joejack102 on Phoenix Rising
- Condition
- ME/CFS
- At worst
- Moderate (mostly housebound)
- Ill for
- 20 years
- Last post
- Oct 2019
In their words
- Condition: ME/CFS
I have POTS/Dysautonomia/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome.
In context ↗ - At worst: Moderate
I have not been well enough to return to my job in over 4 months now.
In context ↗ - Now: No benefit
I still have not found relief.
In context ↗ - Began after: nothing they could name
Starting at age 13, I became the most sensitive person to the effects of herbs & meds.
In context ↗
The story comes from their 59 posts in 21 threads
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Oct 2017
- Nov 2017
- Nov 2017
- Nov 2017
- Nov 2017
- Nov 2017
- Dec 2017
- Dec 2017
- Dec 2017
- Dec 2017
- Dec 2017
- Dec 2017
- Dec 2017
- Dec 2017
- Jan 2018
- Jan 2018
- Mar 2018
- Mar 2018
- Mar 2018
- Mar 2018
- Mar 2018
- May 2018
- May 2018
- May 2018
- May 2018
- May 2018
- Jun 2018
- Jun 2018
- Jun 2018
- Oct 2019
Summary
joejack102 dates their illness to age 13, when they became extremely sensitive to herbs and medicines; they called it POTS, dysautonomia and CFS. In 2009 heavy choline bitartrate and CDP-choline use removed the sensitivities but left severe fatigue, brain fog and pain that persisted after stopping. By late 2017 they had not worked for months; a CPAP helped their sleep, but in October 2019 the choline reaction was still unresolved.
Ask Miruvor AI
What they tried
Also tried
Their words about each treatment
- Choline Bitartrate · Much worse
After using excessive Choline supplements in 2009 ... left me severely fatigued all the time with little to no energy
In context ↗ - CDP Choline · Much worse
Gave me insane fatigue and major symptoms for many years.
In context ↗ - p-5-p / B6 (pyridoxine) · Much worse
I had very bad toxicity, neuropathy, headaches, and extreme anger issues after using p-5-p, a version of Vitamin B6.
In context ↗ - Niacin · No change
Niacin and SAMe did not solve this problem. I tried extensively with those (separately).
In context ↗ - Potassium · No change
Also, potassium doesn’t seem to help me either.
In context ↗ - B12 (methylcobalamin and cyanocobalamin) · Worse
It is causing me to experience quite a significant level of anxiety, racing thoughts, and jitteriness.
In context ↗ - Methyl-Folate (Quatrefolic) · No change
I have tried Methyl-Folate extensively and had no benefits.
In context ↗ - Folic Acid · No change
I took it as a supplement in addition to what I get in my daily diet to no avail.
In context ↗ - N-Acetyl-Cysteine (NAC) · Much worse
I have used N-Acetyl-Cysteine (NAC) multiple times but it made me feel awful. It raised my blood pressure and anxiety a ton
In context ↗ - Tyrosine · Worse
I used it and felt great at first. I thought it cured me. And then I crashed HARD after several days.
In context ↗ - Ashwagandha · Helped
the herb Ashwagandha would temporarily decrease my sensitivities to that of a normal person
In context ↗ - Chamomile · Worse
the herb Chamomile would increase my sensitivities
In context ↗ - homeopathic remedy · Worse
I remember when I used to be super-sensitive having a major reaction to a homeopathic remedy.
In context ↗ - Anticholinergic stuff · Worse
Anticholinergic stuff made me sick.
In context ↗ - Benadryl · Much worse
Benadryl also caused nerve pain over my entire body. Huge negative reaction.
In context ↗ - antihistamines · Worse
I’ve tried Benadryl and antihistamines many times and they made me feel awful every time.
In context ↗ - DMG (DiMethylGlycine) · Not said
Just started DMG (DiMethylGlycine) supplement and it appears to be working
In context ↗ - CoQ10 · Worse
I’m getting a significant chronic headache only a couple days in.
In context ↗ - Agmatine · Worse
Yes, and I have a negative experience with it. Abdominal pain, and increased fatigue.
In context ↗ - Florinef · Not said
Florinef to increase blood volume
In context ↗ - beta blockers · Not said
avoiding all caffeine products, beta blockers, improving quality of diet overall
In context ↗ - high salt diet, salt tablets and lots of water · Not said
lots of water, avoiding sugar, high salt diet (even tried salt tablets)
In context ↗ - Graduated exercise program specifically for POTS · Not said
Graduated exercise program specifically for POTS
In context ↗ - avoiding all caffeine products · Not said
avoiding all caffeine products
In context ↗ - CPAP · Helped
I now use a CPAP every night to help me sleep/breathe and it’s incredible. I now sleep so much better, and my sleep is more refreshing!
In context ↗ - Ginseng · Worse
Ginseng would have an extremely exaggerated effects after the smallest exposure
In context ↗
Their path
How ill they were on the ME/CFS severity scale, estimated from what they describe at each point, with time counted from when the illness began. Hover or tap a point. The chart starts 10 years after onset: the story doesn’t say how ill they were before that. 1 step says too little to place on the scale and is only in the table. What the levels mean.
Show as a table
| When | What happened | Where they were | After |
|---|---|---|---|
| age 13 | became extremely sensitive to herbs and medicines; POTS symptoms lifelongStarting at age 13, I became the most sensitive person to the effects of herbs & meds.In context ↗ | Not stated | |
| Fall 2009 | choline supplements removed the sensitivities but left chronic severe fatigue and brain fogthe excessive Choline usage from 2009 left me severely fatigued all the time with little to no energyIn context ↗ | Mild | Citicoline (CDP-choline) |
| 2017 | further choline use made things worse againit got worse after trying Choline again earlier this year.In context ↗ | Moderate | Citicoline (CDP-choline) |
| 2018-01-13 | lowest point, off work for months and rated suffering 9.9 out of 10I'm at a 9.9 out of 10 on the scale of human suffering a person can even tolerate.In context ↗ | Moderate | |
| 2018-06-28 | diagnosed with obstructive sleep apnoea and started CPAP, sleep became refreshingI now sleep so much better, and my sleep is more refreshing!In context ↗ | Moderate | CPAP and sleep apnoea treatment |
| 2019-10-26 | still no antidote to the choline reactionI have not found an antidote to this reaction.In context ↗ | Moderate |
Adverse events
- Vitamin B6 (pyridoxine, P5P)“I had very bad toxicity, neuropathy, headaches, and extreme anger issues after using p-5-p, a version of Vitamin B6.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Choline“the excessive Choline usage from 2009 left me severely fatigued all the time with little to no energy” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Tyrosine“And then I crashed HARD after several days. All of a sudden I got severe chills and overall nerve pain.” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- “Anticholinergic stuff made me sick.” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Diphenhydramine (Benadryl)“Benadryl also caused nerve pain over my entire body. Huge negative reaction.” In context ↗ Nerve pain
- Homeopathy“having a major reaction to a homeopathic remedy. The effects were exaggerated and extremely real and dangerous.” In context ↗ Side effects
- NAC (N-acetylcysteine)“It raised my blood pressure and anxiety a ton, didn’t feel safe, and made me feel much worse.” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Chamomile tea“CHAMOMILE: Used to do the exact opposite of Ashwagandha; it would INCREASE my sensitives (for 24 hours).” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Citicoline (CDP-choline)“It got worse when I was trying to reverse it and used more CDP Choline this year.” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- CoQ10 / ubiquinol“I’m getting a significant chronic headache only a couple days in.” In context ↗ Side effects
- Agmatine“Yes, and I have a negative experience with it. Abdominal pain, and increased fatigue.” In context ↗ Gut side effects
- Choline“the Choline supplements left me chronically and majorly fatigued... seemingly permanently, LONG-TERM.” In context ↗ Made symptoms worse
- Vitamin B12“it honestly left me severely anxious to the point where I felt like I was going crazy! It made me ready to jump out of my own skin, and caused me to have insane panic attacks.” In context ↗ Mood or psychiatric effects
- Vitamin B12“It is causing me to experience quite a significant level of anxiety, racing thoughts, and jitteriness.” In context ↗ Side effects
Symptoms mentioned
Their words about their symptoms
- Brain fog
I have long-term critical and alarming levels of fatigue & brain fog.
In context ↗ - POTS & dysautonomia
I've had POTS Syndrome my entire life.
In context ↗ - Mast cell (MCAS) & allergies
I used to have very strong seasonal allergies, that magically disappeared when I used the Choline supplements in 2009.
In context ↗ - Headaches & migraine
neuropathy, headaches, and extreme anger issues after using p-5-p, a version of Vitamin B6
In context ↗ - Neuropathy & tingling
Benadryl also caused nerve pain over my entire body.
In context ↗ - Anxiety & low mood
it honestly left me severely anxious to the point where I felt like I was going crazy!
In context ↗ - Breathlessness
It caused me to be left with extreme fatigue, shortness of breath, overall pain, brain fog
In context ↗ - Temperature regulation
All of a sudden I got severe chills and overall nerve pain.
In context ↗ - Sleep problems
I found out recently that I have obstructive sleep apnea.
In context ↗