Miruvor
Sign up

Manganese

How it went for everyone who tried it

Helped means they said it helped with what they took it for, which may be one symptom and not the illness.

59%
helped
70 of 118
18%
no change
21 of 118
23%
got worse
27 of 118

Shares are out of the 118 people who said how it went. 59 more tried it without saying how it went overall; 3 of them describe a problem.

How it wentPeopleShare
Helped a lot33%
Helped6756%
No change2118%
Worse2723%
Much worse00%
Where it was reportedHelpedSaid how it went
Reddit2125
Recovery stories4993

Did it last, for everyone it helped?

  • It wore off for 5 of the 70 people it helped: 2 who credit it for their improvement, 3 who don’t.

Ask about this treatment

Among the 36 who credit it with their improvement, here’s how they are now

Credit it means they say it’s one reason they got better: 3 say it helped them most; 33 say it was one of several things that helped.

22%
recovered or near normal
8 of 36
50%
much or somewhat better
18 of 36
20%
relapsed
7 of 36
8%
no benefit
3 of 36

Where each person was at the end of their story, or in their latest post that says how they are, compared with their worst point.

Outcome describedPeopleShare
Recovered26%
Near normal616%
Much better925%
Somewhat better925%
Relapsed720%
No benefit38%

Did it last?

  • 2 of the 36 who credit it said its benefit wore off (1 of them among the 7 who relapsed).
  • 27 of the 36 who credit it say they still need to keep doing something (not always this) to stay well.

By how ill people were

Only the 36 who credit it, so people it didn’t help or made worse aren’t here. How they are now is their outcome overall, not the effect of this one treatment.

Severity at worstHow they are nownRecovered or near normal
Mild757%, few people
Moderate1118%
Severe1217%
Very severe20%, few people
Not stated40%, few people
At worstOutcomePeopleShare
MildNear normal4 of 757%
MildMuch better1 of 714%
MildSomewhat better2 of 729%
ModerateRecovered1 of 119%
ModerateNear normal1 of 119%
ModerateMuch better4 of 1137%
ModerateSomewhat better3 of 1127%
ModerateRelapsed2 of 1118%
SevereRecovered1 of 129%
SevereNear normal1 of 128%
SevereMuch better4 of 1233%
SevereSomewhat better1 of 128%
SevereRelapsed3 of 1225%
SevereNo benefit2 of 1217%
Very severeRelapsed2 of 2100%
Not statedSomewhat better3 of 475%
Not statedNo benefit1 of 425%

Adverse events

What people said went wrong, in their own words.

31 of 177

people who wrote about taking it described a problem they tied to it

Described one · 31Didn’t mention one · 146

The serious kinds

Worth telling a doctor about straight away.

  • Suicidal thoughts or attempt

    1 person
    “I also had similar suicidal agitation when I took manganese.”
    — Christopher
  • Mood or psychiatric effects

    3 people
    “More than 10 mg, or taken more closely together, and I become prone to anger”
    — aaron_c
    “I think manganese has a HUGE negative effect on my mood”
    — determined
    Show 1 moreShow fewer
    “severe agitation that's been cycling rapidly with depressive thoughts.”
    — Christopher
  • Liver or kidney problems

    2 people
    “At one time I worked up to 8 mg twice a day, but this seemed to bother my liver. I was OK with 4 mg 4 times per day.”
    — Little Bluestem
    “I have had to stop taking manganese because it made my liver hurt”
    — Blossom1
  • Blood count problems

    1 person
    “I had been taking 5mg for some months, until a blood test showed my hemoglobin to be very low. I was feeling increasingly weak and cold”
    — adreno
  • Refeeding or deficiency problems

    1 person
    “recently was taking manganese which I believe activated vitamin D because it gave me permanent magnesium need”
    — Kadar

The serious kinds are a death, suicidal thoughts or an attempt, a hospital stay, an ER visit, an allergic reaction or anaphylaxis, heart rhythm, liver or kidney, blood count, mood or psychiatric, or refeeding or deficiency problems, and being made much worse: a large worsening such as a crash lasting weeks or more.

Other kinds

Unpleasant effects people tied to it, the most serious first.

Made symptoms worse · 6Low blood pressure or fainting · 1Gut side effects · 4Herx / die-off reaction · 2Insomnia from treatment · 1Side effects · 16Other · 1 Show all 7Hide
  • Made symptoms worse

    6 people
    “But it looks like my ebv which had already reactivated earlier in the day appears to have done so again with the manganese.”
    — godlovesatrier
    “I feel worse when I take manganese, i can tolerate it though.”
    — renski
    Show 4 moreShow fewer
    “I think the combination of these nutrients perhaps even made things worse for me.”
    — Meadow 23537
    “Within 6 hours after 14mg I was feeling a deep flu-like ache and general cold-like symptoms.”
    — themjay
    “I am reluctant to keep supplementing, as it seems manganese has worsened some of my OCD symptoms.”
    — Don Quixote
    “when i take manganese i get a weird pressure in the head and brain fog”
    — KenJT
  • Low blood pressure or fainting

    1 person
    “I love manganese but again it lowers my blood pressure”
    — tango
  • Gut side effects

    4 people
    “I didn't get the pale stools till last year after taking manganese. ... They were worse the more Mn I took.”
    — Brenda
    “Last week I had fairly severe diarrhea. ... I have reduced my manganese from 8 mg twice a day to 4 mg three times a day.”
    — Little Bluestem
    Show 2 moreShow fewer
    “Manganese supplementation was a disaster, it kept giving me atrophic gastritis...killing my stomach lining!”
    — merylg
    “Vague feeling sometimes in the stomach which I take maybe manganese induced.”
    — Asklipia
  • Herx / die-off reaction

    2 people
    “I had to stop twice for a couple of days, I felt it was too much detox going on.”
    — Asklipia
    “This has happened with taking a few supps... once while taking the biotin . as well as the initial worsening with taking P5P. .. as well when starting to take manganese.”
    — nanciswell
  • Insomnia from treatment

    1 person
    “it gave me insomnia for weeks after stopping it”
    — aaron_c
  • Side effects

    16 people
    “I get Fibro symptoms / mercury release symptoms when I try to raise selenium, Molybdenum and Manganese.”
    — jason30
    “One problem I had developed on high Mn was bladder irritation. I thought it was infection and was treating with garlic but it would not go away.”
    — Brenda
    Show 14 moreShow fewer
    “even a small dose of a supplement was causing me side effects (manganese, comes to my mind, for example)”
    — Mick
    “Little oddities of position, or stretching my arm a bit too far, caused a surprising amount of burning pain”
    — NilaJones
    “Some things are getting worse: sleep agitated and shorter, hearing loss, vague nausea sometimes, irritation of the eyes and joints.”
    — Asklipia
    “It causes severe problems with my stomach and esophagus even when bypassing the gut (transdermal).”
    — hixxy
    “some mild insomnia ... a sore throat ... I also have some acne on my face since last night.”
    — Christopher
    “I do notice that if I take the manganese and the molybdenum together that it does push me into overmethylation.”
    — Star-Anise
    “I tried it for only a few days in the past. It made me tired & foggy.”
    — Avengers26
    “the manganese revved me up, made my pulse race, and made me nauseas”
    — Dreambirdie
    “I was doing the Mn with Christine, but it was too much for me to handle.”
    — Shellbell
    “I cant tolerate metafolin, manganese.”
    — Luca_Toni
    “I get joint pain with 5-10 mg manganese.”
    — SaraM
    “Manganese on the other hand churns up my intestine pretty bad ... It lead to eczema and joint pain when I tried bits of cut up tablets.”
    — iacyi
    “After taking manganese for a while I started to get low iron symptoms”
    — Blossom1
    “But I have developed a dry itchy rash on both back hands that starts at the knuckles and finishes 2 inches into the wrist.”
    — Boost
  • Other

    1 person
    “have had to stop the manganese because I developed aching muscles in my hands (especially) and my arms”
    — dannybex

How often it comes up

Posts that mention Manganese, per 1,000 posts each month. Hover or tap a point for the count.

0510201020142017202020232026
MonthPosts mentioning itAll postsPer 1,000
Oct 200901050
Jan 201001410
Feb 201001130
Jun 201101090
Nov 201101240
Dec 201111995.0
Jan 201202320
Feb 201201030
Mar 201211905.3
Apr 201211626.2
May 2012437510.7
Jun 201202380
Jul 201212404.2
Aug 201204850
Sep 201205610
Oct 201205260
Nov 201205140
Dec 201236994.3
Jan 201305330
Feb 201304470
Mar 201304290
Apr 201304990
May 201356068.3
Jun 201306090
Jul 2013961614.6
Aug 201305770
Sep 201303640
Oct 201305360
Nov 201303850
Dec 201305190
Jan 201429442.1
Feb 201418211.2
Mar 201434257.1
Apr 201403610
May 201406170
Jun 201404890
Jul 201404440
Aug 201406220
Sep 201435075.9
Oct 201416781.5
Nov 201415671.8
Dec 201406290
Jan 201507600
Feb 201508730
Mar 201501,2760
Apr 201519841.0
May 201501,4960
Jun 201501,0460
Jul 201511,2110.83
Aug 201509980
Sep 201511,0600.94
Oct 201501,2550
Nov 201501,2460
Dec 201509240
Jan 201611,2820.78
Feb 201621,0511.9
Mar 201611,0021.00
Apr 201609980
May 201601,0450
Jun 201611,2300.81
Jul 201601,6190
Aug 201601,7290
Sep 201611,7850.56
Oct 201601,2200
Nov 201601,0920
Dec 201631,2112.5
Jan 201701,6600
Feb 201711,9880.50
Mar 201702,0780
Apr 201742,1331.9
May 201702,3700
Jun 201722,1940.91
Jul 201702,1830
Aug 201702,4660
Sep 201702,1890
Oct 201703,0420
Nov 201701,9760
Dec 201742,1121.9
Jan 201802,6200
Feb 201802,1550
Mar 201812,6130.38
Apr 201822,2510.89
May 201802,8280
Jun 201813,8710.26
Jul 201813,0670.33
Aug 201813,7570.27
Sep 201803,5120
Oct 201813,2610.31
Nov 201802,8610
Dec 201802,7540
Jan 201903,6720
Feb 201912,7150.37
Mar 201903,3170
Apr 201903,1410
May 201903,8550
Jun 201913,3920.29
Jul 201903,3120
Aug 201913,9430.25
Sep 201914,0350.25
Oct 201913,9220.25
Nov 201903,5080
Dec 201903,6590
Jan 202004,6500
Feb 202024,3740.46
Mar 202004,4750
Apr 202013,6900.27
May 202014,5430.22
Jun 202025,7010.35
Jul 202016,1040.16
Aug 2020010,3330
Sep 2020111,9580.08
Oct 2020114,5680.07
Nov 2020116,5460.06
Dec 2020220,7640.10
Jan 2021124,5620.04
Feb 2021424,6720.16
Mar 2021229,4760.07
Apr 2021028,5090
May 2021025,7910
Jun 2021127,8710.04
Jul 2021127,2200.04
Aug 2021030,8080
Sep 2021530,0740.17
Oct 2021222,1320.09
Nov 2021127,7220.04
Dec 2021331,8720.09
Jan 2022042,3170
Feb 2022938,6970.23
Mar 2022444,3050.09
Apr 2022144,3330.02
May 20221150,5940.22
Jun 20221549,0580.31
Jul 2022553,4850.09
Aug 2022154,4550.02
Sep 2022556,9360.09
Oct 2022358,5110.05
Nov 2022159,1980.02
Dec 2022361,5760.05
Jan 2023861,0040.13
Feb 2023350,1330.06
Mar 2023259,9250.03
Apr 2023454,2510.07
May 2023457,7680.07
Jun 2023152,6790.02
Jul 2023556,4010.09
Aug 20231965,4350.29
Sep 20231261,8350.19
Oct 2023758,4190.12
Nov 2023453,6620.07
Dec 20231460,6430.23
Jan 2024371,8180.04
Feb 20241170,0450.16
Mar 20241168,2610.16
Apr 2024364,3740.05
May 2024467,6980.06
Jun 2024264,7200.03
Jul 2024265,3350.03
Aug 2024368,5170.04
Sep 2024570,1680.07
Oct 2024372,6070.04
Nov 2024271,8020.03
Dec 2024574,4010.07
Jan 2025477,9090.05
Feb 2025665,1100.09
Mar 2025269,9050.03
Apr 2025361,6060.05
May 2025265,7330.03
Jun 2025660,5400.10
Jul 2025662,1050.10
Aug 2025564,5780.08
Sep 20251061,7040.16
Oct 2025359,2040.05
Nov 2025358,9440.05
Dec 2025862,8300.13
Jan 2026063,3210
Feb 2026153,0850.02
Mar 2026459,2080.07
Apr 2026553,9890.09
May 2026257,5410.03
Jun 2026255,3010.04
Jul 2026156,3910.02
Aug 2026856,8250.14
Sep 2026057,1430

Forum and Reddit posts, 4,007,898 in all, counted per month. A mention means the post names the treatment, not that the writer took it. All trends

20 of the 177 people who tried it

See all 177 stories
  • Breathlessness, panic attacks and gut stasis, now near normal after K-PHOS and B1

    Near normal Dune 40577 Long COVID Mild at worstIll 4 months before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Dune 40577 fell ill after a stomach bug in November 2023 with breathlessness, panic attacks, gut stasis, tachycardia and limbs they could not control. A fourth ER visit found low phosphorus and thyroid, and prescription K-PHOS with benfotamine B1 helped…

  • Daily nerve pain and brain fog with long COVID, much better after deficiencies corrected

    Much better Alpine 75964 Long COVID Moderate at worstIll 2 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Alpine 75964, a 25-year-old woman, fell ill with COVID in July 2024 and was in pain daily, with nerve pain, brain fog, anxiety and intrusive thoughts. Correcting deficiencies, antihistamines, aspirin, probiotics and other supplements improved her step by…

  • Housebound with long COVID, gains from rest and diet, then a months-long crash

    Relapsed Dew 45619 Long COVID Severe at worstIll 3 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    A person in Ireland developed ME/CFS-type long COVID after a COVID infection in November 2023 and became housebound, while still working remotely from bed. They credited rest/pacing, diet changes and supplement advice from a nutrition practitioner with slow,…

  • xploit316 on Phoenix Rising

    Somewhat better ME/CFS Mild at worstIll 7 years before improving forums.phoenixrising.me Sep 2026

    xploit316, a Melbourne man, traced his illness to food poisoning in India in 2014, followed by hypothyroidism, food intolerances and gut symptoms. He managed it mainly with diet, avoiding high-histamine, high-fibre and high-fructose foods, and said a…

  • Mostly bedbound with ME/CFS, now somewhat better with fludrocortisone and beta blockers

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · Not saidKestrel 92313 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 15 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Kestrel 92313 had ME/CFS for about 15 years, mild at first and severe/mostly bedbound (90–95% bedbound) by early 2026. Fludrocortisone, beta blockers, salt and fluids for POTS were part of measures giving about 10% improvement, and they remained severe and…

  • Long COVID with muscle weakness, now somewhat better with methylene blue and amino acids

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · Not saidOtter 63176 Long COVID Moderate at worst reddit.com Oct 2026

    Otter 63176 has long COVID with MCAS, PEM, brain fog and muscle weakness, and was at their worst for about 18 months. An amino acid stack of D-aspartic acid and L-ornithine gave same-day relief that faded within days; a parasite cleanse with methylene blue,…

  • what has worked for you

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · Not saidhelen1 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 17 months before improving forums.phoenixrising.me Oct 2026

    helen1 fell ill in July 2012 after a hiking and cycling holiday and stopped work. Methylation (B12, methylfolate and carnitine taken before food) plus gut treatment took her from doing almost nothing to part-time work by 2014. HBOT gave four good months in…

  • Housebound with ME/CFS, now somewhat better cognitively with low-dose naltrexone

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · HelpedEagle 99879 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 30 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    He describes ME/CFS that began in childhood and worsened over about 30 years, leaving him housebound and Bell 10-20 by 2023. High-dose prednisolone gave near-total symptom relief while taken but was unsustainable, while low-dose naltrexone produced lasting…

  • ME/CFS insomnia and fatigue improved with antihistamines and diet, then relapsed

    Relapsed Doesn’t credit it · Not saidStarling 25339 ME/CFS Moderate at worstIll 6 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    An Australian with long COVID had seven COVID infections; insomnia worsened over roughly 18 months to two years, then the seventh infection triggered MCAS and fatigue, with POTS diagnosed later. Trigger avoidance, mast cell stabilisers and antihistamines,…

  • Bedbound with long COVID, crashing after showers, somewhat better with physio and cortisol

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · HelpedCardinal 34410 ME/CFS Very severe at worstIll 6 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Cardinal 34410 caught COVID in October 2020 and developed long COVID, which worsened after a severe reaction to a single dose of sertraline. Chest physiotherapy and cortisol replacement helped for a while, but a 2024 reinfection left them bedbound and still…

  • Largely bedbound with ME/CFS, improved on selenium then relapsed after COVID

    Relapsed Doesn’t credit it · HelpedBeacon 93877 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 5 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    An ME/CFS patient from about 2007 after a coxsackievirus B4 infection, they were once largely bedbound. High-dose selenium (400 mcg daily) moved them up half a level within 10 days in 2012, and they still take it, sliding back within days without it. They…

  • Long COVID brain fog and nerve symptoms, now almost back to normal after rest and diet

    Near normal Doesn’t credit it · HelpedOcean 57371 Long COVID Mild at worstIll 3.5 years before improving or writing reddit.com Sep 2026

    A high school teacher who caught COVID in January 2023, he developed a mostly neurological long COVID with brain fog, insomnia, nerve tingling and numbness, DPDR and vision problems. He kept teaching, taking some months off. He credits rest, a strict…

  • List of ME/CFS Recovery and Improvement Stories (page 7-9 discussion)

    Relapsed Doesn’t credit it · HelpedBrightCandle ME/CFS Very severe at worstIll 5.5 years before improving forums.phoenixrising.me Aug 2026

    BrightCandle had mild ME/CFS for about five years, then crashes from GP-prescribed graded exercise and a vestibular session, and Covid in 2020, left him very severe and bedbound for months. Melatonin and Joshua Leisk's supplement protocol brought a rapid…

  • List of ME/CFS Recovery and Improvement Stories (page 7-8 discussion)

    Relapsed Doesn’t credit it · Worsegodlovesatrier ME/CFS Moderate at worstIll 18 months before improving forums.phoenixrising.me Aug 2026

    godlovesatrier fell ill after glandular fever in 2016 and was severe for about 18 months before building back to full-time work with herbal antivirals, high-dose thiamine, the Born Free protocol, valtrex and molnupiravir. He reached about 80–90% in…

  • A year unable to run with long COVID, now about 70% recovered with pacing and breathwork

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · Not saidIsland 59459 Long COVID Mild at worstIll 1 year before improving or writing reddit.com Aug 2026

    Running 70k before COVID in May 2024, Island 59459 could not run for a year afterwards, with tingling legs, PEM and anhedonia, though working 32 hours a week was extremely rough. Pacing, Wim Hof breathwork, meditation and supplements including citrulline…

  • Very severe ME/CFS, now housebound, much better with vortioxetine and low-histamine diet

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · HelpedVale 36036 ME/CFS Very severe at worst reddit.com Aug 2026

    After months on ADHD stimulants, they crashed into very severe ME/CFS in early 2025, needing to be held to reach the bathroom and unable to tolerate light or sound. Over the next year a carer, low-dose vortioxetine, nightly promethazine, lymphatic drainage…

  • Severe PEM with ME/CFS; prednisolone and nimodipine effects wore off

    No benefit Doesn’t credit it · Not saidTulip 79969 ME/CFS Moderate at worstIll for 16 years reddit.com Aug 2026

    Tulip 79969 links ME/CFS to EBV, with severe prolonged PEM after upper-body effort and exhaustion pulling tights on or off. A prednisolone course for another condition around 2010 briefly restored clear thinking, then wore off. Nimodipine eased head pain and…

  • Bedbound for months with long COVID, improved then relapsed, now about half capacity

    Relapsed Doesn’t credit it · No changeTrail 89963 Long COVID Severe at worstIll 2.5 years before improving or writing reddit.com Jul 2026

    A 28-year-old pharmacist got long COVID after an infection in late 2023 and was bedbound for months. He tried dozens of drugs and supplements; niacinamide and minerals did nothing, and metformin crashed him from 90% to 10% of baseline, leaving him two months…

  • ME/CFS: fatigue, brain fog and PEM, now mostly back to normal on diet and B vitamins

    Near normal Doesn’t credit it · HelpedMeadow 43954 ME/CFS Mild at worstIll 6 years before improving or writing reddit.com Jul 2026

    Meadow 43954 fell ill around the start of the COVID pandemic with constant head pressure, fatigue, brain fog and rolling PEM while working part-time. A low-glycemic diet, herbal antimicrobial tinctures and B vitamins with magnesium brought improvement;…

  • Alvin2 on Phoenix Rising

    No benefit Doesn’t credit it · No change ME/CFS Moderate at worstIll for 20 years forums.phoenixrising.me Jul 2026

    Alvin2 had been ill about 20 years by 2017, mostly housebound with severe cognitive limits, a non-24-hour body clock and needing 10-11 hours of sleep. Methylfolate with B12 shortened his PEM and eased headaches; D-ribose, acetyl carnitine and immune-factor…

These are the newest 4 of the 36 who credit Manganese for their improvement, then the newest 16 of the 141 who tried it without crediting it, in about the same proportion as the full list.

A little hope, every Sunday

New recovery stories and data-driven research on ME/CFS and long COVID. Ideas worth considering, and the evidence behind them.

Free · Unsubscribe anytime