Miruvor
Sign up

Meditation, yoga, breathwork

How it went for everyone who tried it

Helped means they said it helped with what they took it for, which may be one symptom and not the illness.

85%
helped
6,933 of 8,138
9%
no change
696 of 8,138
6%
got worse
509 of 8,138

Shares are out of the 8,138 people who said how it went. 1,520 more tried it without saying how it went overall; 57 of them describe a problem.

How it wentPeopleShare
Helped a lot5006%
Helped6,43379%
No change6969%
Worse4806%
Much worse29<1%
Where it was reportedHelpedSaid how it went
Reddit6,2347,272
Recovery stories699866

Did it last, for everyone it helped?

  • It wore off for 132 of the 6,933 people it helped: 61 who credit it for their improvement, 71 who don’t.

Ask about this treatment

Among the 2,890 who credit it with their improvement, here’s how they are now

Credit it means they say it’s one reason they got better: 644 say it helped them most; 2,246 say it was one of several things that helped.

32%
recovered or near normal
936 of 2,882
57%
much or somewhat better
1,648 of 2,882
10%
relapsed
284 of 2,882
1%
no benefit
14 of 2,882
8
outcome unclear
not in the shares

Where each person was at the end of their story, or in their latest post that says how they are, compared with their worst point.

Outcome describedPeopleShare
Recovered34512%
Near normal59120%
Much better81128%
Somewhat better83729%
Relapsed28410%
No benefit141%
Outcome unclear8—

Did it last?

  • 61 of the 2,890 who credit it said its benefit wore off (35 of them among the 284 who relapsed).
  • 1,300 of the 2,890 who credit it say they still need to keep doing something (not always this) to stay well.

By how ill people were

Only the 2,890 who credit it, so people it didn’t help or made worse aren’t here. How they are now is their outcome overall, not the effect of this one treatment.

Severity at worstHow they are nownRecovered or near normal
Mild53039%
Moderate75631%
Severe1,05232%
Very severe17327%
Not stated37929%
At worstOutcomePeopleShare
MildRecovered37 of 5287%
MildNear normal169 of 52832%
MildMuch better78 of 52815%
MildSomewhat better208 of 52839%
MildRelapsed33 of 5286%
MildNo benefit3 of 5281%
ModerateRecovered79 of 75411%
ModerateNear normal154 of 75420%
ModerateMuch better214 of 75428%
ModerateSomewhat better226 of 75430%
ModerateRelapsed77 of 75410%
ModerateNo benefit4 of 7541%
SevereRecovered157 of 1,05115%
SevereNear normal186 of 1,05117%
SevereMuch better371 of 1,05135%
SevereSomewhat better206 of 1,05120%
SevereRelapsed124 of 1,05112%
SevereNo benefit7 of 1,0511%
Very severeRecovered26 of 17315%
Very severeNear normal20 of 17312%
Very severeMuch better70 of 17340%
Very severeSomewhat better31 of 17318%
Very severeRelapsed26 of 17315%
Not statedRecovered46 of 37612%
Not statedNear normal62 of 37617%
Not statedMuch better78 of 37621%
Not statedSomewhat better166 of 37644%
Not statedRelapsed24 of 3766%

Adverse events

What people said went wrong, in their own words.

798 of 9,658

people who wrote about taking it described a problem they tied to it

Described one · 798Didn’t mention one · 8,860

The serious kinds

Worth telling a doctor about straight away.

  • Hospitalisation

    3 people
    “Trying deep breathing during a particularly bad POTS flare(caused by brushing teeth) is what caused my 1st hospitalization.”
    — Ocean 45310
    “I got hospitalized after starting the wim hof. Seemed to make everything ten times worse for me.”
    — Dusk 78485
    Show 1 moreShow fewer
    “A week in hospital, scan after scan, a lumbar puncture”
    — Harry Boby
  • Suicidal thoughts or attempt

    3 people
    “I'll be honest, finding this void made me consider taking my own life, because I want to be there forever”
    — Alder 33411
    “If I try to empty my mind then suicidal thoughts creep in and I can't stop thinking of killing myself.”
    — Petrel 33353
    Show 1 moreShow fewer
    “Now meditation makes me suicidal because I cannot distract myself from my worst symptoms (burning and pressure in head, tinnitus).”
    — Otter 99854
  • Made them much worse

    31 people
    “I was told I could exercise my way out of it and killed myself doing yoga 3x / week for a while, completely destroying my baseline.”
    — Orchid 12813
    “Have previously done Vipassana retreats which have been very detrimental due to the physical demands of sitting straight backed and crossed legs for hours. it pushed me to severe actually”
    — Osprey 57920
    Show 28 moreShow fewer
    “I pushed past when my body said to stop - a massive mistake that I've never recovered from.”
    — Pebble 58253
    “meditation landed me in psych ward”
    — Hill 74711
    “I had attempted 10 mins of yoga 2 days in a row to resolve back pain. Following on from those 2 days I became severely ill”
    — Starling 64313
    “I finally did a power yoga session that sent me into moderate a month ago”
    — Stream 66045
    “Yoga had me in bed bound PEM for 3 weeks.”
    — Quail 78222
    “I yoga’d my way into neck / shoulder / wrist dysfunction that accelerated the end of my brief but thrilling graphic / web design career.”
    — Acorn 89332
    “meditation has triggered some serious symptoms for me that lasted months.”
    — Bramble 90895
    “I did it every other day for a week. I crashed out for like 2 months.”
    — Grove 64745
    “Right at the beginning I tried Wim Hof but found the breathwork and ice baths but it made me much worse.”
    — Crocus 23313
    “Overexcited pushed myself too far to attend a breathwork retreat not accounting for the deconditioning of my body.”
    — Prairie 88252
    “after a while of doing it, I ended up in a psych ward”
    — Daffodil
    “Yoga absolutely decimates me. I did it once and was out for three weeks.”
    — Trail 33381
    “an occupational therapist insisted i do a little yoga with her and it messed me UP for weeks”
    — Bluebell 71799
    “I tried. It caused me too much pain. I ended up being severe from pushing myself like everyone wanted.”
    — Wave 84139
    “wim hoff rapid breathing makes my symptoms much worse.”
    — Maple 47264
    “it mostly pelvic and leg exercises which made my body feel so tired ... unfortunately it created another round of chronic fatigue”
    — Alder 69168
    “Just one session ruined my 4 months of progress... unbelievable...subsequent gym visits have given me full on PEM”
    — Dusk 10750
    “I tried to do yoga again ( very gentle , short duration), and am suffering a horrible relapse.”
    — Flint 19023
    “I started doing five minutes of yoga everyday, on top of my normal routine. A week later I had my first serious ME crash”
    — Dune 50262
    “Gave tinnitus for so many people (including me) and doesn't give a fuck. Ruined so many lives as it looks like the damage is always permanent”
    — Stone 30214
    “The yoga made it a hundred times worse.”
    — Glade 43250
    “Wim Hof gave me nerve damage and memory impairment that took a while to recover from.”
    — Mesa 70474
    “a few months into this way of thinking, I had a crash so severe I was left bedbound and unable to speak. I never recovered.”
    — LaurelB
    “yoga is and was a disaster for me. So many relapses, the last time I tried - and relapsed badly - was 7 months into my illness.”
    — Hill 85184
    “something that caused a big crash ( like trying yoga once)”
    — Mesa 87897
    “Wim Hof gave me tinnitus and a bunch of vestibular disorders. This is VERY common and has completely decimated my life.”
    — Kite 71713
    “Early on I did Hot Yoga. and got his by a ton of bricks.”
    — kendonoghue
    “Be careful a yoga class followed by Pilates cost me four months.”
    — Rain 50250

    The words of 30 of these 31 people.

  • Mood or psychiatric effects

    117 people
    “Now when I try it, it just makes me super nervous”
    — Hill 82091
    “Before it just stressed me out but I think it helps me now.”
    — Ocean 16359
    Show 28 moreShow fewer
    “Meditation itself can trigger panic attacks and anxiety in some people, myself included.”
    — Bramble 30094
    “whenever I tried to relax or meditate it would basically trigger a panic attack”
    — Island 53545
    “some of the mindfulness skills lead to dissociation”
    — Bramble 35757
    “Breath-work, I couldn’t do at all until I had been meditating for quite a few months. It just activated me too much and it always made my anxiety much worse”
    — Kite 77342
    “Yoga and mindfulness often make me cry and give me panic attack type feelings”
    — Kite 67656
    “Absolutely feel mentally worse after meditating, not instantly, at first it’s lovely relaxation. Then BAM, horrible flash backs and negative thoughts.”
    — Canyon 91824
    “In my own example it led to my ocd worsening.”
    — Hare 75846
    “I always found it made me more anxious”
    — Crocus 81605
    “I really struggle with aggressive rest too and stuff like meditation stresses me out more.”
    — Glacier 45332
    “The only thing I want when someone suggests meditation is to punch them in the face... Makes me even more anxious.”
    — Pelican 30016
    “Sometimes the breathing techniques causes more anxiety but i keep trying to do them anyhow.”
    — Tern 36240
    “any attempt ever to consciously guide my thoughts only leads to horrible ocd flares that just make my nervous system feel all knotted up and end up making me much worse”
    — Hawk 54761
    “I get more stressed because I become even more aware of how I feel and the symptoms and all the why doesn't it work?!-thoughts”
    — Osprey 18744
    “In my case, I get super anxious from doing breathwork. Sometimes I begin to hyperventilate because it’s too overwhelming to think about the way I should breathe.”
    — Grove 40739
    “Tried to do a free mindfulness program but instead of relaxing me the guy's moist mouth sounds provoked anxiety and disgust.”
    — Artemisia
    “Meditation is more likely to make me feel crazy.”
    — Sparrow 44362
    “Trying to meditate makes me nervous.”
    — Nightjar 78640
    “I feel objectively much worse ... left me emotional raw, dysregulated, and further disabled by this illness”
    — Eagle 54584
    “when I try to deep breath my left sided symptoms and anxiety/ depression gets worse”
    — Birch 37679
    “holding on empty after that exhale will induce some panic (still does even now for me)”
    — Harbor 40017
    “Before getting MECFS I actually took part in a study about using a meditation app and it made my stress worse.”
    — Glade 43125
    “I would do visualizations or something and then my inner ocd goblin would be going haywire and before I knew it I’d be back on my phone for hours in nearly psychotic rage”
    — Acorn 37104
    “I used to meditate a lot, which I have been forced to stop due to it making my mental state worse”
    — Cove 59437
    “issues with body/breathing awareness exercises making my anxiety worse”
    — Lake 25545
    “I would always get irritated when I wouldn't achieve my goals ... I'd end up more stressed than when i started.”
    — Canyon 96293
    “It’s brought obsessions to the forefront before that then was OCD hell.”
    — Plover 82201
    “do beware if you have a PTSD diagnosis bc the body does store trauma, for me it's too scary”
    — Cedar 73513
    “I also find meditation hard. Sometimes I can get into it, but it seems to cause anxiety and OCD at the time and just unpleasant mental states either at the time or sometimes the next day.”
    — Pond 51836

    The words of 30 of these 117 people.

  • Heart rhythm problems

    16 people
    “Breathing exercises seem to make my heart pound out of control.”
    — Kite 55355
    “i’ll even get a racing heart when doing breathing exercises that are specifically meant to calm down your nervous system”
    — Oak 84870
    Show 14 moreShow fewer
    “Though I find yoga nidra very calming and relaxing, my heartrate says otherwise haha.”
    — Grove 40739
    “Recently I had been trying mindfulness meditation after many years of not doing it, and this also started setting off my heart along with all kinds of weird anxiety issues.”
    — Cove 59437
    “One day while doing this exercise, I felt like something suddenly ‘broke’ in my chest, and I started gasping for air and having lots of palpitations.”
    — Stream 25490
    “controlled breathing triggers heart rate spikes for me and I haven’t been able to stick with the routines”
    — Acorn 72602
    “My heartrate goes way up, during meditation, even though I am deeply relaxed. That sucks, since meditation used to be a nice resting activity, but now I had to stop it completely.”
    — Plover 34966
    “several "easy, gentle" yoga moves were sending my heart rate way into the danger level after just seconds”
    — Lagoon 88610
    “sent my heart rate soaring”
    — Starling 49586
    “I struggle with them because they trigger ectopic heartbeats a lot”
    — Wave 92937
    “I did try some though and it actually made my heart rate too low.”
    — Swan 54697
    “around month 6 I tried to do some light yoga and ended up with my heart rate randomly spiking to 170bpm a few times a day while sedentary for weeks after”
    — Hill 85184
    “Some days slower breathing “works” for me others it drastically increases my heart rate and decreases my heart rate variability.”
    — Badger 54550
    “often times it’s just made my HR worse or only slightly better.”
    — Vale 19824
    “I just tried to meditate and my heart skipped a beat then I got shortness of breath.”
    — Crocus 60466
    “I did 6 minutes of this laying down in bed and my heart rate spiked from 60bpm to 80 bpm within the first minute.”
    — Crocus 41982
  • ER visit

    1 person
    “He accepted me leaving for a month long course of yoga training (terrible idea of my doctors, after 2 weeks I ended up in the ER and I'm bedridden since)”
    — Tide 34218

The serious kinds are a death, suicidal thoughts or an attempt, a hospital stay, an ER visit, an allergic reaction or anaphylaxis, heart rhythm, liver or kidney, blood count, mood or psychiatric, or refeeding or deficiency problems, and being made much worse: a large worsening such as a crash lasting weeks or more. 11 of those made much worse say only that, without a specific adverse event, so are not in the 798 above.

Other kinds

Unpleasant effects people tied to it, the most serious first.

Made symptoms worse · 528Low blood pressure or fainting · 12Autoimmune or inflammatory flare · 2Insomnia from treatment · 13Nerve pain · 4Herx / die-off reaction · 2Side effects · 114Other · 37 Show all 8Hide
  • Made symptoms worse

    528 people
    “I used to be able to do deep concentration practice but now it triggers brain fog”
    — Otter 31595
    “Went on day 3, felt worse.”
    — wabi-sabi
    Show 28 moreShow fewer
    “Wim Hof almost killed me (really, I even got a bump on my lips immediately after I held my breath for a minute and had to lie down for the next 5 hours).”
    — Osprey 74759
    “I've additionally aggravated my CFS by doing some poses that I didn't realize were hurting my (undiagnosed at the time) CCI”
    — Tide 27404
    “If I try when I’m low… it’s not the normal “brain wandering off” sensation, it’s a BAD, almost splintering sensation.”
    — Mesa 20088
    “I was told I could exercise my way out of it and killed myself doing yoga 3x / week for a while, completely destroying my baseline.”
    — Orchid 12813
    “guided meditation 100% causes PEM for me due to the sound and cognitive exertion required”
    — Puffin 71350
    “If I try to hold my breath or do breathing work or breathe into my stiff chest it goes troppo.”
    — Eagle 25391
    “now when i attempt any i only focus on the pain moving through my body bc there is not distraction from it and i hate it”
    — Alder 73967
    “Have previously done Vipassana retreats which have been very detrimental due to the physical demands of sitting straight backed and crossed legs for hours. it pushed me to severe actually”
    — Osprey 57920
    “I often experience extra tension, pain and restlessness, whilst my heart rate does drop”
    — Moon 97425
    “From my experience, it was hard on my body. It seemed to exert a lot of energy.”
    — Lynx 74813
    “decided to do gentle yoga for beginners and it has really hurt my chest, really tight chest pain and now I’m lying on the settee.”
    — Tulip 28194
    “Meditation is too much effort when ME is bad and the fatigue from trying makes me worse.”
    — Bluebell 76797
    “I tried wimhof breathing which is also meant to do that, but got the same kind of worse symptoms as from the TENS machine.”
    — Ridge 79841
    “Too much breathwork is like exercise for me, it makes me crash.”
    — Marsh 78145
    “the effort and focus of traditional meditation exhausting, detrimental and counter productive, like I do”
    — Sandpiper 28301
    “Exercise of practically any kind gives me PEM. And I've tried quite a few version of it from GE to yoga, mindfulness, physical therapy, ergo therapy etc.”
    — Orchid 70885
    “When I was severe, deep breathing made my heart rate go up and exhausted me.”
    — Wave 13014
    “Guided meditation ( Joe Dispensa ) : after 15 min I have sound intolerance. No effects”
    — Oak 13648
    “i did some yoga nidra, with a tiny bit of pem, bc i maybe was stretching too hard.”
    — Moon 63197
    “each time I have done one of her videos I have crashed for a couple of days afterwards”
    — Kite 67656
    “doing yoga gave me full body pain for days”
    — Dew 44784
    “but at a certain point it worsened my tinnitus and head pressure a lot and it didn't feel right so I stopped”
    — Eagle 38843
    “This is combination with other techniques I came across sometimes made it worse but mostly helped me with the pain.”
    — Pelican 92635
    “since my crash it puts me into a buzzing mode where I feel my whole body fibrate and that sets off the adrenaline surges with dissociation so I quit that for a while”
    — Kestrel 61314
    “meditation is one of the worst triggers of this, so I don’t do it.”
    — Canyon 31984
    “many of the things I tried on my own only made me worse (breathing exercises, vagus nerve stimulation, ultrasound, acupuncture, fascia massage, meditation, humming, etc.)”
    — Kite 55355
    “Some are more intensely breathing focused and can wear me out”
    — Swan 98858
    “I have a terrible time trying to meditate or deep breathe, and it is so much worse when I feel like this.”
    — Gull 69101

    The words of 30 of these 528 people.

  • Low blood pressure or fainting

    12 people
    “I just tried it for the first time and I got really light headed by my 10th exhale and I had to stop.”
    — Nightjar 28412
    “I get dizzy if I do extended exhale, and even sometimes if I do box breathing”
    — Stream 85530
    Show 10 moreShow fewer
    “I even passed out once from the oxygen overload.”
    — Dove 17548
    “Standing yoga makes me dizzy”
    — Kestrel 22128
    “Does anyone else get lightheaded doing the fast breathing at the beginning?”
    — Ocean 14951
    “I experienced lightheadedness when I did "box breathing", but I am having much better luck with 4-7-8 breathing.”
    — Horizon 47861
    “even on a short breath hold I almost blacked out. Intense wave came over my body, my eyes went dark and my ears started ringing super loud”
    — Alder 68092
    “I got dizzy after the session and it felt like I used too much energy or something which made me feel fainted”
    — Marsh 40808
    “trying any of the breathing exercises immediately makes me lightheaded and feeling like I'm going to pass out”
    — Ruthie24
    “I just tried it and nearly fainted.”
    — Bluebell 73225
    “I do get dizzy and have to regain my equilibrium in the child's pose”
    — Fjord 74120
    “i had terrible problems and i collapsed twice”
    — golden
  • Autoimmune or inflammatory flare

    2 people
    “easily aggravated my pericarditis to do stretches!!”
    — Glade 35584
    “since I've developed ME/CFS the yoga can cause a bit of inflammation compared to other exercises.”
    — Lynx 55060
  • Insomnia from treatment

    13 people
    “I concentrate so hard on the breathing that it keeps me awake”
    — Sandpiper 74069
    “I’ve probably overstimulated myself by overbreathing and more phone use.”
    — Nightjar 39265
    Show 11 moreShow fewer
    “meditating continuously for 1h+ gives me insomnia”
    — Swan 47416
    “sleeping seemed impossible for a few nights”
    — Dove 17548
    “I tried just doing some simple meditation even, for 1 minute, an hour ago and now my nervous system is so activated i likely wont sleep well tonight.”
    — Glade 96312
    “it gives me worse insomnia.(i already have insomnia but this makes it worse)”
    — Glacier 42436
    “I had to take some pills to get to sleep (I usually don't take anything for sleep).”
    — robson
    “after a long hard day of meditating, I go to bed and lay awake for hours.”
    — Arius
    “Mindfulness mediation seems to corollate with worse sleep for me.”
    — Hawk 85973
    “if I meditate in the evening/before bed, my sleep gets worse because I get more energy.”
    — Tundra 73561
    “i developed later serious insomnia, hyperexctitation and uncrontallable behaviours, chest pain”
    — trollo
    “for the next 3 days I couldn't even get 3 hrs of sleep.... It was a nightmare.”
    — Silence
    “The only problem is insomnia (too much energy) if I do it late in the afternoon.”
    — wciarci
  • Nerve pain

    4 people
    “I am doing the yoga every other day as of the past week which has already made my nerve pain feel a bit weird”
    — Falcon 75740
    “but that shit doesn’t go well with me it makes me have like pins and needles so intensely in weird places like half my face and arms.”
    — Glade 92613
    Show 2 moreShow fewer
    “Passive hangs are awful for me. When I did yoga I was supposed to do them every class and although I technically could, my hands felt awful, hurt, got numb”
    — Otter 33803
    “Wim Hof gave me nerve damage and memory impairment that took a while to recover from.”
    — Mesa 70474
  • Herx / die-off reaction

    2 people
    “I did a session with a guy specialising in circular breathing, for an hour, and I had a very pronounced herx afterwards”
    — Sianrecovery
    “I'm now detoxing heavily from it.”
    — willow
  • Side effects

    114 people
    “I ended up with a small nasal drip for about a week when I started not too long ago”
    — Sandpiper 62097
    “I always get this really weird sensation in my head like it feels fuller or pressure”
    — Spruce 67561
    Show 28 moreShow fewer
    “(4-7-8 made me dizzy)”
    — Pebble 99135
    “I felt very dizzy and sick for a while from this.”
    — Moon 18770
    “That helped a lot for the pain and crushing feeling, but it did cause some spasms in my diaphragm. And those made me have thus hiccups and burping at the same time attacks.”
    — Maple 11272
    “I just tried it and got mad dizzy, so if anyone's reading this and wants to try it maybe try it slow and not a full exhale.”
    — Tulip 34883
    “using all my energy to focus on breathing makes me notice how i can’t draw a full breath (i have asthma and EDS i am Not Good At Manual Breathing) and i feel suffocated and panicky”
    — Petrel 94601
    “Gave myself a headache after 2 days, but my blood pressure has stabilised, the vertigo has stopped, the air hunger has stopped”
    — Pelican 78546
    “I had that problem back when I tried deep breathing (lightheadedness especially)”
    — Bramble 19343
    “Kargyraa is the style that I've found is most efficient at getting stuff out, but it is very intense and it can also hurt a bit.”
    — Prairie 46085
    “I get that if a breathing exercise makes me breathe in for too long.”
    — Oak 86946
    “I started doing wim hof breathing recently. Not sure if I'm doing it right tbh, it just makes me feel like I'm hyperventilating. I also feel quite light headed towards the end of the breathing round”
    — Valley 30312
    “had a weird reaction to a therapist leading me in a basic body scan meditation, don’t know if I’ve ever been so physically agitated”
    — Dew 82283
    “I’ve never found meditation to be anything other than exhausting”
    — Wave 47637
    “I've never done well with meditation or mindfulness due to ADHD and Tourette's. I can't just sit in one position and try to focus, that energy just gets pent up and bursts when it's over.”
    — Breeze 20772
    “my body also goes into alarm mode. It’s like I’m running away from a saber-toothed tiger. Usually, I end up **standing up** for a moment, drenched in sweat”
    — Nightjar 43735
    “Deep breathing can actually elevate my heart rate depending on the technique.”
    — Quail 48323
    “Every time I do relaxation exercises, ... I get those waves of nausea”
    — Hufsamor
    “My body protested, it literally felt unsafe to breathe deeply and relax”
    — Summit 24379
    “Normal breathing meditations often cause me anxiety or difficulties with breathing.”
    — Alder 56326
    “I have had something similar a few times but I always end up feeling better in a day or so and much more rested.”
    — Sequoia 81700
    “Whenever I've tried to do this, I tend to get a really nasty headache from the effort of it.”
    — Dune 42594
    “My eyes keep shaking as I do the breathing exercises. ... knows what is causing my eyes to spasm?”
    — Kestrel 79949
    “As I try to lie there and relax my muscles and breathe slowly, it’s like more and more adrenaline is being pumped out or something. My heart starts pounding and I feel panicky.”
    — Ridge 85448
    “nowadays it makes my migraines worse and makes me tired and depressed”
    — Creek 94550
    “When I did it during the fasting it was much more intense. The tingeling in fingers and tinnitus, but also the boost afterwards.”
    — Dove 17548
    “I get super lightheaded! I hate being lightheaded”
    — Rain 28969
    “If i calm it too much i get dizzy.”
    — Ridge 82949
    “I did eventually notice minor signs of hyperventilation.”
    — Iknovate
    “When i started breathwork it was just uncomfortable and it gave me nothing.”
    — Beech 32129

    The words of 30 of these 114 people.

  • Other

    37 people
    “At first it was becoming excruciating past 8 minutes of mindfullness.”
    — Comet 60796
    “I had been up to 4min previously, but this seems to be the cause of tinnitus and other damage”
    — Nightjar 85524
    Show 28 moreShow fewer
    “this was the cause of severe neck cramps before I decided to be vigilant about meditation ergonomics”
    — Bramble 19343
    “I really like the idea of meditation but I'm just so bad at it and it ends up stressing me out more”
    — Beacon 52755
    “I actually lost my voice at one point, but it came back a bit stronger I think.”
    — Prairie 46085
    “I also tried yoga but this was too hard for me”
    — Horizon 57843
    “I started with 7 reps which was a mistake because with my severe fatigue it was way too much but i forced myself”
    — Osprey 16731
    “I had been doing some meditation sitting upright which I’ll stop though because it seems to keep stress high still”
    — Plover 54715
    “I wish I could do yoga nidra, but my body goes straight into fight/flight every time.”
    — Swan 33095
    “I was dizzy after the first set of 4.”
    — Fjord 89470
    “All meditation does is set my mind ablaze thinking.”
    — Shore 13957
    “I found meditating awful which might be why it isn't restful for me”
    — Tide 36440
    “trying to meditate feels physically painful.”
    — Heron 38745
    “the time I got really into it I missed my period that month”
    — Alpine 25490
    “i’ve been retraining myself to breathe with my diaphragm, and it HURTS if i do it for too long. that muscle has been so inactive that diaphragmatic breathing for about 2 minutes makes me feel like the aftermath of hiccups”
    — Glade 13311
    “it can be hard to do sometimes because it makes coming back to upright world very painful”
    — Bluebell 51069
    “it takes a lot of energy from me. I took his online course and ended up with pneumonia twice, so be careful”
    — Sandpiper 69476
    “Meditation (or anything too slow or boring) makes me want to claw off my own skin.”
    — Valley 14716
    “It is good, but not good when used before bed. ... today I know why: choking at night”
    — Lolinda
    “Yeah… I got so hyperventilated that I fell over dizzy.”
    — Comet 32721
    “Meditation always felt super uncomfortable and impossible to stay still”
    — Acorn 83368
    “when i treated that with parasympathetic breathing i developed POTS”
    — Vale 51355
    “meditation is a terrible experience for me”
    — Spruce 54624
    “I got a disordered breathing pattern from constantly deep breathing in the beginning. It took a good month to retrain myself how to breathe correctly again.”
    — Crocus 99204
    “Meditation brought “involuntary movements” ... They were terrifying.”
    — Eagle 37662
    “I just started yesterday with the breathing exercises, they make me tired but my sleep improves.”
    — Dove 56518
    “i developed later serious insomnia, hyperexctitation and uncrontallable behaviours, chest pain”
    — trollo
    “Eventually I had a side effect that made me stop box breathing altogether. I started holding my breath all the time”
    — Alder 15789
    “It was a very painful experience to sit with (mentally).”
    — Float
    “I'm finding that I have to give up on Yoga however, because all of the twisting and squeezing of internal organs makes my kidneys extremely sore”
    — Patrick* (PWCalvin)

    The words of 30 of these 37 people.

How often it comes up

Posts that mention Meditation, yoga, breathwork, per 1,000 posts each month. Hover or tap a point for the count.

02040201020142017202020232026
MonthPosts mentioning itAll postsPer 1,000
Oct 200901050
Jan 201011417.1
Feb 2010311326.5
Jun 201111099.2
Nov 2011412432.3
Dec 201101990
Jan 2012523221.6
Feb 2012310329.1
Mar 201201900
Apr 201201620
May 201213752.7
Jun 2012623825.2
Jul 2012524020.8
Aug 2012848516.5
Sep 2012956116.0
Oct 2012752613.3
Nov 201235145.8
Dec 2012769910.0
Jan 201335335.6
Feb 201344478.9
Mar 201334297.0
Apr 20131049920.0
May 20131660626.4
Jun 2013860913.1
Jul 2013861613.0
Aug 20132057734.7
Sep 20131936452.2
Oct 2013953616.8
Nov 201323855.2
Dec 20131451927.0
Jan 20141694416.9
Feb 201488219.7
Mar 20141042523.5
Apr 20141536141.6
May 20141661725.9
Jun 201444898.2
Jul 201434446.8
Aug 20141062216.1
Sep 201455079.9
Oct 2014767810.3
Nov 2014856714.1
Dec 20141662925.4
Jan 20151276015.8
Feb 201588739.2
Mar 2015461,27636.1
Apr 20152698426.4
May 2015291,49619.4
Jun 201561,0465.7
Jul 201571,2115.8
Aug 20151599815.0
Sep 2015171,06016.0
Oct 201551,2554.0
Nov 2015131,24610.4
Dec 20151392414.1
Jan 2016211,28216.4
Feb 201661,0515.7
Mar 2016111,00211.0
Apr 201689988.0
May 2016201,04519.1
Jun 2016151,23012.2
Jul 2016231,61914.2
Aug 2016331,72919.1
Sep 2016191,78510.6
Oct 2016201,22016.4
Nov 2016271,09224.7
Dec 2016271,21122.3
Jan 2017111,6606.6
Feb 2017131,9886.5
Mar 2017142,0786.7
Apr 2017322,13315.0
May 2017212,3708.9
Jun 2017202,1949.1
Jul 2017202,1839.2
Aug 2017142,4665.7
Sep 2017142,1896.4
Oct 2017353,04211.5
Nov 2017141,9767.1
Dec 2017422,11219.9
Jan 2018502,62019.1
Feb 2018212,1559.7
Mar 2018282,61310.7
Apr 2018182,2518.0
May 2018372,82813.1
Jun 2018473,87112.1
Jul 2018453,06714.7
Aug 2018383,75710.1
Sep 2018613,51217.4
Oct 2018423,26112.9
Nov 2018302,86110.5
Dec 2018472,75417.1
Jan 2019293,6727.9
Feb 2019372,71513.6
Mar 2019403,31712.1
Apr 2019453,14114.3
May 2019593,85515.3
Jun 2019363,39210.6
Jul 2019583,31217.5
Aug 2019533,94313.4
Sep 2019534,03513.1
Oct 2019773,92219.6
Nov 2019323,5089.1
Dec 2019653,65917.8
Jan 2020594,65012.7
Feb 2020494,37411.2
Mar 2020724,47516.1
Apr 2020713,69019.2
May 2020744,54316.3
Jun 2020845,70114.7
Jul 2020876,10414.3
Aug 202012910,33312.5
Sep 202012511,95810.5
Oct 202013314,5689.1
Nov 202014516,5468.8
Dec 202020920,76410.1
Jan 202126724,56210.9
Feb 202121924,6728.9
Mar 202127829,4769.4
Apr 202125428,5098.9
May 202123225,7919.0
Jun 202128727,87110.3
Jul 202123327,2208.6
Aug 202124830,8088.0
Sep 202126430,0748.8
Oct 202122222,13210.0
Nov 202125527,7229.2
Dec 202127331,8728.6
Jan 202239742,3179.4
Feb 202232738,6978.5
Mar 202241944,3059.5
Apr 202244944,33310.1
May 202250150,5949.9
Jun 202245449,0589.3
Jul 202241753,4857.8
Aug 202242654,4557.8
Sep 202249656,9368.7
Oct 202254158,5119.2
Nov 202246359,1987.8
Dec 202254061,5768.8
Jan 202357961,0049.5
Feb 202346850,1339.3
Mar 202362459,92510.4
Apr 202355254,25110.2
May 202347357,7688.2
Jun 202352252,6799.9
Jul 202350756,4019.0
Aug 202360365,4359.2
Sep 202354861,8358.9
Oct 202352058,4198.9
Nov 202346053,6628.6
Dec 202360860,64310.0
Jan 202470371,8189.8
Feb 202470470,04510.1
Mar 202462368,2619.1
Apr 202456564,3748.8
May 202453367,6987.9
Jun 202451764,7208.0
Jul 202452665,3358.1
Aug 202455668,5178.1
Sep 202465170,1689.3
Oct 202460272,6078.3
Nov 202457371,8028.0
Dec 202461374,4018.2
Jan 202569577,9098.9
Feb 202555765,1108.6
Mar 202559069,9058.4
Apr 202553461,6068.7
May 202562065,7339.4
Jun 202554460,5409.0
Jul 202561862,10510.0
Aug 202574264,57811.5
Sep 202568661,70411.1
Oct 202573959,20412.5
Nov 202560858,94410.3
Dec 202561162,8309.7
Jan 202687863,32113.9
Feb 202662253,08511.7
Mar 202657759,2089.7
Apr 202657653,98910.7
May 202656757,5419.9
Jun 202657455,30110.4
Jul 202661256,39110.9
Aug 202664356,82511.3
Sep 202660857,14310.6

Forum and Reddit posts, 4,007,898 in all, counted per month. A mention means the post names the treatment, not that the writer took it. All trends

20 of the 9,658 people who tried it

See all 9,658 stories
  • ME/CFS at rock bottom, now much better but still often in bed with pacing

    Much better Cedar 14930 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 38 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Cedar 14930 has had ME/CFS for over 30 years, with a sudden flu-like onset, and deteriorated until hitting rock bottom around 11 years before 2020; since then they have improved but remain far from well, often spending 16–23 hours a day in bed and unable to…

  • Moderate long COVID with brain fog and PEM, somewhat better with omega-3 and pacing

    Somewhat better Otter 31595 Long COVID Moderate at worstIll 2.5 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Otter 31595, a 46-year-old man, had mild long COVID from August 2021 and moderate illness after a third COVID infection in July 2023: brain fog, breathlessness, heavy limbs and PEM. After 2.5 years of no progress he reported brain fog and breathlessness…

  • Bedbound at worst with ME/CFS after COVID, now somewhat better with pacing

    Somewhat better Vale 94777 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 4 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    A person in New Zealand became ill with COVID around mid-2022. They worsened for 14 months to severe and bedbound, and are not working. Pacing, an electric wheelchair, mast-cell and arthritis drugs, and vitamin D later brought them to mild (moderate side of…

  • Long COVID breathlessness and severe anxiety, somewhat better with low-histamine diet

    Somewhat better Hill 66692 Long COVID Moderate at worstIll 4 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Hill 66692, a woman in her late sixties, developed long COVID in October 2022 with histamine intolerance, breathlessness, severe anxiety and neuropathy. A massage three weeks after testing negative left her barely able to move, and she was largely isolated…

  • Housebound with long COVID, now much better and back at work after rest and acupuncture

    Much better Spruce 30711 Long COVID Severe at worstIll 2.5 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    An Australian academic in their forties got long COVID in May 2024 after a third infection: brain fog first, then crippling fatigue that left them housebound and crashing daily for months. Rest, time and treatments including acupuncture greatly improved…

  • Severe ME/CFS, housebound and often bedbound; walking better after physio, then relapsed

    Relapsed Pebble 29054 ME/CFS Very severe at worstIll 10 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Pebble 29054, in the UK, has suspected ME/CFS and describes a decline from mild to severe after NHS GET/CBT and exercise, now housebound and often bedbound with crashes, sleep disruption, headaches, dizziness, GI/IBS and electrolyte problems. A private…

  • Helminthic Therapy, the only thing to make a difference so far

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · Helpedbad1080 ME/CFS Moderate at worst forums.phoenixrising.me Nov 2026

    bad1080 had ME/CFS for decades and was mostly house-bound, bed-bound at worst with a Bell score of 30. Helminthic therapy, first hookworm larvae and later TSO ova, lifted them from severe to mild, with short bounces after doses, and they still dose to hold…

  • Mostly bedbound and housebound with ME/CFS, pacing and rest helped before a relapse

    Relapsed Doesn’t credit it · WorseValley 16092 ME/CFS Moderate at worstIll 25 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Valley 16092 has had ME/CFS and fibromyalgia for about 25 years; stress and lifelong health problems led to a crash from 60-hour workweeks. They never became severe but have been mostly bedbound and housebound, and pacing, rest and comorbidity medication…

  • Mostly housebound with ME/CFS, now a little better on Klonopin and low-dose naltrexone

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · Not saidValley 89571 ME/CFS Moderate at worstIll 3 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Joseph, 47, in Los Angeles, developed ME/CFS in January 2024, about 18 days after a second COVID infection. He declined from mild to the bad end of moderate over six months, becoming mostly housebound. Klonopin, low-dose naltrexone, midodrine and propranolol…

  • Long COVID brain fog, somewhat better with nicotine patch and naltrexone

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · HelpedPebble 25278 Long COVID Mild at worst reddit.com Oct 2026

    Pebble 25278 developed long COVID with brain fog, distorted smell, headaches, nerve pain and trouble sleeping. A quarter of a 10 mg nicotine patch restored much of their speech and thinking, and low-dose naltrexone further raised their cognitive and physical…

  • Almost bedridden with ME/CFS, now much better after a specialist regimen and pacing

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · HelpedFox 20038 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 6.5 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    A California woman infected with COVID in March 2020 was sick six months, partly recovered, then relapsed and was almost bedridden by early 2023, unable to drive and sensitive to light and noise. An out-of-pocket ME/CFS specialist regimen of LDN, Abilify,…

  • Bedbound with ME/CFS, now housebound and somewhat better with rest and low-dose naltrexone

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · HelpedMaple 86872 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 18 months before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    After about 1.5 years of ME/CFS with push–crash cycles, they became bedbound for two months in mid-2026, getting up only for the bathroom. They improved slowly with four months of rest, low-dose naltrexone, a beta-blocker, compression and salt/fluids. By…

  • Mostly bedbound with ME/CFS, now somewhat better with pacing and POTS medication

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · HelpedZephyr 59478 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 3 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    A man in Australia became ill about two years ago after stress, surgery and a viral infection; he deteriorated to severe within about a year and was diagnosed with CFS. Mostly bedbound and unable to work, he credits pacing, CBD with micro-dose THC, red meat…

  • Long COVID with POTS and brain fog, improved then relapsed, now mostly housebound

    Relapsed Doesn’t credit it · HelpedGlade 14161 Long COVID Severe at worstIll 4 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    A teenager developed POTS, vertigo and brain fog after COVID in 2022, then had a near two-year remission. A reinfection in late 2024 left her disabled, and further infections plus a decline into ME-type crashes with light and sound sensitivity made her…

  • ME/CFS very severe and bedbound, still extremely severe; lorazepam, magnesium helped sleep

    No benefit Doesn’t credit it · HelpedHill 82091 ME/CFS Very severe at worstIll for 4 years reddit.com Oct 2026

    After two years of mild symptoms only after sport, Hill 82091 declined from mild to very severe over about five months after starting a job in late 2025. A chiropractic neck adjustment in February 2026 took them from moderate to severe. They became fully…

  • Bedridden 3.5 months with ME/CFS, improved with pacing and CoQ10, then relapsed

    Relapsed Doesn’t credit it · No changeStream 14072 ME/CFS Very severe at worstIll 1 year before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    The user became ill in late 2025 after a CNS crash from bipolar-related stress, stimulant use and a lamotrigine dose increase, and was bedridden for 3.5 months with constant pressure headaches. Pacing and CoQ10 helped them improve; they were able to walk up…

  • Bedbound with ME/CFS for over a year, now partly better with pacing and LDN

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · HelpedPrairie 49039 ME/CFS Very severe at worstIll 4.5 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    A Dutch long-hauler became ill with COVID in mid-2022 and was bedbound, in bed around the clock, for over a year. Rest and pacing, a 75% vegetable diet that fixed their gut, NAC for brain fog, LDN for PEM and ivabradine for POTS brought slow, partial gains.…

  • Mostly bedbound with ME/CFS, now somewhat better with fludrocortisone and beta blockers

    Somewhat better Doesn’t credit it · HelpedKestrel 92313 ME/CFS Severe at worstIll 15 years before improving or writing reddit.com Oct 2026

    Kestrel 92313 had ME/CFS for about 15 years, mild at first and severe/mostly bedbound (90–95% bedbound) by early 2026. Fludrocortisone, beta blockers, salt and fluids for POTS were part of measures giving about 10% improvement, and they remained severe and…

  • wabi-sabi on Phoenix Rising

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · Helped ME/CFS Very severe at worstIll 8.5 years before improving forums.phoenixrising.me Oct 2026

    wabi-sabi fell ill after a viral infection in May 2014, stayed mild until an exercise crash in 2018 made her moderate, and declined to very severe by 2022. Mestinon and later mast cell drugs (cromolyn, ketotifen, xolair, LDN) improved her; a COVID infection…

  • Unable to function for six months with long COVID, much better after resting

    Much better Doesn’t credit it · HelpedMaple 47021 Long COVID Severe at worst reddit.com Oct 2026

    They described being unable to function for six months, sleeping all day for three of them and not working. Resting as much as possible helped, and they slowly improved to almost full-time work hours, though they still got spells. They later reported…

These are the newest 6 of the 2,890 who credit Meditation, yoga, breathwork for their improvement, then the newest 14 of the 6,768 who tried it without crediting it, in about the same proportion as the full list.

A little hope, every Sunday

New recovery stories and data-driven research on ME/CFS and long COVID. Ideas worth considering, and the evidence behind them.

Free · Unsubscribe anytime