Miruvor
Sign up

Astragalus

How it went for everyone who tried it

Helped means they said it helped with what they took it for, which may be one symptom and not the illness.

70%
helped
115 of 163
17%
no change
27 of 163
13%
got worse
21 of 163

Shares are out of the 163 people who said how it went. 54 more tried it without saying how it went overall; 7 of them describe a problem.

How it wentPeopleShare
Helped a lot106%
Helped10564%
No change2717%
Worse1912%
Much worse21%
Where it was reportedHelpedSaid how it went
Reddit77101
Recovery stories3862

Did it last, for everyone it helped?

  • It wore off for 6 of the 115 people it helped: 2 who credit it for their improvement, 4 who don’t.

Ask about this treatment

Among the 80 who credit it with their improvement, here’s how they are now

Credit it means they say it’s one reason they got better: 20 say it helped them most; 60 say it was one of several things that helped.

23%
recovered or near normal
18 of 79
56%
much or somewhat better
44 of 79
20%
relapsed
16 of 79
1%
no benefit
1 of 79
1
outcome unclear
not in the shares

Where each person was at the end of their story, or in their latest post that says how they are, compared with their worst point.

Outcome describedPeopleShare
Recovered56%
Near normal1317%
Much better1823%
Somewhat better2633%
Relapsed1620%
No benefit11%
Outcome unclear1—

Did it last?

  • 2 of the 80 who credit it said its benefit wore off.
  • 49 of the 80 who credit it say they still need to keep doing something (not always this) to stay well.

By how ill people were

Only the 80 who credit it, so people it didn’t help or made worse aren’t here. How they are now is their outcome overall, not the effect of this one treatment.

Severity at worstHow they are nownRecovered or near normal
Mild2227%
Moderate1443%
Severe2910%
Very severe333%, few people
Not stated1218%
At worstOutcomePeopleShare
MildRecovered1 of 225%
MildNear normal5 of 2222%
MildMuch better2 of 229%
MildSomewhat better9 of 2241%
MildRelapsed5 of 2223%
ModerateRecovered2 of 1414%
ModerateNear normal4 of 1429%
ModerateMuch better6 of 1443%
ModerateSomewhat better1 of 147%
ModerateRelapsed1 of 147%
SevereRecovered1 of 293%
SevereNear normal2 of 297%
SevereMuch better8 of 2928%
SevereSomewhat better10 of 2934%
SevereRelapsed7 of 2924%
SevereNo benefit1 of 294%
Very severeNear normal1 of 333%
Very severeMuch better2 of 367%
Not statedRecovered1 of 119%
Not statedNear normal1 of 119%
Not statedSomewhat better6 of 1155%
Not statedRelapsed3 of 1127%

Adverse events

What people said went wrong, in their own words.

41 of 217

people who wrote about taking it described a problem they tied to it

Described one · 41Didn’t mention one · 176

The serious kinds

Worth telling a doctor about straight away.

  • Made them much worse

    2 people
    “I might've herxed after astragalus. I stopped after a week. Exacerbation of all symptoms to a severe level.”
    — Swan 12591
    “every time I take an immune stimulating drug or herb I have cold symptoms and much worse ME symptoms ... This includes: cimetidine, astragalus, humic acid, reishi, coriolus, proboost.”
    — Inez
  • Mood or psychiatric effects

    3 people
    “pretty much all flavonoids are MAOI, they caused my serotonin syndrome.”
    — Comet 53354
    “they increase inflammatory symptoms and the most bothersome effect is they produce depression and fatigue that is worse than normal”
    — JES
    Show 1 moreShow fewer
    “I tried adding Astragalus recently which is another natural antiviral but that very quickly led to a fight or flight feeling, so not right for me.”
    — Stone 38359

The serious kinds are a death, suicidal thoughts or an attempt, a hospital stay, an ER visit, an allergic reaction or anaphylaxis, heart rhythm, liver or kidney, blood count, mood or psychiatric, or refeeding or deficiency problems, and being made much worse: a large worsening such as a crash lasting weeks or more.

Other kinds

Unpleasant effects people tied to it, the most serious first.

Made symptoms worse · 15Autoimmune or inflammatory flare · 3Withdrawal problems · 1Gut side effects · 6Insomnia from treatment · 3Herx / die-off reaction · 2Nerve pain · 1Side effects · 13Other · 1 Show all 9Hide
  • Made symptoms worse

    15 people
    “I also react really badly and get PEM from immune regulating herbs like astragalus and echinacea, and adaptogens like ashwaganda.”
    — Stream 28708
    “However I started yesterday a trial of astragalus and it looks like it’s flared up again.”
    — Treeman
    Show 13 moreShow fewer
    “the antimicrobial herbs have aggreviated my symptoms and been too much for my microbiome to handle”
    — Comet 53354
    “After intake of one of these sups I react badly to toxins, this takes days and sometimes a week.”
    — jason30
    “every time I take an immune stimulating drug or herb I have cold symptoms and much worse ME symptoms ... This includes: cimetidine, astragalus, humic acid, reishi, coriolus, proboost.”
    — Inez
    “Whenever I took it I would feel very tired and achy. Almost like a fever, but without an actual fever temperature. I tried it a few times but eventually had to stop”
    — Wave 42618
    “I just tried it and it seemed to throw me into a major PEM”
    — Coast 68053
    “Now I realize that they were actually prolonging my flares, rather than helping a cold or a flu!”
    — ljimbo423
    “I have taken astragalus in the past and I thought it made me worse.”
    — helios
    “Astragalus and Cat's claw knock me out.”
    — Sidereal
    “Astragalus acute makes me feel slightly ill but over time it tends to make me feel good energy wise.”
    — ramakentesh
    “Worst thing I could have done. Within 20 minutes of taking them my twitching went crazy all over my body, my symptoms enflamed like crazy.”
    — PhoenixBurger
    “Last year I got a similar reaction (although not as awful as today's) when I tried astragalus to boost immune function.”
    — Antares in NYC
    “My symptoms after 2 or 3 days include flu-like symptoms, severe fatigue and increased pain, lasting 2 to 3 days.”
    — Sinclair
    “I also tried astragalus by itself before, and experienced similar headaches and fatigue.”
    — Binky123
  • Autoimmune or inflammatory flare

    3 people
    “I have Hashimoto's and react to some immune stimulants like astragalus and turkey tail, but I tolerate cat's claw well.”
    — Puffin 24989
    “Lately I have been trying rather high doses of astragalus ... and my histamine/allergic symptoms are really acting up”
    — adreno
    Show 1 moreShow fewer
    “I can't take immune boosters like those listed above, as they cause an autoimmune flare-up.”
    — CBS64
  • Withdrawal problems

    1 person
    “on two occasions when I stopped taking astragalus, my symptoms worsened and the viral titers sharply increased.”
    — oncemoreuntothebreach
  • Gut side effects

    6 people
    “I tried it a long time ago for something else pre-covid and got bloody stools”
    — Alpine 80601
    “i started making my IBSD worse”
    — Comet 23941
    Show 4 moreShow fewer
    “I stopped taking it from stomach upset unfortunately.”
    — Bluebell 35299
    “Super gassy since I started it. Not 100% sure it's the astralagus, but the timing lines up.”
    — Acorn 87878
    “I did try some astragalus a few days ago but it didn't help at all and it hurt my stomach a bit.”
    — mrquasar
    “I stopped because the (liquid) astralagus was making me nauseas”
    — mikipe2
  • Insomnia from treatment

    3 people
    “My insomnia was at an all time high/severe in July bc I unknowingly triggered it”
    — Comet 53354
    “I tried ACE2 stuff like Agmatine Sulfate and Dandelion, perhaps another. Both times I got issues with sleep (racing thoughts, lack of deep sleep, sleep feeling artificial, etc.).”
    — Lake 57841
    Show 1 moreShow fewer
    “because sometime Huangqi will give u too much energy,and u cannot sleep well at night.”
    — mars2014
  • Herx / die-off reaction

    2 people
    “And now I have herx reactions with strange taste of pepper with a plant used against borrelia and bacterian biofilm in general (carderelle), at a very low dose.”
    — Crest 87595
    “I might've herxed after astragalus. I stopped after a week. Exacerbation of all symptoms to a severe level.”
    — Swan 12591
  • Nerve pain

    1 person
    “Also some deep muscle/nerve pains.”
    — Wave 42618
  • Side effects

    13 people
    “I couldn't get HDQ so I tried red cinchona bark and it gave me a terrible headache”
    — Trail 96635
    “I'm still taking it, only one a day (it says to take four but I found i just got exhausted from the intake)”
    — Oak 15492
    Show 11 moreShow fewer
    “I have only tried herbs for mycoplasma, didn't go too well tbh.”
    — Comet 53354
    “This week I’ve taken l theanine, vitamin D plus K 2, mag threonate, ... Could this be the cause?”
    — Tundra 92430
    “I tend to feel slightly shaky and shivery, like a low grade fever. My temperature doesn't go into actual fever territory though.”
    — Wave 42618
    “one of the other herbs Amla/Amalaki causes me very dry skin which is not helpful so I don't like using it”
    — Oak 81352
    “I blamed it on ashwa. I mean the 1st day i was amazing, finally standing up and moving around. Now i m feeling so hot and cold. That s weird.”
    — Coast 85389
    “body temperature became extremely low (I was freezing cold). the same thing happened with astralagus and few other herbs”
    — Mylifesobright
    “I've been using astragalus for a few weeks and it has caused a massive headache in the last few days or so.”
    — rwac
    “If i dont do so, i feel terribly heaty and will get sick”
    — wintersky
    “Astragalus is tricky for me; it usually causes jerking limbs and insomnia.”
    — zoe.a.m.
    “My flu-like symptoms have increased by the 5th day on additional Astragalus, with strange symptoms such as upper lip trembling and feeling of dust in my eye”
    — Sinclair
    “Multi herb combos I tend to react to especially anything with astragalus in it”
    — end
  • Other

    1 person
    “I'm currently experimenting with astralagus, but my teeth issues seem to have reared their head again. Almost feels like I got a cavity”
    — Lake 57841

How often it comes up

Posts that mention Astragalus, per 1,000 posts each month. Hover or tap a point for the count.

05201020142017202020232026
MonthPosts mentioning itAll postsPer 1,000
Oct 200901050
Jan 201001410
Feb 201001130
Jun 201101090
Nov 201111248.1
Dec 201101990
Jan 201202320
Feb 201201030
Mar 201201900
Apr 201201620
May 201203750
Jun 201202380
Jul 201202400
Aug 201204850
Sep 201205610
Oct 201255269.5
Nov 201205140
Dec 201206990
Jan 201305330
Feb 201314472.2
Mar 201304290
Apr 201304990
May 201306060
Jun 201306090
Jul 201306160
Aug 201315771.7
Sep 201313642.7
Oct 201305360
Nov 201303850
Dec 201305190
Jan 201409440
Feb 201408210
Mar 201404250
Apr 201413612.8
May 201406170
Jun 201404890
Jul 201404440
Aug 201416221.6
Sep 201405070
Oct 201406780
Nov 201405670
Dec 201416291.6
Jan 201507600
Feb 201508730
Mar 201501,2760
Apr 201509840
May 201511,4960.67
Jun 201501,0460
Jul 201501,2110
Aug 201509980
Sep 201551,0604.7
Oct 201541,2553.2
Nov 201501,2460
Dec 201509240
Jan 201601,2820
Feb 201621,0511.9
Mar 201601,0020
Apr 201609980
May 201601,0450
Jun 201601,2300
Jul 201611,6190.62
Aug 201611,7290.58
Sep 201601,7850
Oct 201601,2200
Nov 201611,0920.92
Dec 201601,2110
Jan 201701,6600
Feb 201701,9880
Mar 201702,0780
Apr 201712,1330.47
May 201712,3700.42
Jun 201702,1940
Jul 201702,1830
Aug 201702,4660
Sep 201702,1890
Oct 201703,0420
Nov 201701,9760
Dec 201702,1120
Jan 201802,6200
Feb 201802,1550
Mar 201812,6130.38
Apr 201822,2510.89
May 201812,8280.35
Jun 201813,8710.26
Jul 201803,0670
Aug 201803,7570
Sep 201803,5120
Oct 201803,2610
Nov 201802,8610
Dec 201802,7540
Jan 201913,6720.27
Feb 201902,7150
Mar 201903,3170
Apr 201903,1410
May 201903,8550
Jun 201903,3920
Jul 201903,3120
Aug 201923,9430.51
Sep 201914,0350.25
Oct 201903,9220
Nov 201903,5080
Dec 201903,6590
Jan 202004,6500
Feb 202004,3740
Mar 202004,4750
Apr 202003,6900
May 202004,5430
Jun 202005,7010
Jul 202026,1040.33
Aug 2020010,3330
Sep 2020111,9580.08
Oct 2020114,5680.07
Nov 2020016,5460
Dec 2020520,7640.24
Jan 2021824,5620.33
Feb 2021524,6720.20
Mar 2021329,4760.10
Apr 2021228,5090.07
May 2021025,7910
Jun 2021427,8710.14
Jul 2021427,2200.15
Aug 2021430,8080.13
Sep 2021030,0740
Oct 2021122,1320.05
Nov 2021227,7220.07
Dec 2021431,8720.13
Jan 2022142,3170.02
Feb 2022338,6970.08
Mar 2022144,3050.02
Apr 2022144,3330.02
May 2022350,5940.06
Jun 2022549,0580.10
Jul 2022353,4850.06
Aug 2022054,4550
Sep 2022556,9360.09
Oct 2022658,5110.10
Nov 2022159,1980.02
Dec 2022461,5760.06
Jan 2023461,0040.07
Feb 20232750,1330.54
Mar 20231859,9250.30
Apr 20231354,2510.24
May 20231357,7680.23
Jun 20231352,6790.25
Jul 20231156,4010.20
Aug 2023665,4350.09
Sep 2023861,8350.13
Oct 2023958,4190.15
Nov 2023653,6620.11
Dec 20232460,6430.40
Jan 20241171,8180.15
Feb 2024170,0450.01
Mar 2024868,2610.12
Apr 2024764,3740.11
May 20241367,6980.19
Jun 2024864,7200.12
Jul 20241165,3350.17
Aug 2024668,5170.09
Sep 2024470,1680.06
Oct 2024472,6070.06
Nov 2024571,8020.07
Dec 2024774,4010.09
Jan 20252277,9090.28
Feb 20251765,1100.26
Mar 20251369,9050.19
Apr 2025961,6060.15
May 2025665,7330.09
Jun 2025560,5400.08
Jul 2025862,1050.13
Aug 2025864,5780.12
Sep 2025561,7040.08
Oct 20251159,2040.19
Nov 2025958,9440.15
Dec 2025362,8300.05
Jan 2026263,3210.03
Feb 2026453,0850.08
Mar 2026359,2080.05
Apr 2026353,9890.06
May 2026157,5410.02
Jun 2026255,3010.04
Jul 2026456,3910.07
Aug 2026256,8250.04
Sep 2026157,1430.02

Forum and Reddit posts, 4,007,898 in all, counted per month. A mention means the post names the treatment, not that the writer took it. All trends

20 of the 217 people who tried it

See all 217 stories
  • Often bedbound with long COVID, now almost back to normal after diet and rowing regimen

    Near normal Osprey 74759 Long COVID Ill 2.5 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Osprey 74759 fell ill with long COVID in October 2020 and after about 2.5 years was often bedbound, unable to walk 100 m without near-fainting. In 2023 a self-designed supplement, diet and rowing-machine regimen produced rapid gains: from bedridden to…

  • Couchbound with ME/CFS at worst, improved with pacing and LDN, then relapsed after COVID

    Relapsed Lake 74243 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 3 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Lake 74243 fell ill after influenza A in January 2024 and was moderate for months, couchbound at worst. Rigorous pacing, CoQ10, LDN from October 2024 and compression boots brought them to a very mild, near-remission state by autumn 2025. A COVID-19 infection…

  • Unable to stand or walk across the room with ME/CFS, now much better on supplements and NaturDAO

    Much better Tulip 50673 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 30 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Tulip 50673's ME/CFS came from latent EBV after some 30 years of wear, with MCAS and histamine intolerance on top. They retired early, unable to stand or walk across the room. Supplements and NaturDAO brought a night-and-day change; they now do yard work and…

  • Largely bedbound with long COVID, now somewhat better, crediting niacin and melatonin

    Somewhat better Trail 96635 Long COVID Severe at worstIll 6 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    A person in Illinois fell ill in March 2020 (COVID not confirmed) and by around 18 months was largely bedbound, with breathlessness, panic attacks and brain fog. They improved slowly from around month 17, crediting niacin, melatonin, thiamine and vitamin D.…

  • Daily nerve pain and brain fog with long COVID, much better after deficiencies corrected

    Much better Alpine 75964 Long COVID Moderate at worstIll 2 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Alpine 75964, a 25-year-old woman, fell ill with COVID in July 2024 and was in pain daily, with nerve pain, brain fog, anxiety and intrusive thoughts. Correcting deficiencies, antihistamines, aspirin, probiotics and other supplements improved her step by…

  • Long COVID with severe brain fog and PEM, now nearly normal after methylene blue

    Near normal Dusk 25060 Long COVID Moderate at worstIll 8 months before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    After their fifth COVID infection they developed long COVID with ME/CFS, POTS, MCAS, severe brain fog, PEM and hypoxia, were hospitalised twice and had a TIA. Methylene blue immediately cleared the hypoxia, PEM, ME/CFS, POTS and brain fog, and 7 mg nicotine…

  • Long COVID with POTS and brain fog, somewhat better with kefir and P5P

    Somewhat better Osprey 90789 Long COVID Moderate at worstIll 5.5 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Osprey 90789 caught COVID in March 2020, aged 27, and has had long COVID since, with POTS, brain fog, one-sided numbness, nausea and hot flashes. He has not been able to work part-time yet and uses a cane outdoors and a kick scooter around his house. He…

  • Long COVID with PEM and fatigue for five years, now 95% normal after low-histamine diet

    Near normal Doesn’t credit it · HelpedShore 89796 Long COVID Moderate at worst reddit.com Oct 2026

    Pam, 84, of northwestern Nevada, caught COVID-19 in October 2020 and worked on long COVID with PEM and debilitating fatigue for over five years. She took amino acids and other supplements for mitochondrial support, paced, and did daily Yoga Nidra. She later…

  • Bedridden with ME/CFS, now much better with aggressive rest and immune globulin

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · WorseStream 28708 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 10 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Developed ME/CFS at 13 after mononucleosis and became bedridden with months of rolling PEM, worsened by exercise addiction and a COVID vaccine. Aggressive rest plus subcutaneous immune globulin (20 g/week), testosterone, growth hormone and peptides took him…

  • Long COVID foot vessel ruptures, nearly normal after pycnogenol and B12

    Near normal Doesn’t credit it · WorsePuffin 24989 Long COVID Mild at worstIll 4 months before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Their long COVID was mainly vascular. After likely COVID-19 in March 2020 they developed lower-leg circulation problems and spontaneous blood-vessel ruptures in their feet; high-dose pycnogenol with krill oil improved the circulation within weeks and…

  • Long COVID made study hard and cut exercise, somewhat better with rhodiola

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · Not saidLake 34609 Long COVID Mild at worstIll 4 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Ill with long COVID since late 2022, a college student could study only with difficulty and had dropped exercise, choir and most friends. Rhodiola rosea gave the biggest gains in energy and brain fog; LDN, low-dose propranolol and compression tights helped…

  • Long COVID at 40-50% of normal, now nearly back to normal after brain retraining

    Near normal Doesn’t credit it · HelpedAlpine 80601 Long COVID Mild at worstIll 14 months before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    A woman got long COVID in September 2024 after a third COVID infection, with severe depression, head pressure, air hunger, tachycardia and later PEM; she rated herself about 40-50% of normal. After 70-plus supplements and drugs gave little lasting benefit,…

  • Housebound with ME/CFS, in bed 23 hours a day; low-carb helped, antibiotic gains faded

    Relapsed Doesn’t credit it · No changeOrchid 18458 ME/CFS Very severe at worstIll 28 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    In Australia, Orchid 18458 became ill after an EBV infection around 1998 and never recovered. Pushing through with a backpacking holiday and six years of graded exercise left them permanently worse; a graded return to work caused a crash. A low-carb diet…

  • Mild long COVID worsened after Pfizer doses, now somewhat better but brain fog persists

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · No changeMarsh 24960 Long COVID Mild at worstIll 3 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    A man who had mild long COVID after a COVID infection in mid-2020 and worsened sharply after two Pfizer doses in 2021. His physical symptoms, including PEM, resolved in 2023, and by 2026 he was working a demanding full-time job and exercising three times a…

  • Bedridden with long COVID at first, now much better with LDN and ketotifen

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · Not saidSwan 40811 Long COVID Severe at worstIll 4 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    She recovered to 85-95% after a severe March 2020 COVID infection; a second infection in October 2022 was followed by long COVID with fatigue, PEM, brain fog, migraines, insomnia, POTS and MCAS, at first bedridden apart from a few hours of client work, later…

  • Mild ME/CFS after mono, unable to work, still no clear benefit from supplements

    No benefit Doesn’t credit it · Not saidPrairie 54490 ME/CFS Moderate at worst reddit.com Oct 2026

    Prairie 54490 fell ill with ME/CFS after mono around 2005 and has had a mostly mild case, unable to work and limited to short walks. He tried low-dose Abilify, Adderall, natural antivirals and many supplements; Abilify helped briefly but caused anxiety and…

  • Long COVID brain fog, PEM and insomnia; nicotine patches gave no overall benefit

    No benefit Doesn’t credit it · HelpedFjord 58789 Long COVID Moderate at worstIll for 4 years reddit.com Oct 2026

    A Texas man with CFS since 2003 fell ill with long COVID about three years ago after symptomless COVID complications that hospitalised him for a week. He has chronic high blood pressure despite previous low blood pressure, plus chest pressure, leg swelling,…

  • Housebound with long COVID, at worst bedridden, still no better

    No benefit Doesn’t credit it · Not saidIsland 23703 Long COVID Severe at worstIll for 6 years reddit.com Sep 2026

    Island 23703 caught COVID at work in July 2020 and has been housebound since, at worst bedridden for a year after crashing at an event and bedridden for several years after physical therapy. A probiotic helped her eat and lifted her mood, and antihistamines…

  • Long COVID worse to 2021, better after mould move, supplements, then relapsed housebound

    Relapsed Doesn’t credit it · Not saidDusk 28795 Long COVID Moderate at worstIll 2 years before improving or writing reddit.com Sep 2026

    Dusk 28795 fell ill with long COVID after a December 2019 infection, with symptoms from March 2020, and grew steadily worse until late 2021. Moving out of a mouldy house, a supplement regimen and breaks from work due to a layoff turned a corner in early…

  • Bedbound for a month with ME/CFS, much better after pacing and low-dose naltrexone

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · No changeOrchid 36309 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 6 years before improving or writing reddit.com Sep 2026

    He caught covid in December 2020 at 19 and had brain fog for a year while working part-time and studying. A crash in early 2022 left him bedbound for about a month and permanently lowered his baseline. Low-dose naltrexone (3 mg) and strict pacing slowly…

These are the newest 7 of the 80 who credit Astragalus for their improvement, then the newest 13 of the 137 who tried it without crediting it, in about the same proportion as the full list.

A little hope, every Sunday

New recovery stories and data-driven research on ME/CFS and long COVID. Ideas worth considering, and the evidence behind them.

Free · Unsubscribe anytime