Miruvor
Sign up

Protein shakes and powder

How it went for everyone who tried it

Helped means they said it helped with what they took it for, which may be one symptom and not the illness.

71%
helped
181 of 254
11%
no change
27 of 254
18%
got worse
46 of 254

Shares are out of the 254 people who said how it went. 104 more tried it without saying how it went overall; 9 of them describe a problem.

How it wentPeopleShare
Helped a lot114%
Helped17067%
No change2711%
Worse4216%
Much worse42%
Where it was reportedHelpedSaid how it went
Reddit145184
Recovery stories3670

Did it last, for everyone it helped?

  • It wore off for 4 of the 181 people it helped: 1 who credits it for their improvement, 3 who don’t.

Ask about this treatment

Among the 83 who credit it with their improvement, here’s how they are now

Credit it means they say it’s one reason they got better: 16 say it helped them most; 67 say it was one of several things that helped.

19%
recovered or near normal
16 of 83
63%
much or somewhat better
52 of 83
17%
relapsed
14 of 83
1%
no benefit
1 of 83

Where each person was at the end of their story, or in their latest post that says how they are, compared with their worst point.

Outcome describedPeopleShare
Recovered45%
Near normal1214%
Much better2834%
Somewhat better2429%
Relapsed1417%
No benefit11%

Did it last?

  • 1 of the 83 who credit it said its benefit wore off; that person is among the 14 who relapsed.
  • 49 of the 83 who credit it say they still need to keep doing something (not always this) to stay well.

By how ill people were

Only the 83 who credit it, so people it didn’t help or made worse aren’t here. How they are now is their outcome overall, not the effect of this one treatment.

Severity at worstHow they are nownRecovered or near normal
Mild1250%
Moderate2421%
Severe3711%
Very severe40%, few people
Not stated617%, few people
At worstOutcomePeopleShare
MildNear normal6 of 1250%
MildMuch better1 of 128%
MildSomewhat better4 of 1234%
MildRelapsed1 of 128%
ModerateNear normal5 of 2421%
ModerateMuch better6 of 2425%
ModerateSomewhat better8 of 2433%
ModerateRelapsed4 of 2417%
ModerateNo benefit1 of 244%
SevereRecovered3 of 378%
SevereNear normal1 of 373%
SevereMuch better19 of 3751%
SevereSomewhat better6 of 3716%
SevereRelapsed8 of 3722%
Very severeMuch better2 of 450%
Very severeSomewhat better2 of 450%
Not statedRecovered1 of 617%
Not statedSomewhat better4 of 667%
Not statedRelapsed1 of 616%

Adverse events

What people said went wrong, in their own words.

56 of 358

people who wrote about taking it described a problem they tied to it

Described one · 56Didn’t mention one · 302

The serious kinds

Worth telling a doctor about straight away.

  • Made them much worse

    4 people
    “for me back when I could tolerate protein shake, It did gave me terrible episodes of fatigue, pretty much like PEM”
    — Serg1942
    “I had a serious allergic reaction to something in it and had to go to the ER”
    — bspg
    Show 2 moreShow fewer
    “I was bedridden for the day ... I have no doubt this protein shake has something in it that is extremely impairing.”
    — roxie60
    “I drank it for four days and my IBS started to flare.”
    — TCP36
  • Mood or psychiatric effects

    3 people
    “drink protein shakes which seem to cause me to have panic attacks.”
    — Beech 98233
    “One that sticks out to me is glutamine. It makes me feel ragey for some reason.”
    — Maple 33733
    Show 1 moreShow fewer
    “I started to feel manic and like I had a motor inside me that I couldn't switch off.”
    — Stone 36522
  • Allergic reaction / anaphylaxis

    2 people
    “after drinking a new protein shake mix ... I was covered in hives all over my body and I immediately panicked.”
    — bspg
    “now I'm itchy as hell and rashy. It's in the bin.”
    — Skycloud
  • Liver or kidney problems

    2 people
    “drinking protein shakes has taken a toll on my kidney function.”
    — Shore 21768
    “My recent lab work has liver toxicity so I just stopped. ... the shakes are the only culprit.”
    — Quail 70077

The serious kinds are a death, suicidal thoughts or an attempt, a hospital stay, an ER visit, an allergic reaction or anaphylaxis, heart rhythm, liver or kidney, blood count, mood or psychiatric, or refeeding or deficiency problems, and being made much worse: a large worsening such as a crash lasting weeks or more. 1 of those made much worse says only that, without a specific adverse event, so is not in the 56 above.

Other kinds

Unpleasant effects people tied to it, the most serious first.

Made symptoms worse · 17Autoimmune or inflammatory flare · 1Gut side effects · 16Nerve pain · 2Herx / die-off reaction · 1Side effects · 13Other · 1 Show all 7Hide
  • Made symptoms worse

    17 people
    “I tried a protein powder once and felt worse.”
    — wabi-sabi
    “When I took a protein with 5 mg, it made me really bad.”
    — Prairie 26571
    Show 15 moreShow fewer
    “I tried a protein shake with powder from the supermarket but just kept feeling really bad after it”
    — Oak 86946
    “Protein powders were making this problem way worse”
    — Omgitsremy89
    “I came off it as it was making me too wired, and straight away went into a severe week-long PEM episode.”
    — Stone 36522
    “protein powder gave me a boost for a day or two, but then made me worst.”
    — ZeroGravitas
    “for me back when I could tolerate protein shake, It did gave me terrible episodes of fatigue, pretty much like PEM”
    — Serg1942
    “same used to happen with me so i stopped taking protein powder completely”
    — Cedar 25479
    “In the past I had horrible symptoms with protein drinks based on dairy. Last week I tried one based on pea protein and found it gentle and satisfying.”
    — Mel9
    “If I start using Vega pea-protein shakes (or rice, or hemp) I'll be sick within three days and doing poorly.”
    — Runner5
    “I became sick 7 years ago after drinking every 2 hours a shake made of canola oil,honey,olive oil,peanut butter,protein powders.”
    — Carribeanboy
    “I tried protein drinks too, but they made me feel worse.”
    — antherder
    “protein powder (it sometimes made me feel very tired 1-2 years ago)”
    — ZudZud
    “If I take protein powder, brain fog is extensive.”
    — Naibaf
    “I had to stop taking protein powder because it contains too much free glutamate.”
    — xjhuez
    “tried rice protein and l-glutamine individually ... a return of neurological symptoms”
    — velha508
    “I tried protein shakes and they weren't any better ... they still were absorbed too fast and triggered an insulin overeaction”
    — river
  • Autoimmune or inflammatory flare

    1 person
    “They all cause severe EoE flares.”
    — hixxy
  • Gut side effects

    16 people
    “protein shakes mess with my guts and GI symptoms.”
    — Tundra 22611
    “I switched to it when pea protein left me digestively challenged for a period of time.”
    — Summit 88399
    Show 14 moreShow fewer
    “For me the Pea and Soya set my bowels into a painful spin, as did Whey.”
    — BrightCandle
    “the pea protein from Lambards upset my stomach”
    — Brenda
    “I tried different types and brands of proteins shakes but all of them upset my stomach, or give me nausea or general GI malaise”
    — Crocus 22672
    “an hour later I was doubled over.”
    — EddieB
    “sometimes it sets off my stomach”
    — Bluebell 54584
    “protein powder goes really bad on me.”
    — Puffin 26671
    “I puke on protein shake now. Maybe a month ago this works but not now.”
    — Plover 33319
    “The protein powders gave me deadly gas due to my stomach being jacked up by LC.”
    — Prairie 50027
    “protein shakes (which I already have but give me diarrhea and upset my belly”
    — Birch 18566
    “I ended up trying to drink some of a protein shake. Bad idea. It made my stomach hurt pretty bad. Not even nauseous, just .. hurt. And I felt really bloated.”
    — Eagle 92060
    “I've tried a lot of supplementing with shakes before while I adjusted to dysphagia but they without fail give me nasty, nasty diarrhoea”
    — Lynx 45388
    “They still make me super nauseous like all food seems to”
    — Pelican 61100
    “have to be careful with these as the whey protein can trigger my IBS”
    — Tulip 57559
    “I drank it for four days and my IBS started to flare.”
    — TCP36
  • Nerve pain

    2 people
    “No night sweats but I'm pretty sure it's giving me nerve pain down the backs of my legs and a bit in the back of my head.”
    — TreePerson
    “I am now suffering from severe nerve pain all over and my gut and back are very uncomfortable.”
    — TCP36
  • Herx / die-off reaction

    1 person
    “UN-denatured protein powder, even at very low doses, gives me significant detox/die-off symptoms.”
    — ljimbo423
  • Side effects

    13 people
    “I tried Alani but I get a reaction to it”
    — Stone 26828
    “I cut out protein drinks a month or 2 ago bc they always gave me symptoms. Bloating, tachycardia, feeling faint, adrenaline, especially if I had to used the bathroom after.”
    — Flint 93806
    Show 11 moreShow fewer
    “I got sick in October from some type of candida overgrowth from my protein powder and I got a skin rash, sore throat , headaches”
    — Moon 81360
    “I always got horribly bad red eyes from protein powders and never from real food.”
    — Lolinda
    “I’ve tried in the past protein shakes but I just couldn’t tolerate it.”
    — Flint 40468
    “I stopped taking this all completely due to joint pain / depression / tiredness / appetite craving.”
    — JinZ
    “I found that caused me least issues (I had the same when I went with other random powders).”
    — Vale 74096
    “protein powders triggering migraines”
    — xebex
    “Even supplementing with pea protein gives me brain fog and a bizarre “out of it” feeling”
    — GreenMachineX
    “I bought some plant based powder & couldn't tolerate it.”
    — Dove 51564
    “I took one the other day thinking aminos are good. But I had terrible muscular pain in my chest.”
    — seamyb
    “I can't tolerate egg white protein powder at all - so it's a definite problem with me!”
    — Mogwai
    “I bought pea protein powder today. Took 25g and had reactions after an hour...”
    — optimist
  • Other

    1 person
    “the two doses of whey protein I tried, I think, possibly almost killed me”
    — mindgonemad

How often it comes up

Posts that mention Protein shakes and powder, per 1,000 posts each month. Hover or tap a point for the count.

05201020142017202020232026
MonthPosts mentioning itAll postsPer 1,000
Oct 200911059.5
Jan 201001410
Feb 201011138.8
Jun 201101090
Nov 201101240
Dec 201101990
Jan 201202320
Feb 201201030
Mar 201201900
Apr 201201620
May 201203750
Jun 201202380
Jul 201202400
Aug 201204850
Sep 201205610
Oct 201205260
Nov 201205140
Dec 201216991.4
Jan 201335335.6
Feb 201304470
Mar 201304290
Apr 201304990
May 201306060
Jun 201306090
Jul 201306160
Aug 201305770
Sep 201303640
Oct 201325363.7
Nov 201323855.2
Dec 201305190
Jan 201409440
Feb 201408210
Mar 201414252.4
Apr 201403610
May 201406170
Jun 201404890
Jul 201404440
Aug 201406220
Sep 201405070
Oct 201416781.5
Nov 201415671.8
Dec 201406290
Jan 201537603.9
Feb 201508730
Mar 201501,2760
Apr 201519841.0
May 201521,4961.3
Jun 201531,0462.9
Jul 201511,2110.83
Aug 201509980
Sep 201511,0600.94
Oct 201501,2550
Nov 201511,2460.80
Dec 201509240
Jan 201601,2820
Feb 201621,0511.9
Mar 201601,0020
Apr 201639983.0
May 201611,0450.96
Jun 201601,2300
Jul 201611,6190.62
Aug 201601,7290
Sep 201601,7850
Oct 201611,2200.82
Nov 201611,0920.92
Dec 201601,2110
Jan 201731,6601.8
Feb 201711,9880.50
Mar 201712,0780.48
Apr 201722,1330.94
May 201732,3701.3
Jun 201722,1940.91
Jul 201702,1830
Aug 201722,4660.81
Sep 201732,1891.4
Oct 201713,0420.33
Nov 201731,9761.5
Dec 201722,1120.95
Jan 201822,6200.76
Feb 201822,1550.93
Mar 201832,6131.1
Apr 201822,2510.89
May 201842,8281.4
Jun 201843,8711.0
Jul 201833,0670.98
Aug 201853,7571.3
Sep 201833,5120.85
Oct 201823,2610.61
Nov 201812,8610.35
Dec 201822,7540.73
Jan 201943,6721.1
Feb 201912,7150.37
Mar 201973,3172.1
Apr 201923,1410.64
May 201923,8550.52
Jun 201923,3920.59
Jul 201953,3121.5
Aug 201973,9431.8
Sep 2019104,0352.5
Oct 201963,9221.5
Nov 201933,5080.86
Dec 201943,6591.1
Jan 202064,6501.3
Feb 202014,3740.23
Mar 2020104,4752.2
Apr 202033,6900.81
May 202014,5430.22
Jun 202045,7010.70
Jul 202036,1040.49
Aug 2020510,3330.48
Sep 2020811,9580.67
Oct 2020814,5680.55
Nov 2020916,5460.54
Dec 20202120,7641.0
Jan 20211824,5620.73
Feb 2021824,6720.32
Mar 2021729,4760.24
Apr 20211028,5090.35
May 20211825,7910.70
Jun 20211427,8710.50
Jul 20211327,2200.48
Aug 20211030,8080.32
Sep 20211930,0740.63
Oct 20211422,1320.63
Nov 20211327,7220.47
Dec 20212631,8720.82
Jan 20222742,3170.64
Feb 20222538,6970.65
Mar 20222944,3050.65
Apr 20224144,3330.92
May 20223650,5940.71
Jun 20222849,0580.57
Jul 20222553,4850.47
Aug 20222054,4550.37
Sep 20223656,9360.63
Oct 20224358,5110.73
Nov 20226859,1981.1
Dec 20225161,5760.83
Jan 20233361,0040.54
Feb 20232550,1330.50
Mar 20233659,9250.60
Apr 20234954,2510.90
May 20233557,7680.61
Jun 20232252,6790.42
Jul 20232956,4010.51
Aug 20233465,4350.52
Sep 20234561,8350.73
Oct 20236258,4191.1
Nov 20237053,6621.3
Dec 20235960,6430.97
Jan 20244471,8180.61
Feb 20244770,0450.67
Mar 20245868,2610.85
Apr 20245264,3740.81
May 20246467,6980.95
Jun 20246264,7200.96
Jul 202410165,3351.5
Aug 202412868,5171.9
Sep 202411670,1681.7
Oct 20247772,6071.1
Nov 202410171,8021.4
Dec 202410074,4011.3
Jan 20258777,9091.1
Feb 20253965,1100.60
Mar 202512269,9051.7
Apr 20258661,6061.4
May 20255465,7330.82
Jun 20257860,5401.3
Jul 20256962,1051.1
Aug 20256664,5781.0
Sep 20256061,7040.97
Oct 20254659,2040.78
Nov 20255058,9440.85
Dec 20255762,8300.91
Jan 20269363,3211.5
Feb 20264753,0850.89
Mar 20266759,2081.1
Apr 20264053,9890.74
May 20263657,5410.63
Jun 20264155,3010.74
Jul 20266456,3911.1
Aug 20267156,8251.2
Sep 20267457,1431.3

Forum and Reddit posts, 4,007,898 in all, counted per month. A mention means the post names the treatment, not that the writer took it. All trends

20 of the 358 people who tried it

See all 358 stories
  • Mostly bedbound with long COVID, now housebound and somewhat better with rest and pacing

    Somewhat better Pebble 18897 Long COVID Severe at worstIll 3 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Pebble 18897, a former MMA athlete, developed CFS-type long COVID after a mild omicron infection in 2023 and was mostly bedbound early on. Lexapro 10 mg cleared his anxiety and panic but not his physical symptoms; radical rest and pacing helped. He took part…

  • Moderate ME/CFS with weight loss and bloating, somewhat better after rifaximin and LDN

    Somewhat better Glade 58762 ME/CFS Moderate at worst reddit.com Oct 2026

    Glade 58762 had mild ME/CFS until gastritis, SIBO and a move dropped them to moderate, with 30 lb weight loss and months of bloating and indigestion. A breath test found hydrogen SIBO; rifaximin, a low-FODMAP diet and digestive enzymes helped them eat and…

  • Long COVID at 60% with brain fog, joint pain and anhedonia, briefly better then worse again

    Relapsed Lynx 28818 Long COVID Mild at worst reddit.com Oct 2026

    UK software engineer with mild long COVID from late 2020, at about 95% before a first vaccine dose restored them for two weeks; a likely delta infection in July 2021 then took them to 60% with brain fog, joint pain and anhedonia. Later doses did not help.…

  • Bedbound up to 16 hours a day with long COVID, now much better with pacing and diet

    Much better Mesa 11607 Long COVID Severe at worstIll 3 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    A UK person fell ill with long COVID after a COVID infection in November 2023 and became bedbound up to 16 hours a day for months after quitting smoking. Radical rest and pacing, a low-carb Mediterranean diet with meat reintroduced, fluoxetine and medical…

  • Bedbound with ME/CFS, improved on valaciclovir then relapsed after returning to work

    Relapsed Crocus 33227 ME/CFS Severe at worst reddit.com Oct 2026

    Crocus 33227 was bedbound and using a wheelchair at 24, with ME/CFS that they had pushed through for years. Antivirals (valaciclovir) were the most effective treatment they tried, alongside supplements for mitochondrial support, treatment for Lyme and…

  • Long COVID with extreme fatigue and brain fog, still resting at home with no improvement

    No benefit Doesn’t credit it · Not saidGlacier 79635 Long COVID Severe at worstIll for 3.5 years reddit.com Oct 2026

    A former state education administrator fell ill with long COVID after a COVID infection in March 2023, with extreme fatigue, long sleep hours, brain fog, joint pain and dysautonomia; they are still seeking an ME/CFS diagnosis. They stopped working in…

  • Bedridden with long COVID for three years, now nearly back to normal with time and pacing

    Near normal Doesn’t credit it · Not saidKite 59994 Long COVID Severe at worstIll 3 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Caught COVID in December 2019, before lockdown, and was mostly bedridden for three years as symptoms worsened. From year three she improved slowly, crediting time, rest, pacing, a gradual walking programme, daily antihistamines and gabapentin. A 2023…

  • wabi-sabi on Phoenix Rising

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · Worse ME/CFS Very severe at worstIll 8.5 years before improving forums.phoenixrising.me Oct 2026

    wabi-sabi fell ill after a viral infection in May 2014, stayed mild until an exercise crash in 2018 made her moderate, and declined to very severe by 2022. Mestinon and later mast cell drugs (cromolyn, ketotifen, xolair, LDN) improved her; a COVID infection…

  • Long COVID with panic attacks, air hunger and POTS, now much better with MSM and thiamine

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · HelpedHeron 68024 Long COVID Moderate at worstIll 4 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Fell ill in early 2023 after influenza and had roughly four years of long COVID: panic attacks, air hunger, POTS, twitching and brain fog. Without medication or supplements they pushed through crashes and improved to about 75% by late 2025, later tolerating…

  • Bedridden with ME/CFS, now somewhat better; beta blockers and electrolytes helped POTS

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · WorseTundra 22611 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 18 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Tundra 22611 had mild ME/CFS from their early teens, becoming more severe after a presumed COVID infection around lockdown and a first Pfizer dose in May 2021 that left them bedridden. Beta blockers and electrolytes helped their POTS, and they could do some…

  • Severe ME/CFS, mostly in bed, no lasting benefit from B-cell depletion or Pemgarda

    No benefit Doesn’t credit it · Not saidBeech 40768 ME/CFS Severe at worst reddit.com Oct 2026

    Beech 40768 was mild, working and walking 10,000 steps a day, until a Mexico beach trip in March 2024 left them moderate, off work and mostly housebound, later severe and mostly in bed. Three years of B-cell depletion, SS-31, Pemgarda, stellate ganglion…

  • Long COVID fatigue and crashes lifted twice then returned, L-citrulline helped partly

    Relapsed Doesn’t credit it · WorsePrairie 26571 Long COVID Mild at worstIll 4 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    A Reddit user who developed long COVID in August 2022 after a COVID-19 infection, with recurring phases of fatigue, low HRV, raised resting heart rate and post-exertional crashes. Twice the symptoms lifted for three to four months before returning. By 2026…

  • Severe ME/CFS now mild but still lapsing, much better with pacing and creatine

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · Not saidBeacon 59982 ME/CFS Severe at worst reddit.com Oct 2026

    An ME/CFS patient who came from severe to moderate to mild, though they still lapse back into moderate and need to lie down during work hours. They credited no single treatment: a second-hand Garmin with pacing apps and a Fitbit for heart-rate comparisons…

  • Bedbound with long COVID and unable to work, now somewhat better after pacing and diet

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · No changeCoast 93625 Long COVID Severe at worstIll 4 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Coast 93625, a nurse, got long COVID with POTS after COVID in July 2022, then after a reinfection in October 2023 developed ME/CFS and worsened, was bedbound from February to April 2024 and unable to work. Pacing, L-carnitine, taurine, ivabradine, stimulants…

  • Mostly housebound with ME/CFS, now somewhat better with metformin and oxaloacetate

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · HelpedVale 52159 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 18 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    EBV at 18 left her mildly ill for years; she became moderate-severe at 28, and a graded exercise programme later crashed her to mostly housebound/sometimes bedbound for about 3 years. Metformin from April 2023 took her from housebound and 16 hours a day in…

  • Long COVID crash left them largely immobile; much better with rest and diet changes

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · Not saidBeech 98233 Long COVID Very severe at worstIll 6.5 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Someone infected in February 2020 developed long COVID within weeks and had a severe crash around January 2021 that left them largely immobile for about a month, with paralysis, a week of blindness and psychosis. They credit rest and dietary changes—mainly a…

  • Mostly in bed with ME/CFS, improved, then relapsed; now barely leaves house

    Relapsed Doesn’t credit it · HelpedValley 95687 ME/CFS Moderate at worst reddit.com Oct 2026

    After falling ill with ME/CFS, Valley 95687 spent about six months resting, mostly in bed but walking the dog for an hour a day. Their limits then improved so much that symptoms were almost nonexistent, though they were still sick. Travel and overwork pushed…

  • Mild/moderate ME/CFS with bad crashes, now somewhat better

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · WorseOak 86946 ME/CFS Moderate at worstIll 4 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Dutch teenager Oak 86946 got COVID-19 at 13 on her birthday around August 2022 and later got a confirmed ME/CFS diagnosis; CBT/GET treatment had made her worse. Mild/moderate but with bad crashes, she used pacing, rest, a wheelchair for longer outings,…

  • Bedbound with ME/CFS in a dark room, now moderate-severe with strict pacing and rest

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · WorseValley 89773 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 10 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    A midwife in Australia, she became very severe after a tick bite and was bedbound in a dark room by 2021. A live-in carer plus strict pacing and aggressive rest lifted her to moderate-severe: sitting up most days, a rollator indoors, a wheelchair out. She…

  • Mostly bedbound with ME/CFS, some improvement in chest pain with nattokinase, still disabled

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · No changeMoon 52940 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 4.5 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Moon 52940 caught COVID in March 2020 and developed long COVID in June 2020, with POTS, brain fog, neuropathy and later ME/CFS after their second vaccine dose and physical therapy in 2021. They were mostly bedbound in late 2022 after a two-day CPET and a…

These are the newest 5 of the 83 who credit Protein shakes and powder for their improvement, then the newest 15 of the 275 who tried it without crediting it, in about the same proportion as the full list.

A little hope, every Sunday

New recovery stories and data-driven research on ME/CFS and long COVID. Ideas worth considering, and the evidence behind them.

Free · Unsubscribe anytime