ME/CFS
Moderate → no benefit
biophile on Phoenix Rising
- Condition
- ME/CFS
- At worst
- Moderate (mostly housebound)
- Ill for
- Not stated
- Last post
- Sep 2014
Read the original ↗
In their words
- Condition: ME/CFS
When I was first diagnosed with "CFS", supplements had no noticeable effects at all
In context ↗ - At worst: Moderate
right now I couldn't tolerate another permanent backwards slide and want to keep whatever limited functionality I have left.
In context ↗ - Now: No benefit
I have never really recovered from the above in terms of post-exertional sysmptoms becoming worse and not being able to tolerate medications and supplements very well.
In context ↗
The story comes from their 43 posts in 37 threads
- Mar 2010
- Apr 2010
- Apr 2010
- Jul 2010
- Jul 2010
- Jul 2010
- Jun 2011
- Jun 2011
- Jul 2011
- Jul 2011
- Jul 2011
- Jul 2011
- Jul 2011
- Sep 2011
- Sep 2011
- Sep 2011
- Sep 2011
- Oct 2011
- Oct 2011
- Oct 2011
- Oct 2011
- Dec 2011
- Dec 2011
- Jan 2012
- Jan 2012
- Feb 2012
- Mar 2012
- Apr 2012
- Jun 2012
- Jul 2012
- Jul 2012
- Jul 2012
- Jul 2012
- Jul 2012
- Aug 2012
- Aug 2012
- Sep 2012
- Sep 2012
- Feb 2013
- Jan 2014
- Apr 2014
- Jul 2014
- Sep 2014
Summary
biophile had ME/CFS with years of post-exertional symptoms, POTS, sleep fragmentation, headaches and digestive problems. Weekly IV EDTA briefly helped, then made them significantly worse, with cachexia and lasting medication sensitivity. Later methylation supplements seemed to improve tolerance for a time, but no treatment gave sustained recovery; by 2014 they still reported PEM and that GET failed.
Ask Miruvor AI
What they tried
Also tried
DHA with minimal EPA· Helpedhydroxy-B12 and methyl-B12· Helpeddigestive supplements· HelpedBifidobacterium· Helpedfolinic acid· Helpedupping protein intake· Helpedincrease in carbohydrate-rich foods while greatly lowering fat intake· Helped"de-arousing" techniques (relaxation, meditation)· No changehomeopaths· No changenaturopaths· No changeJarrow Formulas sustained release NAC· No changevitamin D· No changeavoiding TV and PC in the evening· No changeremoving the PC from the bedroom· No change"power of the mind"· No changeintravenous EDTA chelation therapy· WorseSAM-e· Worsemolybdenum· Worse"liver stimulant" herbs· Worsemilk thistle· WorseMSM· Worsezinc· WorseVSL#3· Worseparacetamol/acetaminophen· Worseaspirin· Worsesustained release melatonin· Worsecoconut oil· Worseexercise and GET· Worselow levels of resistance training· Worseselenomethionine· Worsevitamin E· Worsevitamin C· Worsejuiced carrots· Worsepotassium· WorseEveryday exercise and activity· WorseFolaPro· Not saidnattokinase· Not saidacceptance and pacing· Not saidacceptance· Not saidsupplement protocol after seeing a orthomolecular doctor· Not saidMethylation support (unspecified)· Not said
Their words about each treatment
- "de-arousing" techniques (relaxation, meditation) · No change
these help induce a sense of relaxation/peace/centredness but do not improve the underlying baseline status of CFS
In context ↗ - intravenous EDTA chelation therapy · Worse
In the beginning it didn't do much, then it started helping for a few weeks and I thought I was on the road to recovery, then later it made me significantly worse
In context ↗ - homeopaths · No change
I had no success with homeopaths/naturopaths either.
In context ↗ - SAM-e · Worse
The response to SAM-e was bad and prolonged enough that you couldn't pay me to try it again.
In context ↗ - DHA with minimal EPA · Helped
Instead I take high dose DHA with minimal EPA, it seems to act as a mild "buffer" to stresses such as sensory overload.
In context ↗ - FolaPro · Not said
I am sensitive to methylfolate but am able to tolerate 0.2mg recommended by richvank.
In context ↗ - hydroxy-B12 and methyl-B12 · Helped
I suspect the methyl-B12 is helping.
In context ↗ - molybdenum · Worse
I was on 250mcg molybdenum per day for several weeks
In context ↗ - "liver stimulant" herbs · Worse
I also tried some "liver stimulant" herbs which was a mistake as well
In context ↗ - milk thistle · Worse
I also had issues with items such as milk thistle and MSM (headachy so-called "detox" symptoms).
In context ↗ - digestive supplements · Helped
Digestive supplements seemed to help a little.
In context ↗ - zinc · Worse
I seem to have developed a sensitivity to zinc even in relatively low doses
In context ↗ - VSL#3 · Worse
when I tried VSL#3, at some stage into the trial it seemed to significantly worsen this symptom about an hour or so after taking it
In context ↗ - Bifidobacterium · Helped
VSL#3 made me a little worse, but Bifidobacterium made me better
In context ↗ - Jarrow Formulas sustained release NAC · No change
so far after a few weeks of 2 x 300mg/day and sometimes more I haven't noticed anything obviously negative from the NAC, and it is cheap so I will continue
In context ↗ - vitamin D · No change
I just starting taking vitamin D too, without obvious effects.
In context ↗ - paracetamol/acetaminophen · Worse
this year I had a few negative experiences which make me want to avoid paracetamol/acetaminophen altogether
In context ↗ - aspirin · Worse
it seems to be different to and last longer than the side effects of aspirin
In context ↗ - sustained release melatonin · Worse
this time within 30min I became so groggy I had to go to bed early
In context ↗ - coconut oil · Worse
shortly afterwards I felt more ill and then I developed a headache
In context ↗ - avoiding TV and PC in the evening · No change
Avoiding TV and PC in the evening doesn't help much either.
In context ↗ - exercise and GET · Worse
I have tried different approaches to exercise and GET but all failed no matter how careful I was
In context ↗ - low levels of resistance training · Worse
PEM and PENE occurred anyway despite this adaptation to DOMS
In context ↗ - folinic acid · Helped
if anything the folinic acid may now be helping further
In context ↗ - selenomethionine · Worse
I started taking 150mcg selenomethionine once per morning and after a few days I started feeling worse.
In context ↗ - nattokinase · Not said
I once tried a dose of the former and coincidently noticed a similar sensation in the sinuses that I get from aspirin.
In context ↗ - upping protein intake · Helped
it doesn't seem as bad in recent times, since upping protein intake (but not too much)?
In context ↗ - increase in carbohydrate-rich foods while greatly lowering fat intake · Helped
What helped was an increase in carbohydrate-rich foods while greatly lowering fat intake, and to a lesser extent, less protein intake.
In context ↗ - removing the PC from the bedroom · No change
Someone suggested to me once that having the PC in my bedroom was probably affecting my sleep. But removing it did not have any effect.
In context ↗ - "power of the mind" · No change
At first it was empowering and gave me much needed hope, but this lead to a series of humiliating reality checks
In context ↗ - acceptance and pacing · Not said
I am accepting, dealing, making do. These are not giving in, but working within limitations
In context ↗ - acceptance · Not said
I think there is CFS research which demonstrates unsurprisingly that a lack of acceptance is actually detrimental to outcomes.
In context ↗ - vitamin E · Worse
Vitamin E: unusual nausea and weird "scratchy" headache.
In context ↗ - vitamin C · Worse
Vitamin C: dull headache.
In context ↗ - juiced carrots · Worse
the last 2 times I had juiced carrots to drink I got a bad headache
In context ↗ - potassium · Worse
Some people swear by potassium to handle effects of methylfolate, but I suspect I have the opposite reaction with potassium.
In context ↗ - supplement protocol after seeing a orthomolecular doctor · Not said
Then I was on some supplement protocol after seeing a orthomolecular doctor
In context ↗ - Methylation support (unspecified) · Not said
I recently started the methylation protocol again and suddenly 4 mouth ulcers broke out over 24 hours
In context ↗ - Everyday exercise and activity · Worse
My approach to exercise was too intense at first and I paid the price.
In context ↗
Their path
They say too little about how ill they were at each step to draw it on the severity scale, so the steps are listed as they describe them.
| When | What happened | Where they were | After |
|---|---|---|---|
| onset | CFS onset; stiff neck and hamstringsAt onset my neck and hamstrings became stiff and inflexibleIn context ↗ | Not stated | |
| a few years before 2011 | Brief improvement during IV EDTA chelationthen it started helping for a few weeks and I thought I was on the road to recoveryIn context ↗ | Not stated | Chelation and heavy metal detox |
| a few years before 2011 | IV EDTA later made symptoms significantly worsethen later it made me significantly worse along with a bunch of strange symptomsIn context ↗ | Not stated | |
| after the SAMe incident | Digestion worsened and cachexia after supplement reactionsI lost even more weight and became clinically and medically cachexic but since then I did eventually regain most of all the above mentioned weight back.In context ↗ | Moderate | |
| 2011-07-19 | Methylation protocol seemed to improve toleranceWhatever I'm doing at present seems better than beforeIn context ↗ | Not stated | Methylation support (unspecified) |
| 2014-01-16 | Selenium made symptoms worse during a relapseafter a few days I started feeling worseIn context ↗ | Not stated | |
| 2014-09-26 | Still ill; GET and exercise approaches failedcareful approaches ie GET didn't help either and just delayed the inevitable failure and consequencesIn context ↗ | Not stated |
Adverse events
- Chelation and heavy metal detox“it made me significantly worse along with a bunch of strange symptoms and my digestion became sluggish and I lost more weight.” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Omega-3 and fish oil“EPA made me feel more irritable and more flu-like when I tried it.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Methylfolate (L-methylfolate, 5-MTHF)“I couldn't tolerate a higher dosage of FolaPro as that seemed responsible for most side-effects” In context ↗ Side effects
- Juicing and smoothies“the last 2 times I had juiced carrots to drink I got a bad headache.” In context ↗ Side effects
- SAMe (S-adenosylmethionine)“SAM-e: horrible bilious and strong malaise feeling all over, especially in the liver area, tingling in right arm.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Vitamin E (tocopherol, tocotrienols)“Vitamin E: unusual nausea and weird "scratchy" headache.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Vitamin C“Vitamin C: dull headache.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Molybdenum“aftewards that I found it difficult to tolerate the molybdenum and eventually gave it up” In context ↗ Side effects
- SAMe (S-adenosylmethionine)“After the SAMe incident my digestion worsened and it was difficult to tolerate food, especially fat, so I lost even more weight” In context ↗ Gut side effects
- Milk thistle (silymarin)“I also had issues with items such as milk thistle and MSM (headachy so-called "detox" symptoms).” In context ↗ Side effects
- MSM (methylsulfonylmethane)“I also had issues with items such as milk thistle and MSM (headachy so-called "detox" symptoms).” In context ↗ Side effects
- Folinic acid (leucovorin)“At first the folinic acid seemed to cause a similar and additive response as FolaPro but less harsh.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Probiotics and fermented foods“when I tried VSL#3, at some stage into the trial it seemed to significantly worsen this symptom about an hour or so after taking it” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Paracetamol / acetaminophen (Tylenol, Panadol)“this year I had a few negative experiences which make me want to avoid paracetamol/acetaminophen altogether.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Vitamin B12“Again, I soon developed another ulcer or equivalent lesion in the location where the drops land under the tongue” In context ↗ Side effects
- Melatonin“it made my dreams negative in tone and I remained really groggy the next day and felt worse” In context ↗ Side effects
- Coconut oil“shortly afterwards I felt more ill and then I developed a headache.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Graded exercise therapy (GET)“I have tried different approaches to exercise and GET but all failed no matter how careful I was” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Strength training“PEM and PENE occurred anyway despite this adaptation to DOMS, and in direct proportion to the workload” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- “Sometimes I'm guilty of crashing because of too much writing for this forum!” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Nattokinase“I once tried a dose of the former and coincidently noticed a similar unpleasant sensation in the sinuses that I get from aspirin.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Zinc“I often react adversely to zinc supplements with headache and flu-like aching” In context ↗ Side effects
- Methylation support (unspecified)“I recently started the methylation protocol again and suddenly 4 mouth ulcers broke out over 24 hours” In context ↗ Side effects
- Meditation, yoga, breathwork“meditation etc had much less benefit and more adverse effects.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Vitamin B12“I found that methyl-B12 (Jarrow) may have a mild stimulant effect.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Vitamin D and sun exposure“probably because I was reacting to the vitamin D itself (makes me feel sleep deprived).” In context ↗ Side effects
- Selenium“after a few days I started feeling worse.” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Everyday exercise and activity“My approach to exercise was too intense at first and I paid the price.” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
Symptoms mentioned
Brain fogFlu-like symptomsGut problemsHeadaches & migraineHeart symptoms & palpitationsMast cell (MCAS) & allergiesNeuropathy & tinglingPOTS & dysautonomiaPain & fibromyalgiaPost-exertional malaiseSleep problemsTemperature regulationVision problems
Their words about their symptoms
- Post-exertional malaise
post-exertional symptoms have become much worse
In context ↗ - Brain fog
increased cognitive impairment and accompanying flu-like brain fog malaise
In context ↗ - POTS & dysautonomia
Preliminary evidence suggests that I have POTS
In context ↗ - Mast cell (MCAS) & allergies
I became more sensitive to cigarette smoke and perfumes
In context ↗ - Sleep problems
It takes me a while to fall asleep and I wake up often.
In context ↗ - Pain & fibromyalgia
constant lactic-acid like burning in my muscles
In context ↗ - Headaches & migraine
migraine-like headpain
In context ↗ - Gut problems
my digestion became sluggish
In context ↗ - Heart symptoms & palpitations
heart pounding sensation/sound in my head
In context ↗ - Neuropathy & tingling
partial numbness/tingling or coldness in the extremities
In context ↗ - Flu-like symptoms
flu-like aching and sub-fever sensations
In context ↗ - Temperature regulation
cold intolerance, cold extremities
In context ↗ - Vision problems
visual disturbances
In context ↗