MacGyver on Phoenix Rising
- Condition
- Condition not stated
- At worst
- Not stated
- Ill before improving or writing
- Not stated
- Last post
- Jul 2016
In their words
- Now: Somewhat better
Have made very big gains though ... I'm positive there are still (many) roadblocks left
The story comes from their 32 posts in 10 threads
Summary
MacGyver described depression, pain, insomnia and low energy, and could not tolerate magnesium at all until he started boron. Boron, then B2 (a light switch for his mood), B6/P5P, manganese, calcium and vitamin D let him raise magnesium, though doubling boron brought a week of severe pain and depression. Amino acids and SAMe helped his mood briefly; he was still fine-tuning B2 and magnesium.
Ask Miruvor AI
What they tried
What they credit
Also tried
Their words about each treatment
- boron · Helped a lot
boron in high dosage (+-30mg/day) is very, very beneficial
In context ↗ - magnesium · Helped
Have made very big gains though
In context ↗ - B2 · Helped a lot
So far I've had tremendous success with B2 as well (it's like a light switch for my mood)
In context ↗ - P5P · Helped
I become angry and anxious when I don't take sufficient magnesium along with my P5P, but can't take magnesium without the P5P.
In context ↗ - potassium · Helped
Had increased heart rate/thumping which responds to potassium
In context ↗ - salt · No change
take potassium, salt, more P5P, B2, general vitamin complex, all other trace minerals etc. nothing worked.
In context ↗ - methylfolate · No change
I never had a positive response to it anyway.
In context ↗ - Methylcobalamin and Adenosylcobalamin · Not said
Something tells me I'll finally experience hypokalemia symptoms which I haven't with taking Methylfolate, Methylcobalamin, Adenosylcobalamin or Carnitine.
In context ↗ - vitamin D · Helped
If I take magnesium without D I get a specific set of symptoms (feeling cold, depressed etc.) which are resolved by taking D.
In context ↗ - manganese · Helped
Also had success with high dosage of boron (+-30mg/day), manganese (up to 20mg/day) and B2 (3x25mg/day)
In context ↗ - calcium · Helped
My latest 'discovery' is that I need to take calcium to balance out the magnesium I'm taking.
In context ↗ - vitamin C · Helped
I think vitamine C is now like a gaspedal for me.
In context ↗ - Betaine HCL · Worse
Tried some Betaine HCL this week with a major increase in pain as a result
In context ↗ - Phosphatidylcholine · Worse
I'm just coming out of a week-long Phosphatidylcholine, TMG and possibly Betaine HCL induced depressed week
In context ↗ - TMG · Worse
I can't take either TMG or Carnitine at this point.
In context ↗ - Carnitine (Fumarate) · Worse
All I know is I can't take either TMG or Carnitine at this point.
In context ↗ - SAMe · Helped
Took some SAMe (Now Foods 100mg) and I got the exact same response to it as with the 9 aminos: a relaxed feeling.
In context ↗ - 9 essential aminos · Helped
I've been taking some ammino acids (Now foods 9 essential aminos) and I do feel an improvement though I'm taking it slowly.
In context ↗ - Methionine · No change
Did try Methionine separately today but too short after a 9 amino's dose to make meaningful conclusions. ... Initial conclusion would be that it did nothing.
In context ↗ - Cod Liver Oil · Not said
I actually tried upping my vitamin A intake by taking Cod Liver Oil but only once so that's not enough to draw any conclusion from.
In context ↗ - zinc · Not said
I should have fidled with my B2, B6 and zinc dosages
In context ↗
Approaches: Amino acids and carnitine · Supplements
Their path
They say too little about how ill they were at each step to draw it on the severity scale, so the steps are listed as they describe them.
| When | What happened | After |
|---|---|---|
| 2015-10-27 | Able to take magnesium after five days on boronI started taking boron (initially 1x 3mg NOW Foods Calcium Borogluconate, now 2x) and after only 5 days I'm already able to take 500mg of magnesium!In context ↗ | Boron |
| 2015-12-22 | B2 lifted his mood like a light switchSo far I've had tremendous success with B2 as well (it's like a light switch for my mood)In context ↗ | Riboflavin (vitamin B2) |
| 2015-12-23 | Doubling boron brought severe pain and worse sleepThen I doubled the boron and after a week I had severly increased pain.In context ↗ | Boron |
| 2015-12-25 | Back to the earlier boron and B2 dose, pain manageable againgo back to what worked before everything went south ... The pain is manageable againIn context ↗ | Boron |
| 2016-04-28 | Off his painkiller with boron, manganese and cofactorsI've been able to completely eliminate my painkiller with those two (and their cofactors).In context ↗ | Boron |
| 2016-06-22 | Very big gains after nine months of magnesium, boron and B2 workI can't imagine I'm still having issues with it after 9 months but I still do. Have made very big gains thoughIn context ↗ | Magnesium |
| 2016-07-25 | A week of depression and near-unbearable pain after phosphatidylcholine, TMG and betaine HCLI'm just coming out of a week-long Phosphatidylcholine, TMG and possibly Betaine HCL induced depressed weekIn context ↗ | Phosphatidylcholine |
| 2016-07-27 | Amino acids and SAMe relaxed him and lifted his moodthe 9 aminos and SAMe definitely have a positive impact on my mood and general well-beingIn context ↗ | SAMe (S-adenosylmethionine) |
| 2016-07-31 | Still fine-tuning FMN form B2 against magnesiumUpping B2 in FMN form resolved that problem.In context ↗ |
Adverse events
- Magnesium“I would get, seriously, depressed and have aggravated pain when taking even a crumb (30mg) of magnesium malate.” In context ↗ Mood or psychiatric effects
- Magnesium“I would get, seriously, depressed and have aggravated pain when taking even a crumb (30mg) of magnesium malate.” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Riboflavin (vitamin B2)“itchy scalp” In context ↗ Side effects
- Riboflavin (vitamin B2)“having trouble getting to sleep and/or waking up at 3-4-5 am then staying wide awake until sleeping again at 8 am” In context ↗ Insomnia from treatment
- Riboflavin (vitamin B2)“low energy/tired ... nearly instant when I started the B2” In context ↗ Side effects
- Riboflavin (vitamin B2)“Had low magnesium symptoms like eyelid twitching and cramping in feet - only in the first week after taking B2.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Riboflavin (vitamin B2)“Had increased heart rate/thumping which responds to potassium (depleting B1?)” In context ↗ Heart rhythm problems
- Riboflavin (vitamin B2)“Increased pain (either nerve or muscle related or both) lower back/belly feels like it heats up, sometimes stabbing pains on the front right” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Boron“I intially had the same response to it as with the B2: insomnia and fatigue.” In context ↗ Insomnia from treatment
- Boron“That immediately caused more sleep problems and probably lead to my current issues.” In context ↗ Insomnia from treatment
- Boron“Then I doubled the boron and after a week I had severly increased pain.” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Riboflavin (vitamin B2)“B2 causing light orange stool, insomnia, fatigue etc.” In context ↗ Gut side effects
- Riboflavin (vitamin B2)“overload my liver (which I had again on Saturday after loading too much B2 on Friday)” In context ↗ Liver or kidney problems
- Vitamin B6 (pyridoxine, P5P)“upping my P5P/B2 intake while not increasing my magnesium intake; that leads to feelings of anger and a certain anxious/tense feeling along with some eyelid twitching” In context ↗ Mood or psychiatric effects
- Vitamin B6 (pyridoxine, P5P)“some eyelid twitching” In context ↗ Side effects
- Magnesium“feeling sleepy and weak when I up it too fast” In context ↗ Side effects
- Magnesium“Before the above my pain increased terribly and I became depressed, badly.” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Magnesium“Before the above my pain increased terribly and I became depressed, badly.” In context ↗ Mood or psychiatric effects
- Vitamin C“noradrenaline rises too high.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Betaine HCl“Tried some Betaine HCL this week with a major increase in pain as a result” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Trimethylglycine (TMG, betaine)“Phosphatidylcholine, TMG and possibly Betaine HCL induced depressed week where I go into complete freak-out and tunnel vision mode” In context ↗ Mood or psychiatric effects
- Trimethylglycine (TMG, betaine)“the amount of pain I then experience goes up to nearly unbearable proportions (low dopamine!)” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Phosphatidylcholine“Phosphatidylcholine, TMG and possibly Betaine HCL induced depressed week where I go into complete freak-out and tunnel vision mode” In context ↗ Mood or psychiatric effects
- Phosphatidylcholine“the amount of pain I then experience goes up to nearly unbearable proportions (low dopamine!)” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Magnesium“After a while I have to stop taking it as it causes increased pain and depression and/or just a general crash of everything.” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- L-carnitine“my bad response to Carnitine Fumarate” In context ↗ Side effects
- Betaine HCl“Regarding the wired feeling on excess Betaine and thus TMG” In context ↗ Side effects
Symptoms mentioned
Their words about their symptoms
- Pain & fibromyalgia
increased pain (either nerve or muscle related or both)
In context ↗ - Sleep problems
having trouble getting to sleep and/or waking up at 3-4-5 am then staying wide awake until sleeping again at 8 am
In context ↗ - Anxiety & low mood
Symptoms after taking B2 (which totally clears out my depressive symptoms mind you)
In context ↗ - Brain fog
My foggy brain has reminded me of something
In context ↗ - Heart symptoms & palpitations
Had increased heart rate/thumping which responds to potassium
In context ↗ - Neuropathy & tingling
I have some very mild tingling in my left arm and leg.
In context ↗ - Gut problems
when bile is too low (as evidenced by light/floating stool)
In context ↗
Ask Miruvor AI
Similar stories
-
alethea on Phoenix Rising
Alethea described lifelong fatigue and ME/CFS-like illness, with a 2014 crash bringing fasciculations, numb lips and crushing fatigue that left her barely able to think or move. She credited high-dose thiamine (benfotiamine) with a life-changing improvement,…
-
Not enough detail to draw a path
Peace on Phoenix Rising
Peace reported being ill since birth, with 29 years of poor health and ankylosing spondylitis, gout, severe skin disease, arthritis and insomnia. A five-week antimicrobial and biofilm protocol in 2016 left Peace unable to walk, but a low-oxalate diet,…
-
Not enough detail to draw a path
Grimace92 on Phoenix Rising
Grimace92, who has CFS, chronic Lyme and candida, spent years on mineral and methylation experiments. Betaine HCl worsened sulfur symptoms, while Swedish bitters aided digestion and a broad mineral regimen left them feeling better generally. From early 2017…
-
On oxygen with long COVID, now much better after second Pfizer vaccine and low-carb diet
A Florida resident in their late fifties caught COVID in March 2020 and was severely ill, on oxygen for about two to three months. They credit a second Pfizer vaccination in 2021 with clearing their breathing, plus low-carb eating, walking and supplements.…