodin, adenosine triphosphate, and oryzanol, and no therapeutic operation. Treatment duration was not reported. Outcomes were ACTH, CORT and MT levels and circadian measures. Some studies reported ACTH levels significantly higher after treatment in both groups, CORT significantly lower after treatment in both groups, or CORT significantly higher after treatment in both groups; one reported no significant change in control-group serum CORT. The review also states randomized controlled trials have shown beneficial effects of hydrocortisone for some patients but overall evidence is insufficient; long-term treatment is associated with adverse effects including Cushing’s syndrome, osteoporosis, extreme mood changes and seizures. Withdrawals were not reported. The authors state the TCM RCTs have design, allocation concealment, blinding and safety-reporting deficiencies, limiting interpretation.
- [Evidence map on post-acute COVID-19 sequelae and rehabilitation: Update as of July 2022Mapa de evidencia sobre las secuelas y la rehabilitación tras la COVID-19 aguda: versión actualizada en julio del 2022].2023 · review
Summary
This evidence map updated a review of interventions for rehabilitation of post-acute COVID-19 sequelae in people who had symptomatic COVID-19 and post-acute sequelae; the population was predominantly adults. The update searched Biblioteca Virtual em Saúde and PubMed and was dated 27 July 2022. It included 32 review studies. Interventions were grouped as multimodal, pharmacological, therapeutic, and complementary therapies; no single treatment duration was reported. There was no comparison group; the map plotted associations between interventions and health outcomes. Effects were classified as positive, potentially positive, inconclusive, not informed, or no effect. The map reported 166 associations; the update analysed 69 associations. Exercise (isolated, multicomponent, or multimodal) had 23 positive effects and four potentially positive effects. Exercise prescription was reported with positive effects for functional exercise capacity, lung function, and quality of life; exercise had positive effects for mental health, dyspnoea, fatigue, exercise capacity, and muscle strength, while depression was not informed and lung function was absent and functional independence inconclusive. Pharmacological and complementary interventions for sensory functions had 15 associations. No study reported negative or potentially negative effects. Worsening, discontinuation, and side-effect counts were not reported. The authors state the literature remains incipient and many included items were protocols.
- Diagnostische Überlegungen und therapeutische Ansätze zu PostCOVID-19 mit Chinesischer Medizin Post COVID-19: diagnostic considerations and therapy options offered by Chinese Medicine2023 · review
Summary
This review (Überblick) summarizes treatment options from Chinese Medicine for LongCOVID, PostCOVID and Chronic Fatigue Syndrome/Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (CFS/ME). No patients were enrolled in this paper; it reports findings from other studies. It reviews acupuncture/moxibustion, acupressure, qigong and Chinese herbal medicine. A systematic review with meta-analysis of 31 studies ranked a combination of acupuncture and moxibustion highest for reduction of fatigue symptoms, followed by acupuncture or moxibustion alone, Chinese herbal formulas, Western medicine and sham acupuncture. A review with meta-analysis of 51 RCTs (49 Chinese) also found the strongest effect on general fatigue score for a combination of moxibustion and acupuncture. A systematic review of moxibustion found moxibustion significantly superior to control procedures on various fatigue scales, with Gaohuang moxibustion showing the strongest effect. Two RCTs of qigong in CFS/ME were described: one in 137 patients with CFS using WuXingPingHengGong qigong reported a significant and clinically relevant effect on the Chalder Fatigue Scale and effects on anxiety/depression scales; another in 150 CFS/ME patients using Baduanjin qigong reported a clinically relevant improvement in the Chalder Fatigue Scale (mean 12 points), HADS depression scale and sleep quality only in the qigong group. A systematic review of 84 RCTs of Chinese herbal medicine reported significant improvements in fatigue severity, mood and clinical symptom score, and significant increases in IgA, IgG and IgM antibody titers in CHM arms. No side effects or withdrawals are reported for this review. The authors state that study quality was low overall, that data for PCS are limited, and that evidence for qigong in CFS is thin.
- SARS-CoV-2 Infection, Post COVID-19 Symptoms and Acupuncture.2022 · review
Summary
This editorial presents a clinician's experience with acupuncture for long-haul post-COVID symptoms. It reports 3 patients with lingering long-haul COVID symptoms of shortness of breath and fatigue; no setting or location is reported. Treatment described was needling SP 8; duration and frequency are not reported. There was no comparison group, no randomisation and no crossover. Outcomes described were shortness of breath and pressure pain on the left subcostal region of the abdomen. The text states that responses were dramatic, with immediate reduction of pressure pain on the left subcostal region of the abdomen and immediate improvement in shortness of breath in each patient. No worsening, stopping, withdrawals, adverse events or harms are reported. The editorial also states that more research is needed to demonstrate efficacy. No enrolled, started or analysed participant totals are reported beyond the 3 patients described; no formal trial registration or follow-up period is reported. The text is an editorial rather than a controlled trial.
- Advances in Clinical Research on Traditional Chinese Medicine Treatment of Chronic Fatigue Syndrome.2020 · review
Summary
This review summarized clinical research on traditional Chinese medicine for chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), described as CFS or myositis encephalomyelitis (ME). The authors searched PubMed, Web of Science, JAMA Network, CNKI, SinoMed and WanFang Data (2010~2020.3 and 2015~2020.3) and included 77 articles, 20 in English and 57 in Chinese. The reviewed treatments included herbal decoctions and proprietary Chinese medicines, moxibustion, acupuncture, tuina, cupping, and combinations of these. Many summarized studies reported higher total effective rates in observation groups than in control groups; the review did not pool these into a single comparison. Adverse drug reactions were mentioned for an estradiol patch study, without counts. The authors state that exact efficacy is still controversial. They report that diagnostic criteria, treatment methods and efficacy evaluations lack consensus, that repeated experiments were lacking, and that the level of evidence is not good enough.
- PACE investigators' response is misleading regarding patient survey results.2017 · review
Summary
This Open Peer Commentary Article reviews patient survey data published between 2001 and 2015 on ME/CFS. Five major patient surveys by Action for ME and The ME Association are pooled. Surveys asked patients about availability, helpfulness, improvement, worsening, or disability benefits for therapies including GET, CBT and pacing. In Action for ME 2011a (977 respondents), 48 per cent responded ‘yes’ for GET and 66 per cent for CBT being available on the NHS, compared with 90–94 per cent for pacing, medications and fatigue/condition management. In The ME Association 2010 survey (3099 respondents), 82 per cent wanted pacing, 28 per cent CBT and 24 per cent GET. In The ME Association 2010 survey (n = 4217), 22 per cent reported improvement with GET, 26 per cent with CBT and 71 per cent with pacing; 57 per cent reported worse symptoms from GET, 20 per cent from CBT and 5 per cent from pacing. The ME Association 2015 reported a net increase in patients on disability benefits after GET courses (+13%) and CBT courses (+10%), compared with a net decrease after pacing courses (−1%). The author states survey limitations should be borne in mind.
- Pain in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome: time for specific pain treatment?2012 · review
Summary
This narrative review, covering literature through December 2011 at several universities, asked whether pain in chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) is a unique feature or shares mechanisms with other symptoms, and which treatments reduce pain. No own cohort or enrollment numbers were reported. The review reports a randomized controlled trial in patients with CFS in which pain physiology education, compared with pacing and self-management education, improved understanding of pain biology and resulted in less catastrophizing (reduced rumination about pain). It reports a study finding CBT improved pain severity in adolescents and adults with CFS even though pain was not specifically emphasized; changes in physical activity, negative affectivity, or body consciousness did not explain the decrease, but decrease was associated with fatigue improvement. The review reports studies found severe baseline pain predicted poor response to CBT in adults. A semi-structured interview (Marshall) reported 14 out of 23 patients experienced pain relief with acupuncture and 5 out of 18 with gentle soft tissue therapies. The review states studies examining effectiveness of complementary medicine for CFS pain are lacking and there is currently no evidence supporting efficacy. Harms reported: patients with CFS experience more pain immediately following and 24 hours after exercise; patients are prone to side effects due to exercise intolerance in early graded exercise therapy. Treatment durations were not reported. Stopping or dose changes were not reported. Limitations: role of deficient hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal axis and immune interactions require further study.
- Discussion on the Discipline of Selected Points in Chronic Fatigue Syndrome Treated with Acupuncture and Moxibustion2009 · review
Summary
This review aimed to summarize and analyse the discipline of selected points in chronic fatigue syndrome treated with acupuncture and moxibustion. The authors collected case report literatures on chronic fatigue syndrome treated with acupuncture and moxibustion from the recent ten years. No patients, enrolled or analysed, are reported; the unit of analysis was the literature and the acupoints mentioned. The abstract does not state a comparison group, randomisation, follow-up, or treatment duration. The reported result was that 40 literatures with 40 acupoints were collected, including 33 specific acupoints, and that 10 specific acupoints were involved. No patient-level outcomes, before-versus-after treatment results, between-group results, harms, side effects, withdrawals, or participants who worsened are reported in the abstract. The authors concluded that the acupoints used for clinical study of chronic fatigue syndrome treated with acupuncture and moxibustion were mainly urinary bladder acupoints, commonly governor vesesl, conception vessel, stomach channel and spleen channel, and that the kind of acupoint was mainly specific acupoint. The abstract states no limitations.