SherDa on Phoenix Rising
- Condition
- Condition not stated
- At worst
- Moderate (mostly housebound)
- Ill before improving or writing
- Not stated
- Last post
- Dec 2019
In their words
- At worst: Moderate
Taking a 1 or 2 g of choline (and/or lecithin) and acetyl-L-carnitine makes me feel more normal than I have in years.
In context ↗ - Now: Near normal
Calcium (along with zinc) has improved my brain fog so much that I'm now working full-time and have gone back to college three-quarters time.
In context ↗
The story comes from their 32 posts in 16 threads
Summary
SherDa, ill for years with gut dysmotility, brain fog, fatigue and muscle spasms, put much of it down to low acetylcholine and later calcium. Choline, acetyl-l-carnitine and electrolytes helped, but calcium was the supplement she could not function without; with it she returned to full-time work and part-time college. She still had to manage supplements daily, and high-dose vitamin A left her with severe fatigue, insomnia and brain fog.
Ask Miruvor AI
What they tried
What they credit
Also tried
Their words about each treatment
- Calcium · Helped a lot
Calcium is the #1 supplement I could not function without.
In context ↗ - Zinc · Helped
I'm responding really well to zinc + 5HTP
In context ↗ - 5-HTP · Helped
I started taking serotonin-supportive supplements yesterday and they have made a pretty remarkable change in how I feel.
In context ↗ - Choline · Helped a lot
Taking a 1 or 2 g of choline (and/or lecithin) and acetyl-L-carnitine makes me feel more normal than I have in years.
In context ↗ - alpha GPC · Helped
Choline source (either plain choline or alpha GPC or sunflower lecithin, all seem to work)
In context ↗ - manganese · Helped
Sometimes, choline and ALCar won't work by themselves and I have to add in manganese, B1 and B5
In context ↗ - thiamine (Solgar 500 mg) · Helped
Thiamine (I like the Solgar 500 mg (super potency)
In context ↗ - B5 · Helped
I have to add in manganese, B1 and B5
In context ↗ - electrolytes · Helped
Just taking the acetylcholine supplements helped me for a good long while but eventually I needed to manage electrolytes too.
In context ↗ - magnesium · No change
Yes, I get no relief from magnesium.
In context ↗ - potassium · Not said
For potassium taste test, I use Now potassium chloride powder.
In context ↗ - tyrosine · Not said
despite extensive support (tyrosine, vitamin A, vitamin D, vitamin C, manganese, selenium, iron, B12, iodine, zinc)
In context ↗ - vitamin A · Helped
When my teeth occasionally get sensitive, vitamin A helps within 24 hours.
In context ↗ - vitamin D · Worse
I've had 3 molars break while taking high-dose vitamin D on 3 separate instances.
In context ↗ - iron · Helped
Improving iron metabolism proved way more beneficial to me than trying to troubleshoot methyl trapping.
In context ↗ - vitamin B12 · Not said
I haven't retried bupropion with adequate B6, methylfolate and methyl B12.
In context ↗ - antidepressants · Helped
I've been through this in the past, an initial good response to antidepressants followed by loss of efficacy.
In context ↗ - vitamin K2 / powdered natto · Helped
My hypermobile shoulder and hip pain was noticeably better within a few days of starting to eat powdered natto.
In context ↗ - lifting weights · Not said
I do lift weights when I can
In context ↗ - copper · Helped
copper would make it go away very quickly
In context ↗ - prebiotic fibers · Worse
Before when I attempted to use prebiotic fibers, I would end up horribly distended with a lot of gut pain.
In context ↗ - probiotics · Not said
Now I can tolerate high amounts of pro- and prebiotics.
In context ↗ - P5P / vitamin B6 · Helped
At first, I controlled it by using sublingual P5P at night, but that quit working.
In context ↗ - biotin · Worse
I've been struggling with low calcium the past couple days triggered by high dose biotin
In context ↗ - antihistamines · Worse
Antihistamines make me a complete zombie.
In context ↗ - lysine · Helped
Lysine and cysteine both make me feel better, but it's short-lived.
In context ↗ - cysteine · Worse
Cysteine (and other sulfur supplements like glucosamine sulfate) depletes my copper pretty quickly, which is manifests as anemia and boils in less than 2 weeks
In context ↗ - glucosamine sulfate · Worse
Cysteine (and other sulfur supplements like glucosamine sulfate) depletes my copper pretty quickly
In context ↗ - NAC · Helped
Glutamine and NAC actually helped for 2-3 weeks before the effect faded.
In context ↗ - leucine · Helped
Leucine did give me a great energy boost the 1st time I took it, but not since then.
In context ↗ - threonine · Helped
The same with threonine.
In context ↗ - BCAAs · No change
I just personally don't notice a benefit from BCAA-only supplements.
In context ↗ - essential amino acids · Not said
I have all of the essential amino acids separately so I could experiment with them individually.
In context ↗ - B2 · Not said
Other items that affect iron availability and may potentially help include B2, B6, B9, and B12.
In context ↗ - folate / methylfolate · Helped
I respond very well to folate and will continue to take it as I see fit.
In context ↗ - beef liver pills · Not said
I started taking beef liver pills in November, and within a couple days, the gums in the back of my mouth on the upper left started to get sore.
In context ↗ - strict paleo diet · Helped
when I've been eating a strict paleo diet (no grains/sugar/dairy), that is the only time my teeth feel so clean I could forget to brush.
In context ↗ - collagen · No change
I used to be able to effectively treat spider veins with collagen supplements, but now, they do not improve.
In context ↗ - bupropion · Helped
I had a really great response to bupropion for 2 weeks. Then, it abruptly stopped working, and I felt dreadful.
In context ↗
Approaches: Amino acids and carnitine · Supplements
Their path
What they say at each step doesn’t fit the worst point or outcome above on the severity scale, so the steps are listed as they describe them.
| When | What happened | After |
|---|---|---|
| onset | became ill while an athleteI was using BCAAs daily when I got sickIn context ↗ | |
| 2016-02-21 | choline and acetyl-L-carnitine made her feel more normalTaking a 1 or 2 g of choline (and/or lecithin) and acetyl-L-carnitine makes me feel more normal than I have in years.In context ↗ | Choline |
| 2016-11-07 | serotonin-supportive supplements lifted gut, temperature and sleep symptomsI started taking serotonin-supportive supplements yesterday and they have made a pretty remarkable change in how I feel.In context ↗ | 5-HTP |
| 2018-02-06 | calcium cleared brain fog and energy enough for work and collegeCalcium (along with zinc) has improved my brain fog so much that I'm now working full-time and have gone back to college three-quarters time.In context ↗ | Calcium |
| 2019-01-19 | declined after several days of high-dose vitamin AI rapidly declined with severe fatigue, insomnia and brain fog after that.In context ↗ | |
| 2019-12-08 | still managing symptoms with supplements, responding well to folateI respond very well to folate and will continue to take it as I see fit.In context ↗ |
Adverse events
- “I would take them, they would work well for a few hours and then I would be right back to having low ACh symptoms that were sometimes even worse than before.” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Vitamin K and K2“It gives me an incredible amount of energy (that feels like good energy, not wired) but it makes me unable to sleep.” In context ↗ Insomnia from treatment
- Vitamin K and K2“My neck and shoulder muscles get very tense after a few days on it, and my digestion freezes up causing neurological symptoms mainly at night (tinnitus, jaw tremor, distal extremity numbness and tingling).” In context ↗ Side effects
- Vitamin K and K2“I get muscle spasms (sometimes quite severe) from K2. They are relieved by taking calcium. Other low calcium symptoms can include palpitations, fatigue, insomnia, pins and needles feelings in the extremities.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Vitamin D and sun exposure“I've had 3 molars break while taking high-dose vitamin D on 3 separate instances.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Biotin“I've been struggling with low calcium the past couple days triggered by high dose biotin” In context ↗ Refeeding or deficiency problems
- H1 antihistamines (unspecified)“Antihistamines make me a complete zombie.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Other amino acids“Cysteine (and other sulfur supplements like glucosamine sulfate) depletes my copper pretty quickly, which is manifests as anemia and boils in less than 2 weeks (every time!).” In context ↗ Blood count problems
- NAC (N-acetylcysteine)“I can induce them by taking NAC for a few days, and I always get anemia symptoms that respond to copper after taking NAC for a few days.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Vitamin A (retinol)“While the vitamin A made me feel better than I've ever felt in my life the first 2 days, I rapidly declined with severe fatigue, insomnia and brain fog after that.” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Vitamin A (retinol)“Since I took the vitamin A, I've had bad skin and hair and high need for vitamin B6.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Beef liver (food or capsules)“I started taking beef liver pills in November, and within a couple days, the gums in the back of my mouth on the upper left started to get sore.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Bupropion (Wellbutrin)“I had a really great response to bupropion for 2 weeks. Then, it abruptly stopped working, and I felt dreadful.” In context ↗ Mood or psychiatric effects
Symptoms mentioned
Their words about their symptoms
- Brain fog
Calcium helps my GI symptoms, brain fog and fatigue.
In context ↗ - Gut problems
I've had bloating, gastroparesis and slow motility that was unrelated to food intake.
In context ↗ - Pain & fibromyalgia
I get severe muscle spasms that are relieved by calcium
In context ↗ - POTS & dysautonomia
The symptoms I treated by managing electrolytes (mostly fatigue, muscle pain/spasms and low blood pressure/POTS-like symptoms) all respond much better to calcium.
In context ↗ - Sleep problems
I thought my GI issues, low body temp, muscle spasms and hypersomnia were related to thyroid
In context ↗ - Neuropathy & tingling
distal extremity numbness and tingling
In context ↗ - Tinnitus
(tinnitus, jaw tremor, distal extremity numbness and tingling)
In context ↗ - Vision problems
clears my blurry vision (my pupils can contract!)
In context ↗ - Hair loss
My hair is in terrible shape (very fine with a lot of shedding)
In context ↗ - Mast cell (MCAS) & allergies
I get horrible restless leg syndrome and have too much histamine to sleep
In context ↗ - Anxiety & low mood
Somehow it even greatly improves my mood.
In context ↗
Ask Miruvor AI
Similar stories
-
I get chills for 2 weeks after a single attempt of killing gut microbes; permanent cure found: cod liver/oil or sashimi. See last post.
Lolinda developed ME/CFS after an EBV and at her worst could not climb stairs or lift a bag, slept 20 hours in 10 days and could barely eat or think. She credited a very low-carb paleo/ketogenic diet with ending ME within two weeks in 2014; later transdermal…
-
alethea on Phoenix Rising
Alethea described lifelong fatigue and ME/CFS-like illness, with a 2014 crash bringing fasciculations, numb lips and crushing fatigue that left her barely able to think or move. She credited high-dose thiamine (benfotiamine) with a life-changing improvement,…
-
Mick on Phoenix Rising
Mick fell ill around 1995 with gut problems and food intolerances, and was bed-bound from 2016 to 2019. High-dose CoQ10, methylfolate, boron, Candex and single amino acids slowly improved him; by 2023 he said he had almost got rid of CFS, though muscle…
-
CBS success!
Star-Anise fell ill in 2004 after a trip to India with gut problems and a Blastocystis parasite, then remained limited by fatigue, brain fog, food sensitivities and post-exertional symptoms. She credited a low-sulphur diet, charcoal, molybdenum, manganese…