Miruvor
Sign up

Echinacea

How it went for everyone who tried it

Helped means they said it helped with what they took it for, which may be one symptom and not the illness.

68%
helped
55 of 81
14%
no change
11 of 81
18%
got worse
15 of 81

Shares are out of the 81 people who said how it went. 48 more tried it without saying how it went overall; 1 of them describes a problem.

How it wentPeopleShare
Helped a lot22%
Helped5366%
No change1114%
Worse1316%
Much worse22%
Where it was reportedHelpedSaid how it went
Reddit3548
Recovery stories2033

Did it last, for everyone it helped?

  • It wore off for 1 of the 55 people it helped, who doesn’t credit it for their improvement.

Ask about this treatment

Among the 25 who credit it with their improvement, here’s how they are now

Credit it means they say it’s one reason they got better: 1 says it helped them most; 24 say it was one of several things that helped.

24%
recovered or near normal
6 of 25
64%
much or somewhat better
16 of 25
12%
relapsed
3 of 25

Where each person was at the end of their story, or in their latest post that says how they are, compared with their worst point.

Outcome describedPeopleShare
Recovered312%
Near normal312%
Much better936%
Somewhat better728%
Relapsed312%

Did it last?

  • No one said its benefit wore off.
  • 16 of the 25 who credit it say they still need to keep doing something (not always this) to stay well.

By how ill people were

Only the 25 who credit it, so people it didn’t help or made worse aren’t here. How they are now is their outcome overall, not the effect of this one treatment.

Severity at worstHow they are nownRecovered or near normal
Mild425%, few people
Moderate617%, few people
Severe813%, few people
Very severe425%, few people
Not stated367%, few people
At worstOutcomePeopleShare
MildRecovered1 of 425%
MildMuch better1 of 425%
MildSomewhat better1 of 425%
MildRelapsed1 of 425%
ModerateRecovered1 of 617%
ModerateMuch better3 of 650%
ModerateSomewhat better2 of 633%
SevereNear normal1 of 813%
SevereMuch better3 of 837%
SevereSomewhat better4 of 850%
Very severeRecovered1 of 425%
Very severeMuch better1 of 425%
Very severeRelapsed2 of 450%
Not statedNear normal2 of 367%
Not statedMuch better1 of 333%

Adverse events

What people said went wrong, in their own words.

14 of 129

people who wrote about taking it described a problem they tied to it

Described one · 14Didn’t mention one · 115

The serious kinds

Worth telling a doctor about straight away.

  • Made them much worse

    2 people
    “If you wanna send me to bed have equinacea tea. Is flue like right there.”
    — Seven7 (lnester7)
    “Echinacea is also from the ragweed family. Made me so much worse.”
    — antherder
  • Heart rhythm problems

    1 person
    “my heart spasmed ... The only catalyst I can think of which caused it was that I took a lot of Echinacea just before it”
    — Island 90224

The serious kinds are a death, suicidal thoughts or an attempt, a hospital stay, an ER visit, an allergic reaction or anaphylaxis, heart rhythm, liver or kidney, blood count, mood or psychiatric, or refeeding or deficiency problems, and being made much worse: a large worsening such as a crash lasting weeks or more.

Other kinds

Unpleasant effects people tied to it, the most serious first.

Made symptoms worse · 8Autoimmune or inflammatory flare · 3Gut side effects · 2Side effects · 1 Show all 4Hide
  • Made symptoms worse

    8 people
    “I also react really badly and get PEM from immune regulating herbs like astragalus and echinacea, and adaptogens like ashwaganda.”
    — Stream 28708
    “If you wanna send me to bed have equinacea tea. Is flue like right there.”
    — Seven7 (lnester7)
    Show 6 moreShow fewer
    “Now I realize that they were actually prolonging my flares, rather than helping a cold or a flu!”
    — ljimbo423
    “I remember feeling like garbage on supplements (like D, C, zinc, magnesium, and echinacea)”
    — Stream 76965
    “I can't take echinacea as it increases my viral symptoms.”
    — ukxmrv
    “Echinacea is also from the ragweed family. Made me so much worse.”
    — antherder
    “Things that stimulate the immune cascade worsen the feeling of pressure (eg - beta glucan, echinacea, h2o2) and increase my reaction to radiation.”
    — gahaust
    “I've noticed over the last few years that it doesn't seem to agree with me, making me feel worse.”
    — Mog
  • Autoimmune or inflammatory flare

    3 people
    “It comes with a pretty identifiable set of symptoms that flare any time something flares my immune system (ex: trying echinacea).”
    — Kite 55355
    “Also it came back when I took echinacea again, assumedly because it increases white blood cells, so triggered the auto-immune response”
    — Island 90224
    Show 1 moreShow fewer
    “I can't take immune boosters like those listed above, as they cause an autoimmune flare-up.”
    — CBS64
  • Gut side effects

    2 people
    “I think it made me nauseous the first couple times, but now I have no reaction!”
    — Lagoon 48948
    “yet if I take any supplements intended to increase or activate the immune system (echinacea, astragalus, Del-V), I get the worst physical reactions, including severe IBS that often includes bleeding”
    — Antares in NYC
  • Side effects

    1 person
    “aggressive micromanagement failed last summer when I used goldenseal, lomatium, cat's claw, cordiceps, lemon balm and echinacea ... Blood pressure surged to 200/100.”
    — Vale 51278

How often it comes up

Posts that mention Echinacea, per 1,000 posts each month. Hover or tap a point for the count.

024201020142017202020232026
MonthPosts mentioning itAll postsPer 1,000
Oct 200901050
Jan 201001410
Feb 201001130
Jun 201101090
Nov 201101240
Dec 201101990
Jan 201212324.3
Feb 201201030
Mar 201201900
Apr 201201620
May 201203750
Jun 201202380
Jul 201202400
Aug 201204850
Sep 201205610
Oct 201215261.9
Nov 201205140
Dec 201206990
Jan 201305330
Feb 201304470
Mar 201304290
Apr 201304990
May 201306060
Jun 201306090
Jul 201306160
Aug 201305770
Sep 201303640
Oct 201305360
Nov 201303850
Dec 201305190
Jan 201409440
Feb 201408210
Mar 201414252.4
Apr 201413612.8
May 201416171.6
Jun 201404890
Jul 201404440
Aug 201406220
Sep 201405070
Oct 201416781.5
Nov 201415671.8
Dec 201406290
Jan 201507600
Feb 201508730
Mar 201501,2760
Apr 201509840
May 201501,4960
Jun 201501,0460
Jul 201501,2110
Aug 201509980
Sep 201501,0600
Oct 201501,2550
Nov 201501,2460
Dec 201509240
Jan 201611,2820.78
Feb 201601,0510
Mar 201601,0020
Apr 201609980
May 201601,0450
Jun 201601,2300
Jul 201611,6190.62
Aug 201601,7290
Sep 201601,7850
Oct 201601,2200
Nov 201601,0920
Dec 201631,2112.5
Jan 201701,6600
Feb 201701,9880
Mar 201702,0780
Apr 201702,1330
May 201712,3700.42
Jun 201702,1940
Jul 201702,1830
Aug 201702,4660
Sep 201702,1890
Oct 201703,0420
Nov 201701,9760
Dec 201702,1120
Jan 201802,6200
Feb 201802,1550
Mar 201802,6130
Apr 201812,2510.44
May 201802,8280
Jun 201803,8710
Jul 201823,0670.65
Aug 201803,7570
Sep 201803,5120
Oct 201803,2610
Nov 201802,8610
Dec 201822,7540.73
Jan 201913,6720.27
Feb 201902,7150
Mar 201903,3170
Apr 201903,1410
May 201903,8550
Jun 201933,3920.88
Jul 201913,3120.30
Aug 201913,9430.25
Sep 201914,0350.25
Oct 201903,9220
Nov 201903,5080
Dec 201913,6590.27
Jan 202004,6500
Feb 202004,3740
Mar 202004,4750
Apr 202003,6900
May 202004,5430
Jun 202005,7010
Jul 202016,1040.16
Aug 2020110,3330.10
Sep 2020111,9580.08
Oct 2020114,5680.07
Nov 2020216,5460.12
Dec 2020120,7640.05
Jan 2021124,5620.04
Feb 2021324,6720.12
Mar 2021429,4760.14
Apr 2021228,5090.07
May 2021025,7910
Jun 2021127,8710.04
Jul 2021027,2200
Aug 2021430,8080.13
Sep 2021230,0740.07
Oct 2021122,1320.05
Nov 2021227,7220.07
Dec 2021031,8720
Jan 2022442,3170.09
Feb 2022438,6970.10
Mar 2022244,3050.05
Apr 2022444,3330.09
May 2022350,5940.06
Jun 2022349,0580.06
Jul 2022253,4850.04
Aug 2022154,4550.02
Sep 2022356,9360.05
Oct 2022558,5110.09
Nov 2022459,1980.07
Dec 2022361,5760.05
Jan 2023061,0040
Feb 2023450,1330.08
Mar 2023659,9250.10
Apr 2023354,2510.06
May 2023557,7680.09
Jun 2023252,6790.04
Jul 2023656,4010.11
Aug 2023465,4350.06
Sep 2023561,8350.08
Oct 2023658,4190.10
Nov 2023753,6620.13
Dec 20231060,6430.16
Jan 2024671,8180.08
Feb 2024770,0450.10
Mar 2024468,2610.06
Apr 2024264,3740.03
May 2024667,6980.09
Jun 2024664,7200.09
Jul 2024465,3350.06
Aug 2024768,5170.10
Sep 2024270,1680.03
Oct 2024272,6070.03
Nov 2024571,8020.07
Dec 2024674,4010.08
Jan 2025977,9090.12
Feb 2025765,1100.11
Mar 2025569,9050.07
Apr 2025661,6060.10
May 2025365,7330.05
Jun 2025560,5400.08
Jul 2025362,1050.05
Aug 2025564,5780.08
Sep 2025061,7040
Oct 2025259,2040.03
Nov 2025258,9440.03
Dec 2025662,8300.10
Jan 2026463,3210.06
Feb 2026253,0850.04
Mar 2026459,2080.07
Apr 2026353,9890.06
May 2026157,5410.02
Jun 2026255,3010.04
Jul 2026156,3910.02
Aug 2026256,8250.04
Sep 2026157,1430.02

Forum and Reddit posts, 4,007,898 in all, counted per month. A mention means the post names the treatment, not that the writer took it. All trends

20 of the 129 people who tried it

See all 129 stories
  • Often bedbound with long COVID, now almost back to normal after diet and rowing regimen

    Near normal Osprey 74759 Long COVID Ill 2.5 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Osprey 74759 fell ill with long COVID in October 2020 and after about 2.5 years was often bedbound, unable to walk 100 m without near-fainting. In 2023 a self-designed supplement, diet and rowing-machine regimen produced rapid gains: from bedridden to…

  • Bedbound with ME/CFS, now mostly housebound after strict PEM avoidance and supplements

    Much better Canyon 17326 ME/CFS Very severe at worstIll 7.5 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Fell ill around 2019 and spent four years barely leaving the house, mostly in bed. A two-week valacyclovir course gave a remission that ended in a month-long crash when the prescription stopped; a second COVID vaccination gave two near-normal weeks before…

  • Crushing fatigue with ME/CFS, 15-16 hours in bed, much better with L-arginine/vitamin C

    Much better Swan 86085 ME/CFS Moderate at worstIll 4 months before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    A man fell ill in December 2023 and crashed in late January 2024 with crushing fatigue, tachycardia, vertigo and brain fog, spending 15-16 hours a day in bed or on the sofa. L-arginine with liposomal vitamin C from April 2024 lifted him to mild, but he…

  • Bedbound with ME/CFS, now recovered after mind-body work and LDN

    Recovered Maple 80980 ME/CFS Very severe at worstIll 2 months before improving or writing reddit.com Jul 2026

    A man first ill with CFS/ME around 2015 recovered after about 18 months, then relapsed in mid-2025 and became bedbound, needing a caregiver to feed him. He credited mind-body and nervous system work, Primal Trust, LDN, later IFS therapy and JournalSpeak for…

  • Substantial improvement with strange dietary adjustments

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · Not saidWonkmonk ME/CFS Very severe at worstIll 14 years before improving forums.phoenixrising.me Oct 2026

    Wonkmonk fell ill in 2007 and worsened after thyroid surgery in 2014, becoming near very severe by 2022 with only 1-2 hours out of bed. Antivirals helped briefly but caused kidney injury; from 2021 dietary changes brought a sustained rise to moderate CFS,…

  • Bedridden with ME/CFS, now much better with aggressive rest and immune globulin

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · WorseStream 28708 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 10 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Developed ME/CFS at 13 after mononucleosis and became bedridden with months of rolling PEM, worsened by exercise addiction and a COVID vaccine. Aggressive rest plus subcutaneous immune globulin (20 g/week), testosterone, growth hormone and peptides took him…

  • A year of long COVID brain fog and fatigue, now near normal with immunoglobulin infusions

    Near normal Doesn’t credit it · HelpedOrchid 95797 Long COVID Mild at worstIll 1 year before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    She caught COVID in March 2025 and spent the next year with constant brain fog, fatigue, joint pain and recurring sinus infections, still holding on to her job. Azithromycin briefly returned her to normal; after a primary immune deficiency was diagnosed she…

  • Bedbound with ME/CFS, still largely housebound after nicotine patches helped then faded

    Relapsed Doesn’t credit it · WorseKite 55355 ME/CFS Very severe at worstIll 4 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Kite 55355 fell ill in January 2022 after a bad Moderna booster reaction, worsened after COVID in August 2022 and crashed into ME/CFS that November. Bedbound/housebound from March 2023, they were still largely housebound or bedbound about three years after…

  • Long COVID brain fog and raised heart rate, improved then crashed worse than ever

    Relapsed Doesn’t credit it · No changeMesa 31924 Long COVID Severe at worstIll 4.5 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Mesa 31924 had mild ME/CFS and loud tinnitus from 2019; his long COVID began in January 2022, the day after a third Moderna shot, with much worse brain fog and raised heart rate. Improvement came in waves through 2023, and by 2025 he could do short hikes,…

  • Long COVID PEM stopped him walking; now 80-90% recovered after methylene blue and NAD+

    Recovered Doesn’t credit it · Not saidMaple 37560 Long COVID Moderate at worstIll 8 months before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    A man who was infected with COVID in May 2024 and later developed long COVID declined over months, with gut pain, headaches, brain fog and PEM that by December stopped him walking without flaring. In early 2025 a stack including methylene blue, NAD+…

  • Long COVID with brain fog, fatigue and breathlessness, still ill; creatine and fish oil no help

    No benefit Doesn’t credit it · Helped a lotCreek 50468 Long COVID Mild at worstIll for 11 months reddit.com Oct 2026

    By late 2025 they had long COVID symptoms including brain fog, fatigue, pins and needles, breathlessness and returning psychotic symptoms, and most days could get by only with difficulty. Pseudoephedrine, echinacea and lemon balm helped, naproxen with…

  • Housebound with ME/CFS, now somewhat better after sleep and acupuncture

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · No changeSequoia 58955 ME/CFS Moderate at worstIll 17 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Sequoia 58955 reported having CFS for 17 years by 2022. They had grown worse and housebound before improving after more sleep and acupuncture, and later credited pacing, rest, salt and fluids and Claire Weekes' floating-past-symptoms method. They remained…

  • Long COVID with vomiting, tremors and vertigo, somewhat better with beta blockers

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · Not saidBeacon 63076 Long COVID Mild at worstIll 6 years before improving or writing reddit.com Sep 2026

    Beacon 63076 caught COVID in 2020 and 2021 and dated her long COVID to around 2022: vomiting bile for hours several times a week, body-wide muscle tremors, vertigo, panic and night sweats. She kept working and did short gym sessions. Beta blockers, saffron,…

  • Long COVID worse to 2021, better after mould move, supplements, then relapsed housebound

    Relapsed Doesn’t credit it · Not saidDusk 28795 Long COVID Moderate at worstIll 2 years before improving or writing reddit.com Sep 2026

    Dusk 28795 fell ill with long COVID after a December 2019 infection, with symptoms from March 2020, and grew steadily worse until late 2021. Moving out of a mouldy house, a supplement regimen and breaks from work due to a layoff turned a corner in early…

  • Long COVID, in bed much of the first 18 months, much better with diet and supplements

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · Not saidQuail 52065 Long COVID Severe at worstIll 4.5 years before improving or writing reddit.com Sep 2026

    A woman in the US caught COVID in October 2021 and spent much of the first 18 months in bed with PEM, brain fog, gut and flu-like symptoms. Over three years she slowly improved, crediting an elimination diet, many supplements, meditation and somatic…

  • Moderate ME/CFS, at times more bedbound, now mild with low-dose naltrexone and pacing

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · Not saidFalcon 30947 ME/CFS Moderate at worstIll 4 years before improving or writing reddit.com Sep 2026

    Falcon 30947 fell ill with ME/CFS after Covid and EBV and became moderate, at times more bedbound, with chronic migraine, nerve pain, POTS and brain fog. Low-dose naltrexone, plus strict pacing, POTS and migraine medication, took them to mild. Returning to…

  • Long COVID with fatigue, brain fog and POTS, now recovered after pacing

    Recovered Doesn’t credit it · No changeHeron 79265 Long COVID Mild at worstIll 18 months before improving or writing reddit.com Aug 2026

    They got COVID in August 2022 and developed long COVID with fatigue, brain fog, POTS, muscle pain and sore throats, at times barely able to work. Reactivated EBV was diagnosed. They credited lumbrokinase/nattokinase, a gluten-free diet, valacyclovir and…

  • Long COVID with twitching, heavy limbs and joint pain, nearly normal after gym and Lexapro

    Near normal Doesn’t credit it · Not saidShore 48268 Long COVID Mild at worstIll 5 months before improving or writing reddit.com Aug 2026

    A 37-year-old man developed long COVID after a first infection in February 2024, with widespread twitching, heavy limbs, migrating joint pain, later a pulmonary embolism, and severe new health anxiety; blood pressure hit 190/100. A neurologist diagnosed…

  • Off work for months with long COVID, now back at work and short walks, still symptomatic

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · WorseIsland 90224 Long COVID Moderate at worstIll 4.5 years before improving or writing reddit.com Jul 2026

    Island 90224 fell ill in September 2021 and was off work for months with fatigue, headaches and insomnia; a January 2022 booster brought tachycardia and chest pains. Propolis helped briefly in November 2021. Returning to work by mid-2023 was possible, but a…

  • Largely bedbound with ME/CFS, now somewhat better after supplements and diet

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · HelpedMaple 57988 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 6 years before improving or writing reddit.com Jul 2026

    A man in Europe fell ill with long COVID in April 2020 after mild gastrointestinal symptoms, months after mononucleosis. Over three years on he still had ME/CFS with PEM, brain fog, MCAS and insomnia, largely bedbound and unable to work. Supplements, herbal…

These are the newest 4 of the 25 who credit Echinacea for their improvement, then the newest 16 of the 104 who tried it without crediting it, in about the same proportion as the full list.

A little hope, every Sunday

New recovery stories and data-driven research on ME/CFS and long COVID. Ideas worth considering, and the evidence behind them.

Free · Unsubscribe anytime